Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 with the box it comes in. Inside the box are the lens, the end caps and a lenshood.

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN lens was introduced in April 2023 for APS-C cameras in Sony E, Leica L, Fujifilm X and Canon RF mounts and currently sells for $750 AUD. The focal length gives a full frame equivalent of 35mm and it joins the 16, 30, and 56mm lenses which means that there are now f1.4 primes in 24, 35, 45, and 85mm full frame equivalent focal lengths. I’m looking at the Sony E mount version which I bought in May 2024 primarily to use for video mounted to my Sony A6500. I’ve only recently started using it as a general purpose walk around lens.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 with the Sony A6500 camera.

 


Vital Statistics

 

Mount Sony E, Leica L, Fujifilm X, and Canon RF
Lens Construction 13 elements in 10 groups with 3 Special Low Dispersion glass and 2 aspherical elements
Angle of View 63.4º
Number of Diaphragm Blades 9 rounded blades
Minimum Aperture  f16
Minimum Focusing Distance 25cm
Maximum Magnification Ratio 1:7.3
Filter Size 52mm
Dimensions 65.8mm ⦰ x 78.9mm (h)
Weight 330g for Sony E mount version
Supplied Accessories Petal shaped lens hood

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN is part of Sigma’s Contemporary line which means it has a utilitarian plastic body (or as Sima prefers to call it a Thermally Stable Composite). The only external control on the lens is the ribbed focusing ring which is of the “fly by wire type”. The lens is advertised as being dust and splash proof, but the only sealing is at the lens mount where there is an “O” ring seal. The lens mount itself is chromium plated brass for longevity. It is still good to see this as other manufacturers are tending to use plastic mounts on their budget lenses. The lens is supplied with a plastic petal shaped lens hood which feels very well made and it attaches by a bayonet fitting to the lens. It feels secure and well made.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The only weather sealing is the rubber “o” ring on the lens mount.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The petal shaped lenshood supplied with the lens is well designed and made. Thoughtful touches are the ribbing on the exterior to facilitate a firm grip when attaching and detaching it from the elns. The interior is also ribbed to prevent light bouncing off it and into the lens.

 

Physically the Sigma 23mm is quite a large lens. Not as big as the Sigma 16mm f1.4, but bigger than the Sony 28mm f2 and Sony 50mm f1.8. The weight of the lens is 330g – the Sony E mount version is the lightest at 330g and the Canon RF is the heaviest at 345g – and it contributes to the lens having a satisfying heft in the hand. The whole thing is well put together with no dodgy looking seams in the composite body or creaking and flexing when you give it a squeeze. While not part of Sigma’s more premium Art and Sports lines the Sigma 23mm feels a quality piece of kit. 

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 while being a fairly chunky lens is smaller that the Sigma 16mm f1.4.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
When compared to the Sony 28mm f2 and 50mm f1.8 you can see the Sigma 23mm is quite a chunky beast.

 

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 mounted on the Sony A6500 camera.

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN has an optical construction of 13 elements in 10 groups with 3 Super Low Dispersion (SLD) elements to reduce transverse chromatic aberration and 2 aspherical elements to provide correction of spherical aberration and field curvature. The diaphragm sports 9 rounded blades and while not having the eleven blades that the Art Series primes have this does produce nice bokeh effects – more about which later. The minimum focusing distance is 25cm measured from the sensor plane which gives a maximum magnification ratio of 1:7.3.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The minimum focus distance is 25cm, which is measured from the sensor plane, and gives a maximum magnification ratio of 1:7.3.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 


Optical Performance

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

I must say I was quite impressed with the optical performance of the Sigma 23mm f1.4. Wide open the centre is sharp and the corners are a tiny bit softer and have less contrast. Stop down to f2 and things significantly improve. The centre gets even sharper and there is more contrast and the corners now match the centre. Quite something. This performance stays constant until f11 where diffraction starts to set in and the image softens.

Chromatic Aberration

  • Axial chromatic aberration, also known as longitudinal chromatic aberration is present when the lens is wide open, but it is very well controlled and barely noticeable. Stopping down fixes the problem.
  • Transverse or lateral chromatic aberration is present, but it is very slight and you really have to pixel peep to find it or turn off the lens profile.

There is some very slight barrel distortion present, but you have to turn off the built in lens profile to really see it.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
With the lens profile turned off the barrel distortion is visible. Switching the profile on reduces it rather than totally eliminating it.

 

When it comes to flare and diffraction spikes it is a bit of a mixed bag. The good is that there is no evidence of any veiling flare. Polygonal shapes and light streaks are visible. The diffraction spikes or sun stars are quite nice and defined.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
Reflected glare in the form of polygonal shapes and light streaks are evident at smaller apertures. The diffraction spikes or sun stars are quite nice and defined.

 

The nine curved diaphragm blades produce nice clean bokeh balls with no evidence of the soap bubble effect or onion rings at the centre of the frame when wide open. At the edges they take on a more elliptical shape. At f2.8 and beyond the circles start to take on a more polygonal shape. The rendering of the out of focus areas and the tonal transitions are beautifully smooth.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
Bokeh balls at f1.4. The are round at the centre of the frame and change to a more eliptical shape at the edges. There is no soap bubble effect and there are no onion rings.

 

 


Autofocus Performance

 

Sigma23AFtest

 

The complexity of modern autofocus systems in mirrorless cameras means that much will depend upon the AF settings you have made on your camera. A casing point is that when testing this lens on my A6500 the initial results looked very poor. So poor in fact that I put the lens on my A7r2 in APS-C mode and repeated them and the results were like night and day. A quick examination of the A6500’s menu found that I had previously been experimenting with the AF settings and hadn’t put them back to how they were. Once restored it was like looking at a totally different camera and lens combination.

Shooting stills I tested the lens by walking towards the camera with continuous AF set and the lens easily kept up with my movement. It was only when I got close up that there was any sign of hesitancy, but it still managed to find focus. Averaging out several test runs I was getting a hit rate of 93% with critical focus and 7% with acceptable focus. An impressive result.

Shooting video the results weren’t as positive and the lens had trouble keeping up with me as the target. But, when I mounted Gary the Galah to a slider and set it to a 10 second run while close to the camera the AF was very sticky and accurate.I would expect that the A6700 with its more sophisticated subject tracking AF system would yield a better result here. Focus pulls using touch to focus were very decisive with no overt hunting.

While we are talking about focusing I looked at the focus breathing it was very evident.

 


Verdict

Well after using the Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN for a year I can say that I have found it be a very capable lens. For video it is near perfect for filming talking head pieces for YouTube – which is what I mainly use it for. For photography it is a great carry around lens suitable for street photography and urban landscapes. I’d happily travel with it as my only lens as well. Does it have any short comings? Well if I were to nitpick some people might find that the lens makes the camera a little front heavy. It doesn’t bother me in the slightest, but these sorts of things can be a deal breaker for some.

Who should buy it? Well that depends upon which camera ecosystem you’re in. If you have an APS-C Canon RF camera and want a fast moderately wide lens then this is your only choice. For Sony and Fujifilm owners it is a little more nuanced. Both manufactures have their own version of this lens. Sony has the Zeiss 24mm f1.8 which retails for $1500 AUD. It can focus a little closer but has a slower maximum aperture and is getting a little long in the tooth. Fujifilm has two competitors. The XF 23mm f1.4 R LM WR lens which retails for $1500 AUD which has better close focusing and superior weather sealing. Then there is the XF 23mm F2 R WR at $640 which also focuses closer, has better weather sealing and is cheaper while having a slower maximum aperture. If you want a fast maximum aperture at a reasonable price then the Sigma can’t be beat.

 


Sample Images

 

2025 York Motor Cycle Festival

 

2025 York Motor Cycle Festival

 

20240522-Mundaring-0226-Edit

 

20240522-Mundaring-0227-Edit

 

20240612-Frida-0224-Edit

 

20250405-York-0227-Edit

 

20250405-York-0233-Edit

 

20250405-York-0234-Edit

 

20250405-York-0242-Edit

 

20250406-York-0225-Edit

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 makes for a excellent lens for architectural studies.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Nisin MF18 Macro Flash

 

The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.

 

Before we get going I’m going to be a little bit pedantic. The Nissan MF18 Macro flash is not and I repeat NOT a ring flash. A ring flash such as the Profoto ProRing2 Plus UV has a continuous light tube that forms a circle. The MF18 has two separate flash heads (A + B) in two semicircular diffusers.

 

The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.with the flash heads positioned at their widest setting.This also shows that the head is comprised of two separate flash tubes in their own semi-circular diffusers.

 

What I’m looking at in this review is the Nissan MF18 for Sony cameras. This is important because the features and the included accessories vary somewhat depending on whether you have the Sony, Canon or Nikon models. Also while this unit is capable of wireless control I didn’t have the where withal to test that as I don’t own a suitable controller.

 


TLDR

 


Specifications

The MF18 is compatible with the following flash protocols:-

Canon ETTL and ETTL ii

Nikon i-TTL

Sony ADI/P-TTL

Having said that some cameras from Sony, Canon and Nikon aren’t compatible.

Canon:-

1dx mk ii, 5d mk iv, 6d mk ii, 80d, 900d, 1d, 1ds, and all the EOS M series of cameras.

Nikon:-

D2Hs, D2H, D100, D1H, D1. Firmware updates are required to ensure compatibility with the Z series cameras, the D6 and the Zfc.

Sony:-

RX100 mk ii

For Sony cameras the wireless strobe will not fire unless the flash mode is set to [WL(wireless)] in the camera menu or the wireless flash function is set to [ON].

Guide Number (GN) 16/53 (ISO 100 m/ft)
Flash output 83 Ws at full power
Power Source Internal – 4 x AA alkaline/Ni-MH batteries

External 

Nisin PS300 battery pack

Nikon SD-8a or SD-9 battery pack

Canon CP-E4 battery pack

Battery Life (approx.) AA batteries 120-800 flashes

Nisin PS300 500 flashes

Nikon Sd-8a or SD-9 200 flashes

Canon CP-E4 260 flashes

Recycling time 0.1-5.5 seconds with AA batteries

0.7 sec with the Nisin PS300

1.5 sec with the Nikon SD-8a/SD-9

1.5 sec with the Canon CP-E4

Colour Temperature  5600 K at full power
Flash duration 1/700 sec at full power when using both flash heads and 1/300 sec when using one.
Wireless flash Optical system relying of line of sight only
Sync Hot shoe or PC sync
Modes of operation Auto, TTL, full manual (power ranges from full to 1/64 in 1/6th increments) and fine macro (1/128 to 1/1024 in 1/6th increments).

1st curtain sync

2nd curtain sync

High speed flash sync (dependent on whether the camera allows this).

Dimensions Body 115 x 65 x 85mm

Head 120 x 134 x 41mm

Weight 446g without batteries
Included accessories Adapter rings to mount the flash head to the lens.

For Canon and Nikon 52, 58, 62, 67, 72, and 77mm.

For Sony 49, 55, 62, 67, 72, and 77mm. 

It is possible to buy adapter rings individually in all sizes from 49mm to 82mm.


First Impressions

The box the Nissin MF18 comes in.

 

The contents of the box. The flash body and head plus 6 adapter rings. The sizes of the included rings depends upon on whether your camera is Sony, or Canon/Nikon.

 

The quick start guide printed on the inside of the box lid.

 

I don’t normally talk about packaging but in this case I’ll make an acceptation. The box and its overall presentation were very nice – almost “Applesque” – and showed nice attention to detail which I thought boded well for the flash itself. Overall the MF18 feels very well made. Like all flashguns/speedlights it is of a plastic construction. There is no mention of any weather sealing on the Nisin website so I’ll assume there is none. The body is connected to the head via a chunky coiled cable that feels nice and secure at both ends. In the case of problems with the cord it doesn’t look user replaceable but this is not unusual. The batteries are held in a magazine that slides out of the side. It is a very neat arrangement and spares are available (Nisin BM-01) for those who want a fast reload capability. The flash body is held in the camera hot shoe via blue anodised knurled ring. Not as fast as a lever that is sometimes found on other brands but perfectly satisfactory. On the rear of the body you’ll find a 3cm square colour LCD panel which is sadly not touch compatible. I really like the touch capabilities on my Metz flashes and it is a shame Nisin didn’t include it. Underneath the screen you’ll find an on/off/lock switch, a four way ‘D’ pad with central button, and a combined pilot and status indicator light/button. On the flash head are four buttons – the two vertical ones release the head from the adapter runs, and the two horizontal  allow the flash tubes to positioned further out. This prevents vignetting and also allows more even lighting over some larger subjects.

 

The rear of the MF18. The A and B buttons allow the flash head to open up to prevent vignetting and provide a wider coverage.

 

 

Overall everything is very confidence inspiring.

 


Performance

Nissin claim that the MF18 has a Guide Number of 16 (ISO 100 in metres). Here the subject is 1m from the camera sensor, the power has been set 1/64 and the aperture set to f2. As we can see the photo is approx two stops under exposed. Also Nissin claim that the white balance of the flash is 5600K. The camera white balance was set to 5600K and this resulted in warm cast.

 

Nisin quote a Guide Number (GN) 16 (ISO100 m) but my testing has found this to rather fanciful as you can see from the table below:

Power setting GN per Nisin Measured
full 16 6.9
1/2 11.3 4.9
1/4 8 3.6
1/8 5.6 2.7
1/16 4 1.9
1/32 2.8 1.5
1/64 2 1.4
1/128 1.4 N/A

The measured guide numbers are between 2 and 21/3 of a stop lower than Nisin’s figures which is quite disappointing. The only positive I can say about it is that running the test 3 times the measured results were very consistent. 

I measured the colour temperature using a grey card and setting the camera’s white balance to 5600K and found that the actual colour temperature was 4750K.

Checking recycling times using a fresh set of AA Ni-MH batteries saw recycle times average out at 8.9 sec when shooting at full power and 4.55 sec at 1/2 power. This falls short of Nisin’s claimed figures.


In Use

 

York Sun Orchid by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
York Sun Orchid, Thelymitra yorkensis. Wandoo National Park, Western Australia. Using high speed synchronisation means I can overpower the sun and render backgrounds dark while illuminating the flower.

OK testing is one thing how does real world performance stack up. I’ve been using the MF18 since August 2021 on a Sony A7r2. The only manual shooting I’ve done with it is just testing it for this review. The rest of the time I use it in TTL mode for photographing flowers. More often than not I use it in high speed sync mode as well so I can have the flash as my key light and the ambient light as my fill. For this it has worked extremely well.

 

York Golf Course by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Shy sun orchid, Thelymitra graminea. York Golf Course, Western Australia.

 

Operating the MF18 is simplicity itself. The basic functions are controlled by the camera. The only time I have to go into the menu is select high speed sync. You can also select 1st or 2nd curtain flash there as well. It is so easy to use that I really don’t have to think about it

 

The MF18 control menu.

 

The menu for selecting advanced features such as second curtain sync power saving modes etc.

 


Conclusion

Pros Cons
  • High speed flash synch
  • Simple to use
  • Fine macro mode allows power output down to 1/1024 power
  • A spare battery magazine is available (Nisin BM-01 and it costs approx $20 USD
  • Can be powered from the mains
  • Can be powered by Canon and Nikon external battery packs
  • Firmware can upgraded via a USB port
  • No case provided – other brands I’ve used provided a case
  • Only a limited range of adapter rings supplied in the box and while the rings are available as separate items they are quite pricey at $30 USD each.
  • Compatibility issues with certain models of camera
  • No weather sealing
  • GN not accurate
  • Colour temperature not accurate

 

The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.viewed in profile.

 

I bought the Nisin MF18 with my own money. At the time it was the only macro speedlight compatible with Sony that had high speed flash synchronisation. While some of the performance issues such as the GN, recycling times and colour temperature are a bit disappointing they have had no impact on how I use the flash. 

 

The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.viewed from the rear.

 

In terms of value for money, compared to the Olympus and Metz equivalents it seems quite keenly priced. It is better specified than the Metz unit but doesn’t have the overall flexibility and the weather sealing of the Olympus. 

 

Blue China Orchid by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Blue China Orchid, Cyanicula gemmata. Wandoo National Park, Western Australia.

 

Would I recommend it? Well if you are just going to use it as I do and are happy with the compatibility issues then yes I would. But if you are still using cameras such as the Canon 5d vi or the 6d ii then I would look elsewhere.

Variations On A Theme

I’ve thinking about variable neutral density filters a lot lately. When I started to get a bit more interested in video I decided to invest in a good Variable Neutral Density filter and as I’d always bought B+W filters I bought a B+W 77mm XS-Pro Digital ND Vario MRC-Nano Filter. It was beautifully made in Germany with a brass frame and hard stops. It didn’t offer anything spectacular in terms of range just 1 to 5 stops but it was very good. Unfortunately I was filming a waterfall and slipped on the rock and went into the river. I ended up with a week in hospital with septicaemia and the filter was smashed. I was unable to get a replacement so bought a Cokin NUANCES NDX 2-400 Filter which was considerably cheaper, not as well made but the images were good. Over time I decided I missed the hard stops and so as the B+W was still unavailable in Australia bought a Heliopan variable grey neutral density ND 0.3 – ND 1.8 filter which has served me very well. 

Recently I decided that I wanted a new one in 95mm size. Normally I’d buy the best quality one and be done with it, but this time I was unprepared to spend that eye watering amount for what just amounts to an experiment. Looking online I saw there is a huge variation in prices and I couldn’t help but wonder whether paying more actually meant a better quality filter. So I’m looking at four filters and the price range goes from $24 AUD to $350 AUD. I’ll look at whether they impact image quality, whether they are prone to flare and whether they effect autofocus performance.


Testing Methodology 

Colour casts produced by the filters at their minimum and maximum settings. Click on the image to see larger.

For all the tests the same camera and lens were used – a Sony A7r2 with Sony FE 50mm f1.8 lens. Although the filters are different sizes I used step up rings to fit the filters to the lens. To test for image sharpness and colour casts the camera was set on a tripod in front of a lens resolution chart so it filled the frame. The chart was lit with an LED light set to 5600K and then a custom white balance was set with no filter on the lens and an image was taken which was the control. Each filter was then tested at its minimum and maximum density.

The effects of the filters on image sharpness at their maximum and minimum settings. Click on the image to see larger.

 

For the video AF test the Sony A7r2 and 50mm lens were used again while with the stills AF test I was so surprised with the results that I also tested with the Olympus EM 1 mk ii and the the Olympus 25mm f1.8 just to make sure. I ran control tests for both camera and lens combinations to provide a baseline with which to compare. In the stills test both cameras without filters attained a 100% in focus rate.

The glare test was done with just the Sony A7r2 and the 50mm lens.

 

Testing for lens flare with no filter

TLDR

 

 


Fotga

Fotgar Fader Adjustable Variable 52mm ND Lens Filter ND2 to ND400

 

Fotga ND2-ND400 Adjustable Neutral Density Filter is the cheapest filter on test costing around $24 AUD on EBay for a 77mm filter. Interestingly Fotga state on their website:

“Image quality may drop when focal length above 200mm. It may not be suitable for a wide-angle lens <24mm,35mm film format equivalent.”

The filter is made from an unspecified Japanese optical glass and there is no mention of any coatings. The frame is made out of aluminium and has a satin black finish. There are no hard stops but there is a scale indicating where the minimum and maximum effect occurs. The filters are made in China and come in a flimsy rectangular hard plastic case.

 

Fotgar Fader Adjustable Variable 52mm ND Lens Filter ND2 to ND400

 

Certainly this filter has an effect on image sharpness it decreased sharpness and contrast of the tested 50mm lens the most. At the minimum density setting there was a definite reduction in contrast and sharpness which deteriorated even further at maximum density setting. It also had a pronounced colour cast.

 

The Fotga filter is the cheapest on test but the aluminium frame appears to be as well made as the filters from Cokin and Urth.

 

When testing the video autofocusing the Fotga produced the worst result – the AF was as snappy or confident and the image was decidedly soft. Shooting a burst of still images images  the Fotga filter only achieved an in focus rate of 67% and the images were all low in contrast, very soft and showed glare. Speaking of glare when testing for it specifically the Fotga produced the worst result exhibiting veiling and ghosting flare and strong halation around the light source.

 

 


Urth  

Urth 95mm ND2-400 (1-8.6 Stop) Variable ND Lens Filter

 

The Urth Variable ND2-400 (1-8.65 Stop) Filter is the next cheapest filter costing $82 AUD for a 77mm filter. Urth state on their web site that the filter is not suitable for use on wide angle lenses stating:

“For wide-angle lenses, we recommend our Variable ND2-32, ND8-128, ND64-1000 or fixed ND filters.”

Urth also state that filter has eight layers of coatings to make it easier to clean but no mention of whether they improve optical quality. They also claim that there are no colour casts which unfortunately is not true, but on the positive side there was no impact on image sharpness at the minimum setting and a slight reduction in sharpness at the maximum setting.

 

The Urtth variable neutral density filter has an aluminium alloy frame and hard stops.

 

About the type of glass used the website says: 

“Japanese AGC optical glass is coated with an 8-layer nano-coating “

The frame is aluminium and finished in matte black. There are hard stops at each end of the adjustment range with a scale marked showing maximum and minimum. Out of all the filters on test the Urth has the nicest presentation being supplied in a circular metal tin with a screw on lid and it was the only filter to be supplied with a lens cleaning cloth. To make you feel even better about your purchase Urth say they will plant 5 trees with every purchase. Urth are an Australian company but the filters are made in China.

 

Urth 95mm ND2-400 (1-8.6 Stop) Variable ND Lens Filter

 

When shooting video the Urth filter had no visible effect on the autofocus, but strangely enough did on the stills performance achieving an 80% hit rate. For the glare test it shared the best performance with the Cokin filter.

 

 


Cokin

 

Cokin NUANCES Variable Neutral Density 2-400 (1-8 Stops) Screw-in Camera Filter

 

The Cokin NUANCES NDX 2-400 – 77mm Filter comes in at $176 AUD for the 77mm size tested. Cokin put out a very helpful information sheet which clearly states that they do not recommend its use on lenses shorter that 24mm (full frame). Interestingly they specifically talk about the “Maltese Cross” phenomenon which occurs when you try to get the maximum density. This varies depending upon the focal length of the lens and limits the amount of density you can use. To get the full 8 2/3 stops lenses longer than 45mm should be used. A focal length of 35mm gives you 6 1/3 stops and 24mm gives 5 1/3 stops. 

 

 

In terms of the optical construction the Cokin filter is made of “Schott Glass B270, renowned for its high transmittance and low reflection”. They state that the filter is coated but not with how many coats. The frame is made of aluminium with a matte black finish and it has a series of dot markings with min at one end and max at the other. The dots don’t correspond with any particular effect. The filter comes in a round hard plastic case that is hinged. It doesn’t feel particularly sturdy and I find it quite awkward to open. Although the packaging states it is designed in France there is no indication as to where the filter was made. As Cokin was acquired by Hoya in 2000, which is part of the Kenko Tokina group, which makes filters in both the Philippines and Japan it would be a fairly safe assumption that the Cokin filters would be.

 

Cokin NUANCES Variable Neutral Density 2-400 (1-8 Stops) Screw-in Camera Filter

 

 

Tested performance shows no effect on image sharpness at both the minimum and maximum settings and a very slight cast. The Cokin filter performed very strongly in the video autofocus test showing effect on performance or image quality. The stills performance was the second best at 82% and the results in the glare test were joint best.

 


Heliopan

Heliopan Variable (1 to 6 Stops) ND Filter

 

The Heliopan variable grey neutral density ND 0.3 – ND 1.8 filter cost $350 AUD for the 77mm size tested. Heliopan are the least forthcoming about the effect of variable NDs stating:

“Depending on the focal length of the lens this filter is not recommended for use with very wide angle lenses.”

The Heliopan variable neutral density filter is the only one on test that has a brass frame. It is also one of only two that have hard stops to limit the amount of adjustment.

 

But having said that you shouldn’t be having too many problems as the filter has hard stops to prevent running into the “Maltese cross” phenomenon. They claim the use of Schott glass but make no mention of any coatings. The frame is made in Germany of brass with a matte black finish to avoid reflections and has hard stops at each end of the adjustment range plus a numerical scale marked from 1-12 but the numbers don’t correspond to any ND value. The filter comes in a square hard plastic case that is hinged and it is quite sturdy.

Heliopan Variable (1 to 6 Stops) ND Filter

 

The tested performance was similar to that of the Cokin a slight colour cast ( although different from the Cokin) and no effect on image sharpness.  For the video AF there was no impact on the focus performance and no effect on the image quality.For the stills AF the heliopan was the best performer with a score of 86%. Interestingly it was not an equal performance across both cameras. On the Sony it achieved a score of 78% and the Olympus 94%. I’m really at a loss to explain why there is such as discrepancy with the results and I had to test several times to confirm it. The Heliopan didn’t do very well in the glare test exhibiting pronounced veiling and ghosting flare. It wasn’t as bad as the Fotga but it was significantly worse than the Urth and the Cokin.

 

 


Conclusion

 

For filters that don’t have hard stops, like this Cokin, if you apply too much filtration you get this cross pattern.

 

Before I started testing I definitely believed that you got what you paid for. I fully expected the Fotga filter to be the worst performer and the Heliopan the best leaving the Cokin and Urth filters to battle for second and third places. Well I only got part of it right. The Fotga was definitely the worst performing filter of the bunch. Its only redeeming feature is the price – it’s incredibly cheap. The real surprise was that the Heliopan while being marginally the best performer wasn’t delivering any significant improvement over the Cokin which cost half the amount. The Urth filter was a very solid performer. Their 77mm is half the price of the Cokin yet delivered a result that was only a fraction worse – probably undetectable in real world use. Yet the filter has hard stops and is more nicely made and presented. For a little more, $44 AUD to be precise, the Urth Filter Plus+ might be a very good buy having the benefit of the better Schott glass, but that is conjecture as I’ve not used one.

A key takeaway is that to get the best possible image quality you have to set your custom white white balance with the filter on. All the filters produce some degree of colour cast despite what the manufacturers claim. All the filters are prone to flare so I would recommend the use of a lens hood. Lens hoods and variable NDs are problematic as the filters prevent the use of the ones designed for the lens. I now use a matt box when shooting outside and it has made a surprising difference.

To sum up, well if I needed to start again I wouldn’t waste my money on the Heliopan. The Cokin would be my choice if I could live without hard stops and the Urth would be it if I couldn’t.

Tamron 20mm f2.8 Di III Lens Review

The Tamron 20mm f2.8 lens for Sony E mount cameras was announced back in November 2019 as part of a trio of prime lenses which share the same exterior design, construction, size, filter diameter and f stop. The other lens being the 24 and 35 mm. I reviewed the 35mm f2.8 back in June 2021 and was quite impressed with it.


TLDR


Vital Statistics

 

 

Focal Length 20mm
Maximum Aperture F2.8
Angle of View (diagonal) 94º30’
Optical Construction 10 elements in 9 groups with 3 low dispersion lens elements and 1moulded glass aspherical element.
Minimum Object Distance 11cm or 4.3 inches
Magnification Ratio 1:2
Filter Size 67mm
Dimensions (h) 64mm (2.5 inches) x ⌀ 73mm ( 2.9 inches)
Weight 220g (7.8 oz)
Number of Diaphragm Blades 7 curved blades
Accessories included lens hood
Available Mounts Sony E

Build Quality

The Tamron 20mm is pretty much the same design and build quality as the 24 and 35. They are all the same length and diameter. They all have the same filter diameter of 67mm. Weight wise the 20mm is the heaviest at 220g and the 35mm is the lightest at 210g. All three have the same magnification ratio of 1:2. So Tamron has worked very hard to ensure that uniformity is carried throughout this line of lenses. It will be interesting to see if they introduce longer lenses like an 85mm how they carry that out. When compared to my Canon EF 20mm f2.8  the Tamron is only a smidge smaller and lighter which is quite surprising as the Canon is a retrofocus design built to accommodate the larger lens flange distance of 44mm compared to the 18mm of the Sony. 

The body is made out of some form of engineering plastic and the lens mount appears to be chrome plated brass which is nice. There is an “o” ring which provides some semblance of sealing from the elements at the mount. There is no other weather sealing and no indication as to the level of sealing and Tamron on their website just say that it has a “Moisture-Resistant Construction”. Tamron also claim that the front lens element has a fluorine coating which is dirt resistant. The only control on the lens is the ribbed focus ring which is of the fly-by-wire type and it has no hard stops or any form of tactile feedback when turning it. Bad news if you want to do manual video focus pulls. The lens comes with a petal shaped lens hood that bayonets into place.

 


Optical Performance

Tamron on their website say “The expert arrangement of the LD and GM specialised glass elements greatly controls aberrations, including chromatic aberrations. Tamron’s proprietary BBAR (Broad-Band Anti-Reflection) Coating reduces ghosting and flare, which can otherwise occur when taking a photo against the sun.” When shooting with the camera’s lens correction function enabled “it delivers, throughout the frame, high resolution performance that maximises the benefits of the latest high-megapixel cameras”. So let’s see how those claims stack up to real world usage.

With no lens profile applied there is massive barrel distortion on the Tamron 20mm f2.8 Di III at f5.6.

Let’s deal with the whopping great elephant in the room. This lens has very profound barrel distortion, but for jpg shooters an inbuilt lens profile minimises the effect. For RAW shooters Adobe has made a lens profile available for Lightroom and Camera RAW.

When we look at the uncorrected image and look at the rulers on the bottom and the side we can see that it is 47.4 cm in width and 29.5 cm in height. Compare that to the corrected image which is 43.7cm by 28.3cm. So in percentage terms that is a 7.2% reduction in width and a 4.2% reduction in height. This means that with the lens profile applied the lens effectively becomes a 22mm. But if you shoot video with electronic stabilisation the image is cropped again and it will give an angle of view similar to that of a 24mm lens. So if video is important to you and you want an angle of view given by a 20mm lens then you either get a lens that doesn’t suffer from as much distortion or you get a wider lens  – somewhere around 16-18mm.

So in real terms how bad is the distortion? Well comparing the Tamron, which is a very modern design to the Olympus OM Zuiko 21mm f3.5 released in 1984 and the Canon EF 20mm f2.8 USM from 1992 we can see that the Tamron has considerably worse distortion. This is very surprising as the two older lenses are retrofocus designs. SLRs have a big flippy flappy mirror between the lens and the film/sensor and this meant in the early days of SLR photography making wide angle lenses impossible  because the rear lens element would foul the mirror. The breakthrough came  in 1950 when Pierre Angénieux invented the retrofocus lens which is a  kind of “reverse” telephoto design where the lens elements closest to the film plane have a negative effect making the image smaller. The downsides are more glass elements which means more air to glass surfaces which means more refraction which means more potential chromatic aberration and distortion. So the fact that the Canon and Olympus lenses have a better performance with their compromised design is saying something.

Slight barrel distortion on the Olympus OM Zuiko 21mm f3.5 lens at f5.6.

 

Slight barrel distortion on the Canon EF 20mm f2.8 lens at f5.6.

In terms of lateral chromatic aberration the Tamron 20mm shows mild CA in the corners and edges which is very slight when uncorrected and virtually invisible when the profile is applied. Wide open there is longitudinal chromatic aberration present – cyan and magenta fringing on the out of focus edges – but this is easily fixed by stopping down. Vignetting is quite apparent without the lens profile, but when it is applied it is a non issue.

Specular light sources in the frame or just outside it can cause ghosting and flare.

 

Using the supplied lens hood reduces the incidence of len flare.

When it comes to flare resistance, well extreme wide angles lenses are very prone to the effects of flare and don’t necessarily have to have a specular light source in the frame to cause it. The Tamron handles it reasonably well but is prone to veiling and ghosting flare. The lens comes with a lens hood and it would be wise to use all the time and it does a reasonably good job of reducing the incidence of flare. The seven aperture blades produce sunstars or diffraction spikes that are a bit messy and not very pleasant – although this is a matter of personal taste.

The sunstars or diffraction spikes are a little on the messy side.

 

The bokeh balls produced by the Tamron 20mm f2.8 Di III lens wide open at f2.8.

 

A close up of the bokeh balls showing the shape deformity and the onion ring artefacts.

 

The bokeh produces nice tonal transitions in the out of focus areas.

The bokeh balls aren’t very attractive, they have a very pronounced onion ring effect and even the balls at the centre of the image have a slightly elliptical shape and this gets more apparent towards the edge of the image. While you don’t necessarily buy a 20mm lens for its bokeh it is important on this lens because of its close focusing capabilities. When we look at real world examples we can see the tonal transitions in the out of focus areas are nice and smooth.

Sharpness. Wide open at the centre the lens is a little soft and lacking contrast. Things improve as you stop down and the best sharpness is attained at f5.6. At the edges at f2.8 the corners are slightly worse than the centre. It is not until f8 when the corner performance equals that of the centre.

 

The pergola in the middle of Tomato Lake in Kewdale.

Autofocus 

 

For stills photography the Tamron 20mm is very positive in acquiring focus if just a bit slow. There’s no hesitancy and no hunting. In a sequence of shots of me walking backwards and forwards the camera and lens combo achieved an 88% hit rate. I would expect that to be better with the third and fourth generation A7 bodies.

Video is a different story. There is some hesitancy in focusing and a bit of wobble even with static shots. Performance is at its best at closer distances.


Usage Scenarios

For landscape and architectural work this would be quite a nice choice, particularly if you are travelling and want to keep the weight of your kit down. The fact that the lens doesn’t reach peak optical performance across the frame until f8 would not be a problem. Just remember to keep for your verticals vertical when shooting buildings.

The minimum focus distance and high magnification ratio means that you can fill the frame with small objects.

 

To achieve the magnification ratio of 1:2 you have to be very very close to your subject

 

The close up capabilities of this lens are what sets it apart from other extreme wide angle lenses. This lens will reproduce an object at half size at its minimum focusing distance of 11cm. Now remember that that distance isn’t measured from the front lens element but from the sensor plane. This means to achieve the magnification ratio of 1:2 you have to be very very close to your subject. So close that you may have to remove the lens hood as it casts shadow over your subject. I bought the lens for nature photography, particularly close ups of flowers. Wide angle close up shots allow you to show the detail of the subject and its context. That gives a more unusual look to the more standard viewpoint of a short telephoto macro lens such as 100mm. For this the Tamron works very well.

Cowslip Orchid, Caladenia flava subs. flava. Christmas Rock, Western Australia.

Astro – I don’t do this type of photography but from what I’ve read I think that you’d be better off getting one of the faster 20mm lenses from Sony or Sigma. F2.8 is borderline too slow an aperture and the lack of edge sharpness at wide apertures further handicaps the lens for this particular usage.

Video usage. This is where the lens is like the curate’s egg – “good in parts”. The autofocus is a bit of a let down and the manual focusing makes repeatable focus pulls difficult. The light weight is a boon for gimbal usage as is the fact that the lens doesn’t extend when focusing. If vlogging is your thing then the angle of view is just about perfect – giving your viewers more of the background rather than just having a large talking head – plus the light weight means the lens and camera combo is easier to hold at arms length.


Conclusion

 

 

Rainwater captured on Christmas Rock in natural forming crack, depressions and gullies.

 

A suprising number of plants grow on Christmas Rock.

 

Jug orchid or recurved shell orchid (Pterostylis recurva). Woottating, Western Australia.

 

 

Cycling along the Beenyup Swamp Boardwalk in Yellagonga Regional Park.

I bought this lens to compliment the 35mm f2.8 which I really like and use a lot. I find that the 20mm is somewhat underwhelming. I feel that the optical performance isn’t as good as it could be. The lens distortion is quite severe and the lens profile just blurs the detail in the corners. Couple this with the autofocus performance and I’m left feeling that it would be better to save more money and buy a better lens. In fact if it wasn’t for the close focusing capabilities I would be parting company with this lens. 

A Flash Piece Of Kit

The Olympus FC-WR flash controller mounted on an Olympus OMD EM1 mark 2 and the FR-WR connected to an Olympus FL-600R speedlight.

When Olympus launched their wireless radio controlled flash system there were howls of derision from the combined blogosphere and photographic forums. Mainly it went along the lines of Olympus had lost the plot in charging so much for something that others were offering so cheaply.  If all you want to do is take portraits with a couple of off camera speedlights then there maybe something to this argument. Let’s make a quick comparison.

Olympus Godox
Commander or transmitter Olympus FC-WR Wireless Commander $385 AUD Godox X2T-O Wireless TTL Trigger $99 AUD
Speedlights with built in receivers 2 x Olympus FL-700WR Flash $449 AUD each 2 x Godox TT685OP Speedlight Flash $195 AUD each
Total Cost $1283 AUD $489 AUD

So that is quite some difference – $794 AUD is a lot of money. Then the Godox fans will tell that the system is much more flexible because if you change camera system all you have to do is change the wireless trigger to one that is dedicated to your new system and you can keep using your existing speedlights. On the face of it it this quite a compelling argument. But this really doesn’t tell the whole story as it assumes that you have no existing flash equipment and that all you want to do is shoot basic lighting set ups with either TTL or full manual control. Now a lot of people who are attracted to Olympus cameras aren’t just attracted by the small size of micro four thirds but also by the advanced features that the cameras have such as focus stacking, keystone compensation, High Res Shot Mode, Live Bulb, Live Time, Live Composite, multi exposure, art filters, picture modes, and interval shooting. Plus Godox doesn’t offer a TTL enabled flash such as the Olympus Twin Flash STF-8 for macro and close up photography.

Using the Olympus STF-8 close up flash as part of a multi flash set up controlled by the Olympus FR-WR and FC-WR.

Regular readers will know that I do a lot of wildflower photography, product shots and the occasional portrait all using flash. I realised I wanted to use more complex lighting arrangements and so I decided to put together a system based around the existing flash units I already had – an Olympus FL-600R, an Olympus STF-8, 2 Metz 44AF-1’s, and a Metz 64AF-1. To that end I bought an Olympus FC-WR wireless commander and three Olympus FR-WR Wireless Radio Flash Receivers ($285 AUD each). Still not a super cheap option, but one that gives me a lot of scope. Now when I started this because the system was not well received there were next to no reviews of it and I didn’t know if everything I had, particularly the Metz units would work. Also I wanted to know whether they would also work with my Panasonic G85. So this was a real voyage of discovery

As I progressed with this I realised that I didn’t just want to write a review, but that I’d also say how to use the equipment in various modes across both Olympus and Panasonic cameras using third party flashguns so that prospective users can find all this information out without having to take a punt like I did. As usual I’ve provided the information in both video and written formats.

So with all that preliminary guff stated (phew!!) lets dig in by looking at the Commander and Receivers themselves first.

FC-WR Commander


Specifications

Maximum communication distance Approx. 30 m
Frequency 2.4 GHz band
Number of channels 15 (in the commander mode; with automatic channel setting function)
Number of groups 3; maximum number of flash units; unlimited
Flash control modes TTL / MANUAL / FP TTL / FP MANUAL / Off
Flash compensation ±5 EV (Increment: 1/3 EV or 1/2 EV)
Manual flash power settings From 1/1 to 1/128 (Increment: 1/3 EV or 1/2 EV)
Power supply AAA alkaline dry-cell batteries x 2 / AAA NiMH batteries x 2
Continuous usage duration Approx. 6.4 hours (when using AAA alkaline dry-cell batteries)
Operable temperature / humidity From -10 to 40℃ (14 to 104°F) / From 30 to 90%
Dimensions Approx. 59.5 (W) x 51.0 (H) x 67.4 (D) mm
Weight Approx. 73 g (excluding batteries)

Firstly the WR in designation is Olympus speak for the fact that the commander has a degree of weather resistance. This is a huge positive for me as I shoot a lot of stuff outside in all weathers. Olympus doesn’t specify the degree of water resistance, but says the unit will operate in temperatures ranging from -10 to 40ºC and humidity up to 90%. I didn’t throw it in a bucket of water but I have used it out in the rain on several occasions with no functional problems, and when I opened up the battery compartment it was dry so that’s all good.

The FC-WR uses AAA batteries. This was a bit of a disappointment and I would have liked AA as it means I only have to carry one type of battery and AAs last longer. However in practice I’m still using the first set of AAAs, and I suppose the use of them keeps the size down.

Olympus FC-WR, showing the information panel and the various controls.

Physically the FC-WR is made of sturdy plastic which doesn’t creak or flex if you give it a squeeze. The door to the batter compartment is on a sprung hinge and slides to lock and open. It fits well and there is some initial resistance to moving so there won’t be any accidental opening. On the base is a locking hotshot with the standard m4/3 pins providing electrical contact. On the to is a large LCD screen which gives all the necessary info and is backlit.  Underneath that are three buttons – one each for the the three groups. Then there is a mode button, a test button, a dial and rocker switch surrounding the OK button and finally the on/off button. A nice touch is that if you turn off your camera the FC-WR automatically switches off, and if you restart your camera within 10 minutes it will automatically switch back on. Any longer and you have to press the on/off button.

To use it is simplicity itself. First select the group or flashgun you want to control, press the button followed by the mode button. Select between TTL, manual or off. Use the right side rocker switch to move to the +/- ratio to select either flash compensation for TTL mode or the power levels for manual mode. Another press of the rocker switch and you can select whether you want high speed flash sync or FP mode in Olympus speak. A final press of the rocker switch lets you select the channel that you want all this to occur on.

FR-WR Receiver


Specifications

Maximum range Approx. 30 m
Frequency 2.4 GHz band
Number of channels 15
Number of groups 3
Control modes RCV (commander flash control), X-RCV (connected flash control)
Charging completion indication Beeping sound
External terminal Sync terminal (output)
Power supply AAA alkaline dry-cell batteries x 2 / AAA NiMH batteries x 2
Continuous usage duration Approx. 6.4 hours (when using AAA alkaline dry-cell batteries)
Operable temperature / humidity From -10 to 40℃ (14 to 104°F) / From 30 to 90%
Dimensions Approx. 59.1 (W) x 46.1 (H) x 51.0 (D) mm
Weight Approx. 75 g (excluding batteries)
Olympus FR-WR showing the controls on the rear of the unit.

In terms of construction what I said about the the commander applies here. On top of the receiver is a standard four thirds protocol hot shoe. On the base there is a locking cold shoe with 1/4 20 mount. On the left side (looking from the front) is a pc sync socket – does anyone actually use these any more? – which would allow you to tigger a studio mono block or power pack. On the other side is the battery compartment which takes two AA cells.  On the back panel is a dial that enables you to select channels (1-15) and beside it another dial for selecting channels. Then there are three buttons which are from the bottom the on/off switch. The neat little touch with this is if you are using an Olympus brand flash then switching off the receiver will switch off the flash. In the middle is a button for switching the beep on and off. I leave it on as it gives me an audible indication of when everything has recharged. Finally at the top is the X-RCV button. This allows you to either control the flash from the commander unit or from the flash itself. I choose to control the flash via the commander unit as I find that more convenient.

Usage Scenarios


Standard Mode

The Radio triggers work with both Olympus and Panasonic cameras and with third party flashes. It also works with the Olympus ST-F8 as part of a multi flash set up, but you will have to cobble together something to hold the FR-WR and ST-F8 body off of the camera.

Using the Olympus STF-8 close up flash as part of a multi flash set up controlled by the Olympus FR-WR and FC-WR.

FP Mode or High Speed Sync

FP mode or high speed sync is a function of the flashgun and not the camera. So if your flash supports it it you can use it. I got it work with the Metz 64AF-1 and the Olympus FL 600-R using both Panasonic and Olympus cameras.

Focus Stacking or Bracketing

The focus stacking feature found on Olympus cameras imposes certain operating restrictions:

  1. Uses the electronic shutter
  2. The flash sync speed is 1/50th sec or longer
  3. You can’t use TTL flash you have to manually adjust the power settings of the flash to get correct exposure

When you set operating parameters for focus stacking in the camera menu remember to allow a a delay between shots that allows for the flash to recycle. I’ve found four seconds to be sufficient. Having set that up switch on the FC-WR and it automatically selects manual flash mode and the camera selects the the flash sync speed. This worked with both the Olympus and Metz flashes on only the Olympus cameras. Panasonic’s focus stacking function is video based (4K capture) and not stills like that of the Olympus.

The original shot with no focus stacking.
The end result of the in camera focus stacking. Twelve shots taken at a different focusing distance and then merged in camera. The camera always applies a slight crop when doing this.

High Res Mode

In many ways this is similar to the focus stacking mode mentioned previously.  It requires an electronic shutter set at 1/50th sec or longer and the flash to be set manually. This worked well with both the Olympus and Metz flash guns. I didn’t test this with a Panasonic camera as my G85 doesn’t have this function.

Conclusion


The Olympus FC-WR flash controller mounted on an Olympus OMD EM1 mark 2 and the FR-WR connected to an Olympus FL-600R speedlight.

Lets get the niggly issue out of the way first. Yes the system is expensive and I wish that it was a little cheaper. Having said that you get rock solid dependability. I found that the Godox units were somewhat flaky at times – occasional misfires where the flash didn’t go off. I like dependability and I’m prepared to spend a little more to get it.

The good stuff. I like the fact that the operation of the constituent parts is seamless even when using the advanced Olympus camera features. The build quality and the weather resistance is excellent, Olympus do a really good job in making small equipment that can handle all the vagaries that life can dish out. The fact that this works with Panasonic cameras is great. Cross compatibility was another factor that brought me into the micro four thirds system. If you want full frame these should work with Panasonic’s full frame offerings as they also share the m4/3 protocols for flash. I say “should” as I’ve not tested it and cannot find anything online to confirm one way or the other. The fact that you can use it with third party speedlights is a huge bonus.

If you are a micro four thirds user and want a rock solid off camera flash solution that gives you access to multi-flash set ups even with specialist close-up equipment using the specialist in camera features such as focus stacking or high res mode then I think its worth spending the cash.


I have written and made videos about several aspects of the Olympus flash system and these are:

Optical Antithesis


A review of the Sigma 16mm f/1.4 DC DN lens for m4/3

 

 

 

The Sigma 16mm f1.4 shown mounted to an Oympus OMD EM1 mk 1 which is one of the larger m4/3 cameras.

 

I’ve said many times on this blog that my favourite focal length is 35mm (35mm equivalent) which give a diagonal angle of view of 63.4º To me it is a relaxing normal view, I find 50mm a bit too tight and 28mm a bit too “loose”. So when I migrated from so-called full frame to micro four thirds in 2010 one of the first lenses I bought was the Olympus m.Zuiko 17mm f2.8 pancake lens. Actually at the time there were only three lenses in the system the 17mm, a 14-42mm kit lens and the 40-150 telephoto kit zoom and I ended up getting them all.

 

Olympus m.Zuiko 17mm f2.8 shown on an EP5. The lens was the first prime introduced for the Olympus’ m4/3 system.

 

The 17mm was equivalent to 34mm in in full frame terms and has a diagonal angle of view of 65º, so close enough as not to make any real difference. It wasn’t a well received lens despite being what initial advocates of the micro four thirds said they wanted – pancake lenses. It’s slow maximum aperture of f2.8, slow and noisey auto focus combined with less than stellar optical performance put many people off and they went for the much more expensive Panasonic 20mm f1.7 which had the virtues of being optically better, and having a faster maximum aperture. It still wasn’t great in the AF department though. But hey these were the early days of mirrorless technology and AF systems were not very quick and accurate then. But anyways I got the Olympus in a kit with my Olympus EP2 and I actually loved it. I could slip it mounted to the EP2 in my pocket which made it a great stealth camera combination and I used it to shoot my TransPerth-Transhumance project. I still use the lens today, mainly on my EP5. The area where I felt it was absolutely hopeless was video. The AF was too slow, too noisy (think angry wasp stuck in a jar) and I wanted a bit more subject isolation than the f2.8 aperture could give.

 

The Sigma 16mm f1.4 compared to the Olympus 17mm f2.8, 25mm f.1.8 and the 45mm f1.9.

 

The Sigma 16mm f1.4 is a physically large lens. Here it is shown with the Olympus 12-40mm f2.8 and 75-300 f4-6.3 zoom lenses.

 

So fast forward a few years and I’m shooting more and more video and I decide to get myself a better 17mm lens. In the intervening years Olympus had produced the very favourably received 17mm f1.8 and the eye-wateringly expensive f1.2 version. Panasonic had also come to the party with their Panasonic Leica Summilux 15mm f/1.7 lens. In fact I went to my local (if you can call 110Km away local) camera dealer to buy this lens and it was always out of stock which made me want it even more. But in the end I went for an outlier in the form of the Sigma 16mm f/1.4 DC DN lens. The reasons being that f1.4 is faster than f1.9, it was cheaper than the f1.2 and the difference between f1.2 and f1.4 is slight, and my dealer had it in stock. So what makes it and outlier? Well to put it bluntly it’s bloody huge. It has a 67mm ⌀ filter thread which compares to 37mm for the Olympus 17mm f2.8. It is bigger than the Olympus 12-40mm f2.8 and the Panasonic Leica 8-18mm f2.8-4 while being only a little shorter than the Olympus 75-300mm f4.8-6.7. The 16mm focal length equates to 32mm on full frame with a diagonal angle of view 68.1º so is a bit wider, but when used with the Panasonic G85 for 4K video this isn’t much of a problem as the camera crops in slightly. So how come this lens is so lardy I hear you all ask. Well this lens wasn’t designed for micro four thirds, it was initially designed for the Sony 6000 series cameras with an APS sized sensor where it equates to being a 24mm in full frame terms. To get a wide angle lens that’s fast and a good optical performance means lots of glass and glass is heavy, and this lens is large and heavy for APS format cameras. To get some additional return on their investment Sigma decided to offer the lens in micro four thirds mount hence it seeming a funny focal length and being bigger than necessary.

 


Vital Statistics

Olympus 17mm f2.8

Sigma 16mm f1.4

Diagonal angle of view 65º 68.1º
Optical construction 6 elements in 4 groups 16 elements in 13 groups
Diaphragm 5 rounded blades 9 rounded blades
Minimum aperture f2.8 F1.4
Maximum aperture F22 F16
Minimum focusing distance 20cm 25cm
maximum magnification ratio 0.11x 0.07X
Filter diameter 37mm 67mm
Dimensions ⌀ 57mm x 22mm (H) ⌀ 72.2mm x 92.3mm (H)
Weight 71g 405g
Internal focusing No Yes

 

 

In the hand the Sigma 16mm feels very dense and substantial. The lens body is made out of what Sigma calls a Thermally Stable Composite (TSC) which is substantially stronger than conventional polycarbonates while having similar thermal expansion properties to aluminium. The lens mount is made of chromium plated brass which should ensure a long life. The Sigma 16mm is advertised as being dust and splash proof but on closer reading of Sigma’s spec sheet there is only one seal and that is at the lens mount. The lens comes with a bayonet mount petal lens hood which has a ribbed grip to make attaching and detaching easier. While it is good that the lens comes with a hood it’s not the best implementation and feels quite insubstantial and can be fiddly to attach as it can foul and not lock home. There is a ribbed rubber focus ring of the fly by wire type – it feels smooth and easy to use. There are no other controls or switches which means if you want to switch between AF and manual focus you will have to use the camera controls for that.

 

 

The Sigma 16mm has an optical construction of 16 elements in 13 groups with 3 FLD (“F” Low Dispersion) glass elements, which offers performance equivalent to fluorite which exhibits less chromatic aberration than those utilising a traditional flint glass. There are 2 SLD (Special Low Dispersion) glass elements which also help to minimise chromatic aberration and 2 ASPH moulded glass aspherical elements which work to reduce optical aberrations. According to Sigma’s website the ASPH elements are polished with a tolerance of under 10 nanometers or 0.000001 millimetres which according to Sigma reduces onion ring bokeh.


Performance

100 % crops showing lens performance wide open and then at the best performing aperture.

 

In terms of autofocus the stepping motor is fast and accurate and very smooth when shooting video. I tested the lens on the OMD EM1 mk ii which has on sensor phase detect AF and on the Panasonic G85 which uses DFD technology – a variant of contrast detect auto focus that requires the lens to provide a profile to the camera to ensure fast and accurate AF. The Sigma does not have such a profile as these are limited at present to only Panasonic’s own lenses. Despite that there were no problems and I could detect no discernible difference between the Olympus and the Panasonic. The only downside in the AF department is that I can’t use the Pro Capture Low setting which gives up to 18 fps with auto exposure and AF tracking. This is no fault of Sigma’s as the option is only available with Olympus lenses.

 

 

Optically – well straight from the get go the Sigma is impressively sharp wide open corner to corner. The performance improves slightly (and it is only visible on my 4K screen at 300%) as you stop down. Diffraction sets in at f16 and this does soften the image. In terms of chromatic aberration, well wide open in high contrast situations it is apparent albeit slight and it is easy to correct in post. The lens is reasonably resistant to flare – but if you have a specular light source in the frame you will experience some veiled flare and ghosting. If you turn off the built in lens profile you can observe a slight barrel distortion, but switch on the profile and it is not visible. The bokeh balls this lens produces are more or less round when shooting wide open even at the edges of the frame and the transitions are nice and smooth. There is some onion ring bokeh which is the result of using moulded aspherical lens.Vignetting is not a problem and is very slight in the region of 1/2 stop.

 

Chromatic aberration is quite apparent on this lens. It is also quite prone to flare even when using the included lens hood.

 


Verdict

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

 

Being designed to have an image circle much larger than micro four thirds requires means that you are using the best performing part of the lens and this really shows. Just for giggles I compared the Sigma with my old Olympus. The Olympus is noticeably soft in the corners at all apertures and just average in the centre. It suffers badly from chromatic aberration. Vignetting is very apparent, in excess of 1 stop in the corners with the lens profile switched on and getting on for 2 stops when switched off. Physically, optically and figuratively the Sigma stands head and shoulders above the little Olympus. The only area where the Olympus wins out is its small size and that is why I’ll continue to use it when I want something small and compact. For every other occasion I’m reaching for the Sigma. The knock on effect is that I’m seriously wondering about replacing my Olympus 45mm f1.8 with the Sigma 56mm f1.4.

Zoomin’ Heck

 

On 7th October 2018 I put a video up of me unwrapping the Panasonic Leica DG Vario-Elmar 100-400 f4-6.3 ASPH Power OIS and my initial impressions of it. Well after six months of use this is my opinion of the lens. I don’t know if it has won the title for having the longest model name, but if not it should be a contender. For brevities sake I’ll just refer to it hence forth as the PanaLeica 100-400.  At the outset I’ll say that this is my lens bought with my money and I’ve only used the one copy of it

 

First off let’s set things straight – this is a very specialist bit of kit that you either have a need for or you don’t. I’ll also say that there is a very good argument to adopt the micro four thirds system just for this lens alone. No I’ve not stopped taking my meds, this lens should be a contender for anyone who shoots wildlife, particularly birds, and travels a lot. A long time ago someone said to me, and I’m not entirely sure who it was, but I’ll attribute it to Hugh Graham who’d been a Fleet Street photographer, that you should choose your camera system on the basis of the lenses you’ll use. I think Panasonic were very smart when they designed this lens because this leverages all the benefits of the m4/3 system. It uses the two times crop factor and small size to produce a lens that is just not available in the 35mm full frame world ie a compact lightweight 200-800mm zoom lens. Recently a muppet on YouTube pronounced that micro four thirds is dead but this lens proves that the system is very viable indeed. Lets compare the PanaLeica 100-400 to some of its rivals. 

Comparing the Canon EOS6d with Sigma 150-600mm lens to the Panasonic G85 and PanaLeica 100-400 lens. Remember folks the Panasonic combination has more reach.

 

 

Lens Weight Cost
PanaLeica 100-400 0.985 Kg $1900 AUD
Canon EF 800mm f/5.6L IS USM Lens 4.5 Kg $17000 AUD
Sigma 800mm f/5.6 APO EX DG HSM Lens 4.9 Kg $8400 AUD
Sigma 300-800mm f/5.6 APO EX DG HSM Lens 5.8 Kg $8000 AUD
Nikon AF-S 800mm f/5.6E FL ED VR Lens 4.5 Kg $23000 AUD

 

 

Or lets look at it another way. My Panasonic G85 with battery grip, two batteries, a memory card and the PanaLeica 100-400 weighs in at 1.829 Kg. A Canon EOS 550d with a Sigma 150-600mm F5-6.3 DG OS HSM Lens which has the same equivalent angle of view is 2.958 Kg and my Canon 6d with the same Sigma lens is 3.345 Kg and doesn’t have the same range. To get the same zoom range the 6d would need to be paired up with the Sigma 300-800mm f/5.6 APO EX DG HSM Lens and the combination would weigh 7.1 Kg. Now if you sit in a bird hide all day with your camera on a tripod then you might be prepared to sacrifice weight, expense and portability to get high image quality. But if like me you walk around anything up to 20 Km in a day looking for birds and are willing to work around the issue of the smaller sensor and it’s inherent poorer performance at ISOs over 6400 (and coming from the days of shooting slide film at ISOs between 50 and 400 I can’t believe that I see 6400 as a problem) then you will be very happy. The argument about image quality is very spurious if you only look at your images on an iPad or phone. So you can see why I think that this lens is enough to persuade people to adopt the m4/3 system – it has enormous reach, is lightweight and is very affordable.


Tech Specs

 

Focal Length 100-400mm (200-800 35mm equivalent)
Aperture range f4-6.3 to f22
Construction 20 elements in 13 groups
Diaphragm 9 circular blades
Focus drive Ultra sonic stepper motor
Close focus distance 1.3 m
Maximum magnification x 0.25
Length collapsed 17.15 cm
Diameter 8.3 cm
Filter size 72 mm
Weight 985 g

The Leica designation denotes that Leica had input into the design but the lens is made by Panasonic at their Yamagata lens factory in Japan. The PanaLeica 100-400 retains the same design cues as Leica’s own lenses and the other Panasonic lenses in this series such as the 8-18mm f2.8-4 ie it uses the same fonts and the same ribbing for the focus and zoom rings. It features an all metal body construction and is listed as being weather proof. However, there is no rating as to the extent of the weather resistance. It is a very attractive lens to look at and has a satisfying heft to it which reinforces the fact that this a quality bit of kit. In November 2015 I blogged about the Olympus m.Zuiko 75-300mm f4.8-6.7 mk ii which I bought when I first started dabbling in wildlife photography, with its plastic construction it makes the PanaLeica 100-400 look like a luxury item.

 

The PanaLeica 100-400mm mounted on Olympus OMD EM1 with lens zoomed out to 400mm.

 

With regards to the physical controls on the lens body working backwards from the built in mini lens hood (a separate full-sized one can attach to this but I have never used it) there is a narrow focus ring. As per usual with Panasonic this a fly by wire ring with no direct physical coupling to the lens heliocord. Behind the focusing ring is ring which locks and unlocks the lens mechanism to prevent zoom creep. This can be applied at any point in the focal range. The zoom ring is nice a broad enabling a good grip and is quite smooth with a little resistance to movement. It has a ninety degree throw and works very nicely when shooting video. The lens body extends outwards as you progress through the lens range. The front lens element, however, does not rotate which is good news for users of polarizing and variable neutral density filters. The tripod foot and collar is really a rather clever piece of design. There is no collar as such, the rear part of the lens rotates 90 degrees to allow users to change from horizontal to vertical orientation. The foot screws into the lens and can be completely detached. In another nice touch you don’t need the foot to attach a tripod plate as you can attach it directly to the lens body which reduces the profile of the lens considerably. Just before the lens mount there are three physical switches. The first is a focus limiter which offers two positions, full focus range and 5m to infinity. Below that is a switch for AF or manual focus, and below that a switch for the optical image stabilisation system. The lens mount is metal and there is an o ring that provides some sealing against water and dust ingress.

 

 

Without a doubt the PanaLeica 100-400 is a very complex lens with 20 elements in 13 groups, 1 ultra low dispersion element, 2 extra low dispersion elements and 1 aspheric extra low dispersion element. From this we can see that it is corrected against chromatic aberration and optimised to produce high contrast, high-resolution images whilst maintaining a compact form factor. Although each group is positioned precisely within the lens barrel it is impossible to do this perfectly so the three lens groups that are most acutely effected by tilt and centring defects and therefore impact most upon image quality are the only ones that are adjustable. This has meant that repair or adjustment of the lens is very difficult and only Panasonic’s Yamagata factory is able to do this which means warranty repairs are sent back to Japan for assessment and then are usually replaced. If your lens fails outside of the warranty period customers are offered a refurbished lens at a discount rather than a repair. To further complicate the issue Panasonic in most countries contracts out its customer service and it is very difficult to access and there have been quite a few accounts of poor service on various camera forums. So my best advice would be to buy this lens from a bricks and mortar store with a good returns policy and then thoroughly test the lens, because if you have a problem it could be quite difficult to resolve.

 

 

The image quality is very good from 100-300 and just gets a little softer towards 400. This is not unusual for zoom lenses. At all focal lengths the edges of the frame are a little softer wide open but sharpen up nicely as you stop down. Diffraction becomes apparent at f16. There is next to no chromatic aberration, and the only times that I did observe it a simple click in Lightroom fixed it. Flare is remarkably well controlled on a lens with so many glass elements. I have shot a lot of frames into the light and have found that I don’t need to use the full-sized screw on lens hood, I just use the mini sliding hood that is built into the lens. Filter users be aware that this lens is very fussy about filters as many long lenses are. I’ve had no problem with multi-coated B+W and Heliopan filters. For giggles I tried an uncoated Fotga variable neutral density filter and using a combination of the lens on both a G85 and an EM1 could not get focus. This is not a fault of the lens but shows the effect that using cheap uncoated filters can have on lenses. My Canon 70-200mm f2.8 IS L does exactly the same with the Fotga filter. I’ve never understood why people will spend $2K on a lens and then slap a cheap $10 filter on it. If you are going to use filters use good ones.

 

Australasian Grebe by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Australasian Grebe, Tachybaptus novaehollandiae. Lake Monger, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 with PanaLeica 100-400mm. Exposure: 1/1000s, f6.3, ISO 400.

 

Rainbow Lorikeet by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Rainbow Lorikeet, Trichoglossus moluccanus. Lake Monger, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 with PanaLeica 100-400mm lens. Exposure: 1/1000s, f5.1 at ISO 6400.

 

Laughing Kookaburra by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Laughing Kookaburra, Dacelo novaeguineae. Avon Walk Trail, York, Western Australia. Panasonic Lumix G85 with PanaLeica 100-400mm lens. Exposure: 1/1000s, f6.3 at ISO 250.

 

 

White Faced Herron by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
White faced heron, Egretta novaehollandiae, Wilson Inlet, Denmark, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 with PanaLeica 100-400mm lens. Exposure: 1/800s, f6.3 at ISO 320.

 


In Use

 

After six months of use and a few thousand exposures I think I’ve got a good handle on this lens. The inbuilt optical stabilisation combines with Panasonic’s Dual IS bodies (at the time of writing the GH5, G9, G95, G85, GX85, and GX9) to give impressive results, around 5-6 stops. When shooting 4K video with the G85 it is very impressive being able to shoot handheld with such a long lens. The video below has footage using the lens on both the G85 and EM1 as well as more stills examples. Unfortunately the OIS does not combine with the IBIS on Olympus bodies so it’s a case of either or. I have my EM1 set up with the IBIS permanently on and have selected Lens IS Priority in the custom functions. This means that when a lens with inbuilt stabilisation is detected the camera switches IBIS off. The reason for this is with shorter lenses IBIS is more effective, but with longer telephoto lenses lens based stabilization works best. The OIS works well enough to get fairly good handheld 1080 video with the EM1, but it’s obviously not as smooth as the G85. The hybrid AF system in the EM1 (a combination of contrast detect and on sensor phase detect) is more confident than the DFD (depth from defocus) of the Panasonic. With small subjects against busy backgrounds I’ve found that the G85 and the PanaLeica just hesitates that little bit as it tries to acquire focus and with small birds that slight hesitation is difference between getting a shot or not. The EM1 is very quick to acquire focus and that is why I’ve ended up favouring it more for bird photography. Now I’m perfectly happy to accept that this just might be a shortcoming of the AF system in the G85 and having read the Lumix GH5/Gh5s/G9 AF Guide Book things might improve significantly if I were to use one of those bodies. But for now I have the quandary of superb image stabilisation versus better AF and I’d sooner have better AF and use faster shutter speeds.

 

 


Conclusion

 

Lakesided Walk - Thomsons Lake by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Good close focusing and fairly decent maximum magnification of 0.25 means that the PanaLeica 100-400 is very good when photographing larger insects such as butterflies, moths, dragon flies and damsel flies. Australian painted lady (Vanessa kershawi). Thomsons Lake, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 with PanaLeica 100-400mm lens. Exposure: 1/1000s, f6.3 at ISO 640.

 

If you are already invested in the m4/3 ecosystem and are interested in photographing birds then this is a no brainer. The PanaLeica 100-400 is streets ahead of the Olympus 75-300 and I would imagine the similarly priced Panasonic 100-300mm. It’s absolutely the muts nuts for walking around in the bush photographing birds and larger insects. Now if you’re interested in wildlife and nature and either don’t have a camera or have another brand I’d really recommend giving this lens and a micro four thirds camera some serious consideration. The image quality is very good as long as you’re not a pixel peeper and are honest with your self on what you’ll do with the image. It is very liberating to walk through the bush unencumbered by heavy camera kit that cost the equivalent of the annual GDP of a small Pacific Island nation. My only wish is that there were more compatibility within the micro four thirds system so that the image stabilisation worked across brands, the zoom rings turn in the same direction and that Panasonic adopt the clutch mechanism on their lenses for manual focus with hard stops.

 

Sacred Kingfisher by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Sacred Kingfisher, Todiramphus sanctus, the Knoll, Walpole, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 with PanaLeica 100-400 lens. Exposure: 1/1000s, f5.7 at ISO 800.

 

Get A Grip

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.

 

There’s no doubt about it that micro four thirds cameras offer superb performance in a compact body. My favourite cameras have been the EM10 Mki and the EP-5 equipped with one of the excellent prime lenses such as the 25mm f1.8 or the 45mm f1.8. Trouble arises when you slap a bigger lens on such as the truly excellent Olympus M.Zuiko 40-150mm f2.8. It’s possible to use them but it feels unwieldy and uncomfortable for long periods. So the solution was to buy a bigger bodied camera such as the EM1 Mki. I was lucky that I managed to blag a good deal and it included HLD-7 battery grip. In day-to-day usage that grip has never left the camera. When I got the Panasonic Leica 100-400 I started using it primarily on the EM1 and it felt well-balanced, but I wasn’t getting the use of the 5 axis dual image stabilisation. So I thought I’d slap it on front of the G85 that I bought for video. Problem solved for the image stabilisation, but then I felt I needed a bit more real estate for the hands. 

 

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.

 

Looking online I saw the Panasonic BGG1 Battery Grip was $362 AUD. Now I don’t know about you but lately I think the camera manufacturers have been having a lend of us with camera grips. The new Canon EOS R’s grip retails for $599 AUD and the Fuji X-H1’s is $499 AUD. This is why there is a thriving market in cheap Chinese knock offs, but these tend to be for the best-selling cameras from Canon and Nikon. A lot of people regard these as crap, but back in 2010 I’d bought a Canon 550d and wanted a grip and I ended up buying one by Aputure from eBay for a whopping $40. It is still going strong, in fact it is in better nick than the camera body which I’ve had to superglue together on a couple of occasions. So I was definitely open to the idea of an after market grip, but I was under the impression that there wouldn’t be one as Panasonic don’t command a big enough market share. The other week I was trawling the internet looking for some batteries for my G85 and I found on Amazon Australia for the grand price of $61 AUD the battery grip DMW-BGG1 Battery Grip. So I took the plunge.

 

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.

 

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.

 

Ok first impressions. It’s made of plastic, but so is the body of the G85. It seems to be a pretty faithful copy of the Panasonic version right down to the recessed area for holding the rubber cover for the electrical contacts from the camera. The buttons and dials don’t feel as nice as those on the camera but they work well. The only downsides are that the tripod mount is not under the axis of the lens and it is obviously not weather sealed. For me these weren’t a big deal. In use the grip is comfortable and fits the contours of the camera body well. It helps provide a nice comfy grip, especially in the portrait orientation and the extra battery is a welcome addition when shooting video.I’ve been using it for a couple of months and it has been great. A good buy. 

 

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.

 

The Neewer DMW-BGG1 battery grip for the Panasonic Lumix G85.