The Everyday Camera

The best Every Day Camera I’ve ever had. If only some one could make a digital version with a full frame sensor. Stuff it just make it with a Micro Four Thirds sensor and I’d buy 2!

 

If you were to take a browse through photography social media sites you will see the proliferation of the acronym “EDC” which apparently stands for “Every Day Carry”. I particularly dislike the phrase – its origins lie in American military and survivalist culture where it meant a concealed weapon such as a gun or a knife. I particularly dislike how American culture has become part of photographic culture. We hear terms like “shooting”, “pull the pin”, or “pull the trigger”. But, having said that if we change the acronym EDC to mean Every Day Camera then I think it has a lot of merit.

 

My Leica D-Lux pimped out with its accessory grip, tripod adapter and Peak Designs Anchor Link.

 

Our recent trip to Cairns made me appreciate a small fully featured camera with a large sensor that could be carried around everywhere unobtrusively. For that trip I took my Leica D-Lux Type 109 and it did a fantastic job. But, it is getting long in the tooth and it has started to develop a few annoying little faults. Initially I just thought about getting it repaired, but when I found out that it would have to be shipped back to Leica’s factory in Germany at considerable cost even though it is a Panasonic Lumix from Japan in Leica fancy dress I decided to look for a replacement.

 

The Leica D-Lux compared with its predecessor the Panasonic Lunix LX5. Looking from the front there is not a lot of difference in the size despite the D_Lux having a sensor much larger than the LX5. Both are excellent Every Day Cameras.

 

At one point every camera manufacturer made such a camera, but then with the ubiquity of mobile phones with “reasonably” good cameras (but with lousy ergonomics and controls) they went out of fashion and if you wanted to buy one they were like hens teeth. Oh sure a few manufacturers continued to make them – Ricoh’s GR IV, Fuji’s X100vi, Sony’s RX1R Mark III , Panasonic’s L10, Leica’s Q3 and D-Lux 8 – but have you seen the price? Well in the consumer paradise that is Australia the price range is roughly $2000 – $12600. Definitely not for the financially embarrassed.  On looking at the secondhand market I discovered a curious paradox. For cameras that nobody wanted just a few years ago they are now selling for a lot of money. For example a 12 year Leica D-Lux Type 109 camera is going for north of $2000. A lot of money to pay for an older second hand camera which will just as likely develop the same faults as mine just has. Another strategy is clearly needed.

Perhaps I didn’t need a built in zoom lens. Perhaps I could use a small camera body with a small interchangeable prime lens. Ideally I want a flat topped rangefinder styled camera with a viewfinder. If so I have a couple of likely candidates in the camera cupboard. So the other day when I had to go into Perth for the day I took three (yes three!) Small cameras fitted with a 35mm equivalent prime lens. It’s not important at this stage to say what I took, but it was quite interesting to see how much time I spent with each camera and lens combination and how much I enjoyed using them. What I discovered was that the specs aren’t that important. For this type of photography a central single AF point is perfectly adequate. In terms of the sensor, well anything more than 12Mp is overkill for my uses. The pictures either get shared with friends and family or put on social media. If I do want to print well 12Mp is good for a nice A3 print. Burst speed doesn’t have to be great – 4 fps is perfectly adequate if I need continuous shooting. Start up time is fairly important, but usually I wander around with the camera always on and have a spare battery in my pocket.

 

20260703-Perth-0249-Edit
And whose truth would that be?

 

20260703-Perth-0238-Edit-2
A chilly winters morning cycle ride.

 

20260703-Perth-0236-Edit-3
A giant blue alien puts the local kangaroos to flight on St. George’s Terrace in Perth.

 

20260703-Perth-0236-Edit-2
Perth’s street art is getting more interesting.

 

20260703-Perth-0232-Edit
Another giant alien walking through Perth.

 

20260703-Perth-0230-Edit-2
A pigeon flash mob in Forest Place.

 

20260703-Perth-0228-Edit
Tweety Pie gangsta.

 

 

Everyday Cameras are also great for recording those special spontaneous moments that happen so the user interface needs to be intuitive to allow quick use such as when your new puppy does something really cute. They should also be able to be used single handed. I’m not a great advocate of doing that, but, sometimes situations present and you’ve only got one hand free.

 

Bertie
Bertie posing in the garden

 

Bertie
Cuteness overload

 

I’ve yet to make a decision on which one I shall use as the EDC – or I may just keep using all three on a rotation basis and possibly add other combinations to the mix.

What A Carry On!

We recently went to Cairns in Queensland on a birding trip – more about that later – part of the deal on the flight was that we were limited to carry on luggage only. We’d been able to increase my allowance from 7Kg to 14Kg. At first glance this looks easily doable, but the devil is in the details. The main bag could weigh a maximum of 10Kg and measure 56 x 36 x 23cm. The second bag had to be able to fit under the seat in front of you. This pretty well meant that my camera equipment had to be 4Kg in a small bag. I can tell you this caused weeks of furious activity in terms of weighing equipment, doing test packs, looking online at small bags, studying various videos for how wildlife photographers pack for flights, and an inordinate amount of worry.

 

20250830-OMSystem100-400-0230-Edit
The Olympus EM1x and OM Systems 100-400mm f5-6.3 is my preferred choice for wildlife photography.

 

For our last two trips where we flew (Darwin and Broome) we had the luxury of checked baggage which meant my photographic kit could weigh 7 Kg and fit in a photo backpack  that went as carry on. For the last few trips I’d settled on the following equipment:

 

Olympus EM1x 1003g
Olympus EM1 mk ii 620g
Olympus 12-40mm f2.8 428g
OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 1462g
6 batteries 420g
12 SD cards 140g
Manfrotto 209 table top tripod 500g
Camera Bag 1780g
Monopod 900g

 

This all came to 7.25kg. Clearly something would have to go. The other headache was that my bag wasn’t small enough to fit under a seat. I did countless test packs and made countless changes. Two days before our flight I was still  plagued with doubt and indecision. In the end at literally the twelfth hour I made a radical decision and then spent the whole 5 hour flight worrying about whether I’d done the right thing.

 

The Panasonic Lumix G9 mk 2 with Panasonic Leica 100-400mm f4-6.3 lens for wildlife photography.

 

So what did I leave behind? All of the above except batteries and SD cards. I took instead a totally untested combination. A brave decision or totally bonkers? Well in the end it was the right decision. So what did I take?

 

Panasonic Lumix G9 mk ii 714g
Panasonic Leica 100-400mm f4-6.3 1130g
Leica D-Lux Type 109 compact camera 475g
24 SD cards 280g
Batteries 350g
Think Tank Digital Holster 50 v2.0 370g
Think Tank Speed Changer v2.0 300g
Think Tank Thin Skin Belt v2.0 230g
Think Tank RU Hot? Water bottle holder 120g

 

Total combined weight 3.83Kg so a 3.42Kg weight saving. So in practical terms I reduced the load by nearly half and importantly it would fit under the seat in front of me.

 

To carry my camera equipment while in Cairns I used a Think Tank Digital Holster 50 v2.0, a Think Tank Speed Changer v2.0, and a Think Tank Thin Skin Belt v2.0 in carry on luggage configation.

 

Yours truly sitting on a houseboat in Kashmir, India, in 1987. You can just see the Camera Care Systems belt pouch on my hip. Oh to be young and thin again! Photo by Helen Amyes.

 

Before we talk about the camera and lens choice let’s address the carrying system – it is a a modular belt system which means it is easy to configure for the job in hand. I’ve been using these since the late 1980’s after a trip to the island of Santorini in the Mediterranean. The bag I used for that was heavy without any load, configured badly and the designers had obviously never heard of the concept of ergonomics. At one point on a walk across the island I could have quite happily thrown the the bag and its contents off of a cliff and into the sea. I quickly bought a belt and series of pouches that were made by the now sadly defunct Camera Care Systems. After twenty or so years I started using the Lowe Pro Street and Field System which was originally designed for working professional photojournalists. After a while Lowe Pro made changes to the system and it was no longer as extensive or flexible and I moved over to the Think Tank System. It’s basically a series of pouches and camera holsters that can be used singularly or in various combinations using a waist belt and/or straps. These are great when working events as all the weight is carried on your hips, they are easy to work out of and means you can walk through crowds without knocking anyone flying with a big photo backpack. The major down side is that unlike a backpack there is nowhere to stuff a jacket or anything else.

 

What the well dressed bird photographer is wearing this season at the Cattana Wetlands. Here I’m wearing the Think Tank Modular Belt System. Photo by Helen Amyes.

 

So how did it go? The short answer is very well.  Not having a backpack while I walked through the rainforest in high humidity was heaven. The only downside was that it often caused my trousers to migrate south towards my ankles, so I was walking around hitching them up all the time.

The Panasonic G9 mk2 and the 100-400mm lens worked flawlessly even in quite dim conditions. The new 25Mp dual gain sensor produces lovely files that are a pleasure to work with and the high ISO performance is much better than my Olympus EM1x. There were a couple of aspects that initially caused concern. The first was that the G9 mk ii RAW files are really large – about twice the size of those from the 20Mp EM1x which meant that I’d have to take a lot more SD cards. Normally I take 12 64Gb  V60 SD cards and that is all I have of them. I didn’t want to go out and buy a load more as the current price of memory cards is very high. I had a load of 64Gb cards in the slower V30 rating which would mean that the camera buffer would take longer to clear. I took the slower cards but didn’t end up using them. The second was that my EM1x has a built in GPS and tags the files with the location while the G9 mk2 doesn’t. So I had to manually annotate the EXIF with the GPS co-ordinates when I got home. It was only a minor inconvenience.

 

The Leica D-Lux Type -108 had all other photographic opportunities covered.

 

The Leica D-Lux Type 109 camera was a little gem. The fast standard zoom did everything I wanted. I really should use this camera more.

 

Cairns Chinese Friendship Garden by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
The pavillion at the Cairns Chinese Friendship Garden. Cairns Botanic Garden, Queensland. Leica D-LUX (Typ 109).

 

The trip went really well, probably one of the best we’ve ever done. I’ll post some stuff about it a bit later.

Bread And Butter Lens

20260417-Canon35mm-0224-Edit
The Canon EOS 30 film SLR with a Canon EF 35mm f2 lens mounted.

 

Regular readers may recall that I have been shooting film again and it has been great fun going out with a single camera and a single lens. My camera of choice is my Olympus OM4 with the Olympus OM Zuiko 35mm f2 lens. That combination is over forty years old and I’m a bit worried that it may give up the ghost because there will be no chance of repairing it. I had thought of getting another OM4 body or even the later OM4 Ti, but they are all getting on a bit. I do have another film camera body that I can use and that is the Canon EOS 30, also known as the Elan 7E in North America and EOS 7 in Japan. I’ve been using it with either my Canon EF 24-70mm f4 or my Canon EF 50mm f1.8. The zoom lens and camera combination is a bit on the heavy side heavy for an every day carry and while the 50mm was suitably lighter it’s not a focal length I particularly like. So I had the bright idea of buying a Canon EF 35mm f2 lens. They have the benefit of being small and light while being cheap second hand. So I scoured EBay and found that Map Cameras had a suitable copy rated as “B – Has been used preciously. Showing a few marks, scratches of cosmetic surface. Functions perfect.”. When it arrived it looked like it was new, there were no marks on the lens barrel, front and rear lens elements, and the mount looked pristine.

 

Canon EF 35mm f2 lens
The Canon EF 35mm f2 was part of Canon’s consumer range of lenses. Here it is shown with the 24mm f2.8 and 50mm f1.8 mk ii.

 

Canon introduced their autofocus EF lens mount in 1987 and it took them until October 1990 to introduce a basic 35mm lens – the EF 35mm f2 a no frills prosumer grade lens. It’s got a plastic body with a metal lens mount. There’s a focusing ring and a switch to put it into manual focus. The lens extends as you focus in and out, but, the front element doesn’t rotate which is a boon if you like to use polarising filters. It feels quite dense in the hand, but it doesn’t exude quality.

 

Canon EF 35mm f2 lens
It is a very no frills construction with a plastic body, manual focus switch and a rudimentary ribbed manual focus ring. You do get a focus scale for zone focusing and an infrared focus point. Which is all very welcome on a budget lens.

;

 

Canon EF 35mm f2 lens
It does have a metal lens mount which is always nice to see as many budget lenses have plastic mounts.

 


Specifications 

Focal Length 35mm
Maximum Aperture F/2
Angle of View (diagonal) 63° 26′ (for full-frame format)
Optical Construction 7 elements in 5 groups
Minimum Object Distance 0.25m
Maximum Magnification Ratio 0.23
Filter Size Φ52mm
Maximum Diameter Φ67.4mm
Length 42.5mm 
Weight 210g
Diaphragm Blade Number 5 straight blades
Minimum Aperture F/22
Standard Accessories Lens caps
Compatible Mounts Canon EF

 

 

EF35mm f2 - Canon Camera Museum 2025-07-28 16-18-22-Edit
The optical construction is very simple with 7 elements in 5 groups and no fancy glass elements.

 


Performance

Sharpness

 

20260501-Canon35mm-0001

 

20260501-Canon35mm-0004

 

20260501-Canon35mm-0002

 

20260501-Canon35mm-0003

 

Wide open the centre of the image is soft, but has reasonable contrast. The corners were far worse – low contrast mush. At first I thought I had a lens that was  decentered, but, when I checked all four corners they were equally bad so it was field curvature . This is, apart from a lens by Holga, the worst lens I’ve ever tested. Two stops down from wide open is where a lens traditionally hits optimum performance, well someone forgot to tell the Canon optical design team that as although there had been a slight improvement in the centre the corners were still very mushy. At f5.6 the centre of the frame is as good as it gets, but the corners still aren’t sharp and lack contrast. The best performing aperture is f8 in terms of the full field of view. By f16 diffraction starts to kick in degrading the image and that just gets worse at f22.

Now this is a 36 year old design for a consumer grade lens so is this performance to be expected. Well the Olympus OM Zuiko 35mm f2 was designed was introduced in 1972 a full 18 years before the Canon EF 35mm f2 and it has a better optical performance and better bokeh – more about that later. The only advantage the Canon has over the Olympus is that the Canon manages flare a lot better. We’re also told that primes are better than zooms so I compared the Canon EF 35mm f2 to my Canon EF 24-70mm f4 IS L at 35mm, and the zoom is better. Not surprising really. An old consumer grade design compare to a more modern professional grade. So I wouldn’t look to replace a good zoom lens with the Canon EF 35mm f2 unless you were considering some other metric of comparison such as size and weight.

Bokeh

 

20250918-Canon35mmf2-0225
Wide open the bokeh balls are bad. The transitions to out of focus areas are quite pleasant.

 

Wide open the Canon produces nice large round bokeh balls that have no onion rings – the lens has after all no aspheric elements. At the edges the balls take on a more elliptical shape caused by mechanical vignetting. As you stop the lens down to f2.8 the balls cease to be balls and become pentagonal thanks to the five straight aperture blades. They become defined the further you stop down.

 

20250918-Canon35mmf2-0226
Stopping down to f2.8 and the bokeh balls cease to be balls and take on a pentagonal shape thanks to the 5 straight blades of the aperture diaphragm.

 

Flare Resistance 

 

20250815-Canon35mmf2-0236-Edit

 

A specular light source within the frame will produce quite pronounced veiling and reflective flare. The effect becomes more pronounced as you stop down. It is a good argument for a lens hood, but Canon never supplied their non ‘L’ lenses with one, you had to buy it separately. It would be worth looking for a second lens that came with one. The diffraction spikes or sunstars are ugly with little definition. 

Chromatic aberration

 

Canon EF 35mm f2
Wide open there is axial chromatic aberration. Stopping down will fix the problem.

 

Axial chromatic aberration, also known as longitudinal chromatic aberration is present wide open with magenta and green fringing. This is difficult to remove in post, the best way to deal with it is to stop down.

Transverse or lateral chromatic aberration is present and considering the age of the design and the fact there are no fancy glass elements it does remarkably well. If using the lens on a digital camera this is easily dealt in post.

Distortion

 

Canon EF 35mm f2
Barrel distortion is present, it’s not too extreme – I’ve seen much worse. It is easily corrected if you shoot digital. You can also see the vignetting. This diminishes as you stop down and can also be fixed in post if working digitally. Personally I quite like a bit of vignetting and will often add it in post or in the darkroom.

 

As with most wide angle lenses there is barrel distortion, but it is very mild. Again shooting on digital this can be fixed by applying the profile for this lens.

Vignetting

There is some vignetting when shooting wide open and this clears up pretty quickly as you stop down. The Canon EF 35mm f2 lens profile in Lightroom also removes it.

Autofocus

When this lens was designed autofocus systems were a lot more primitive than they are now. Firstly these first generation auto focus lenses have according to Canon “an arc form drive for focusing. This is a conventional small motor unit, shaped to fit inside the curved barrel of a lens.”. Consequently they are slow and noisy. When I say say noisy I mean it. Racking the lens back and forth produces a sound that is akin to angry wasp trapped inside a bottle. It is very noticeable. There is no full-time manual focus, as found on later lenses that used USM and STM motors, you have to switch to manual focus using the switch on the lens barrel. Talking about manual focus there is a narrow ribbed focus ring and a focusing scale. While the lens is in AF mode the ring spins freely and does nothing. Throw the switch and the focus ring drives the lens elements back and forth. There are hard stops at either end so repeatable focus moves are possible. While not the most pleasant focusing ring to use it’s not unpleasant either. It gets the job done.

For stills this lens was made when a camera with seven AF points clustered in the centre of the frame was considered sophisticated. Single point AF was usually a matter of keeping the subject in the centre of the frame or focusing and recomposing. The AF on the lens is adequate, mostly it is accurate, but it can be a little slow and hunt in low light or with low contrast subjects. Continuous AF is much the same story.

This lens was not designed with video in mind, but I gave it a go.  I tried it on an 80d the Dual Pixel CMOS AF but it wasn’t the best performance. Finally I bunged the lens on my Sony A7r2 via a Metabones adapter and to some extent the AF was a little better but the lens really struggled and made some awful noises as it focused.


In Use

 

20250815-Canon35mmf2-0225-Edit

 

Moylan Silos

 

20260124-York-0244-Edit

 

Bing's Visit

 

From the above you’d think that this lens isn’t much chop. In photography there is a tendency to obsess about specifications and lens resolution charts, but they don’t tell the whole story. Wide angle retrofocus lens for SLRs don’t really perform well at close distances unless they have a floating rear element which the Canon EF 35mm f2 does not. That may explain some of the results. Also answer these two questions. How many times do you compose a photo with the main subject in the extreme corners? Short of very precise copy work how many images do you take that require corner to corner sharpness? I know I don’t do any of those two things. The attributes this lens brings to the table are that it is small and light and is sharp enough where it counts. It is ideal on a compact SLR as an everyday carry.  Although I primarily bought it to use on my film EOS 30 to date I’ve not done so preferring to use it on either my Canon 5d or 6d. It’s been a very pleasant experience and I’ve enjoyed using for landscape, urban landscape and street photography.

 

Smile

 

20251229-Perth-0224-Edit

 

20251229-Fremantle-0226-Edit

 


Conclusion

 

Canon EF 35mm f2 lens

 

If like me you want a small compact lens to walk around with on a film or digital Canon SLR and you aren’t bothered by not having a red ring, the best specs and best optical performance then this lens is perfect. There are loads of them out there which makes it easy to pick up a reasonably priced second hand example. If you want something to shoot video I’d look for the Canon 35mm f2 IS, the Canon 35mm f1.4 L, or a Sigma 35mm f1.4 Art. They will all have more modern motors which will make the autofocus experience more pleasurable. If you want to adapt the lens to shoot on a modern mirrorless again look for something more modern.

 

Canon EF 35mm f2 lens

 

OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 II IS lens Redux

Untitled-1

Back in November 2025 I wrote about my experiences with the OM System 100-400 mk ii, and it is fair to say that they weren’t very positive. Since then a lot has happened and I’ve had a couple of requests for an update so here we go.

First of all I’d like to take the time to thank Aaron Harivel Product and Sales Specialist at OM Digital Solutions Australia for his help and patience in bringing this matter to a resolution. On 21st January 2026 I picked up a new copy of the lens.

My main problems with the original copy were that the autofocus was very bad – it just wouldn’t find focus or when it did it would not hold it. It was a very frustrating experience. My other cause for concern was that the lens was soft wide open and didn’t improve until I stopped down to f11. So I was interested to see whether the new copy was any better.


Optical Performance

I didn’t bother testing the lens at all focal lengths I just concentrated on the 400mm end. So pointing the lens at a test chart with the camera mounted on a tripod and using the self timer to trigger the electronic first curtain shutter I found that the new version wide open at f6.3 was softer than the first copy – only by a gnat’s whisker, but none the less it resolved less fine detail. But, more importantly the performance at f8 was way superior to that of the first lens even when that was stopped down to its best aperture of f11. Not ideal, but I can work with it if I can get the lens to focus accurately and consistently.

wide_open_centre

 

wide_open_corner

 

f8_centre

 

f8_corner


Autofocus

 

Laughing Dove

 

The day after I collected the lens I took it out and gave it a simple test – taking a sharp photo of a Laughing Dove sitting on a railing from a distance of about 10m. I fired a burst of shots using single point continuous auto focus and held my breath waiting for the buffer to clear before looking on the back screen of the camera. When I looked I saw to great relief that every shot was perfectly in focus – something the first copy could not achieve. I carried on walking along the riverbank taking photos of a variety of different birds in as many different lighting scenarios as I could find using either single point CAF or subject tracking and the lens performed flawlessly. The video I shot was also in focus. I’ve even tried it in combination with the 1.4x teleconverter and it works well in brighter light, but struggles a little bit when the light levels are low and lack contrast. It was better than I expected.

 

 

I’ve taken it out of subsequent occasions with the same results.

 

Kanyinak
Kanyinak or Sacred Kingfisher (Todirmphus sanctus). Northam, Western Australia.

 

Djakal-ngakal
Djakal-ngakal or Galah (Cacatua roseicapilla) fly past. York, Western Australia.

 

Djoowi
Djoowi or Tawny Frogmouth (Podargus strigoides). Lake Leschenaultia, Chidlow, Western Australia.

 

Doolor
Doolor or Silvereye (Zosterops lateralis). Lake Leschenaultia, Chidlow, Western Australia.

 

Koordji-koordji
Koordji-koordji or Australian Reed Warbler (Acrocephalus australis subspecies gouldi). Lake Leschenaultia, Chidlow, Western Australia.

 


In Summary

Well when I posted the original post about the first version and the accompanying YouTube video I was amazed at the supportive comments. Most people it seemed were happy with copy of the lens, but there quite a few who definitely had problems with theirs and were unhappy. In my first write up I recommended the Panasonic Leica 100-400mm over the OM version. I had a few comments from people who had the opposite experience to mine and felt that they could not share my recommendation. It would seem that there is quite a lot of sample variation with camera lenses, although this is my first problem in this regard in 40 years of photography.

All I can suggest is that you be persistent with your dealer or local distributor if your lens doesn’t function like it should and work to a satisfactory resolution.

As to how I feel about the lens now I have a satisfactory copy. Well I’ve got some exciting trips lined up this year and the lens will be coming with me.

Second Time’s A Charm…

 

… or is it?

OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 II IS lens Review

 

20250829-OMSystem100-400-0236-Edit

 

This has been very difficult to write and has become a very long and drawn out affair and it shouldn’t have been.

I have, as regular visitors to the site may recall, been using the Panasonic Leica DG Vario-Elmar 100-400mm f4-6.3 lens for my wildlife photography since September 2018. I bought it because it was the only affordable quality long lens available in Micro Four Thirds at the time. Largely I have been very, very happy with it. The major nitpick I have is that although both Panasonic and Olympus/OM System are part of the Micro Four Thirds consortium and conform to certain protocols such as lens mounts, flash system standards, and autofocus compatibility some features are not cross brand compatible. Now when I got the lens I was primarily using a Panasonic Lumix G85 with which it mates up perfectly and an Olympus EM1 mk 1 which was close enough. But as I progressed with Olympus cameras some of the features such as Synch IS, autofocus while using Pro Capture, focus stacking and high resolution functions required complete compatibility and I was wanting to use them on a regular basis. When Olympus introduced the mk 1 version of the 100-400mm lens in 2020 it seemed weird as it wasn’t compatible with those features so I saw no need to change. So with the announcement in February 2025 OM System announced the OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 II IS lens and that they had fixed some those issues I became very interested and bought it after watching and reading many, many positive reviews.

 

20250829-OMSystem100-400-0234-Edit

 

 

One of the things that has made this so difficult is because I keep making comparisons to the Panasonic 100-400mm mk I which I also own. In fact, it is probably more a comparison review than anything else, which is unfortunate as I wanted to make it a stand alone look at the OM System 100-400mm.

 

Panasonic Leica 100-400mm Lens
Comparisons with the Panasonic Leica DG Vario-Elmar 100-400mm f4-6.3 are inevitable considering they both share the same focal range and lens mount.

 

 

The Controversy 

When the original Olympus 100-400mm came out a lot people jumped on the fact that it was simply a rebadged SIGMA 100-400MM F/5-6.3 DG DN OS Contemporary Lens. The criticism mainly centred on the fact that it was firstly a lens designed for full frame cameras rather than specifically for Micro Four Thirds which meant some how that it was too large and heavy and undermined the original m4/3 ethos of being small and light. The second complaint was that the original Sigma lens sells for around half the price of the Olympus/OM System version so, therefore, customers were being ripped off by Olympus/OM System. When the  OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 II IS lens was launched these same complaints were again raised. Well the truth is somewhat different. 

 

M.ZUIKODIGITALED100-400mm -Edit
Optical construction of the OM System 100-400mm lens.

 

Sigma100-400_2
The optical construction of the Sigma 100-400mm lens. Looking at this and the OM System one you can see the differences.

 

 

While both lenses may have been built by Sigma (and there is no definitive proof that the Olympus/OM System lens has been) there are some key differences. While they share the same focal length, aperture range, and thermally stable composite body the filter size of the Sigma is 67mm compared to 72mm of the OM System lens. The Sigma lens has a lens construction comprising of 22 elements in 16 groups with four FLD elements and one SLD element. The OM System 100-400mm lens has 21 elements in 15 groups with four ED elements, two HR elements and two Super HR elements. The OM System lens diaphragm has 9 circular blades while the Sigma has 7. The OM System lens has IPX1-rated weather-sealing and there is no rating for the Sigma. The OM System lens’ front element has a ZERO Coating which is a form of fluorine coating that repels water and smears keeping it clean.  The Sigma’s image stabilisation is four stops while the OM System’s is 5 on its own and it fully integrates with their cameras IBIS to give 7 stops of image stabilisation. 

At this point I think it is fair to say that the OM System lens is not a simple case of badge engineering, there are too many differences. Now I’m not saying that OM System didn’t contract Sigma to build the lens using their existing  SIGMA 100-400MM F/5-6.3 DG DN OS Contemporary Lens as a framework. What I am saying is that are sufficient differences in the specifications and they should be treated as entirely separate entities.

Vital Statistics

Focal Length  100-400mm (35mm equivalent 200-800mm)
Mount Micro Four Thirds
Lens Construction 21 elements in 15 groups with four ED elements, two HR elements and two Super HR elements
Lens Coating ZERO Coating
Angle of View 12° (wide) – 3.1° (tele)
Number of Diaphragm Blades 9 rounded blades
Maximum Aperture f/5.0 (wide) – f/6.3 (tele)
Minimum Aperture  F22
Minimum Focusing Distance 1.3m
Maximum Magnification Ratio 0.09x (wide) – 0.29x (tele)
Filter Size 72mm
Dimensions 86.4mm ⌀ × 205.6mm h
Weight 1,125g
Supplied Accessories lens hood
Weatherproof IPX1-rated weather-sealing – Dust-proof, Freeze-proof, Splash-proof
Lens Sync IS 5-Axis

 

20250829-OMSystem100-400-0224-Edit
The OM System 100-400mm is not part of the top tier PRO line of m.Zuiko lenses, but rather one of their consumer grade ones. Consequently it does not have the metal body nor MF Clutch / Snapshot Ring but rather a nondescript composite body that is strictly utilitarian. The zoom is of the external variety in that the lens barrel extends as you zoom through the focal range, but the focusing is internal and the front element does not rotate as the lens focuses. The mechanism feels sturdy with no hint of any flex or wobble. At the mount end there is a chromium plated brass mount which is surrounded by an “o” ring which provides a seal between the lens and camera body. Be aware that OM Systems OM1 mk i & ii, OM3 and OM5 mk i & ii have an IPX rating of 53 which means that they are protected against low pressure water streams from any angle and while not completely dust proof any ingress that does occur will not interfere with the operation of the camera. The lens is IPX1 rated which means that there is no information available about resistance to dust ingress and it is resistant to vertically dripping water equivalent to 1 mm rainfall per minute. So the camera body has more resistance than the lens. 

 

20250829-OMSystem100-400-0231-Edit
The chromium plated brass lens mount and the rubber “o” ring that provides some weather sealing.

 

The lens is quite a chunky beast and it also has considerable weight. It is when you compare it to the PanaLeica 100-400mm that this becomes really apparent. The PanaLeica is 34.1 mm shorter, 3mm in diameter smaller and 140g lighter while having a much more premium metal body that just exudes class. In comparison the OM System lens comes off as feeling lumpen and a little tacky.

 

20250830-OMSystem100-400-0237-Edit
The OM System lens extends as you zoom in. Fitted with the included lens hood it is quite a large lens.

 

When it comes to controls both lenses are pretty the same. A zoom ring, focus ring, zoom lock and switches for the AF function, focus limiter and image stabilisation. The OM System lens scores well here as the PanaLeica is plagued with an incredibly stiff zoom ring, but overall the PanaLeica gives to my mind a much better user experience.

 

20250829-OMSystem100-400-0242-Edit
The much lauded new tripod collar. I see it as a solution to a problem that never existed.

 

On launch there was a lot of fanfare about the new tripod collar. Yes it’s different from the one on the original version but you’d hardly call it innovative. I see it as a solution to a problem that never existed. I’m amazed that so many of the internet reviews went on and on about this giving scant attention to things like autofocus and optical performance. If you want to see a truly innovative approach to tripod collar design look at how Panasonic implemented theirs on the PanaLeica 100-400mm.

 

20250830-OMSystem100-400-0233-Edit
At its minimum focal length with the lens hood attached.

 

The OM System 100-400 includes a bayonet type lens hood in the box while the PanaLeica has a a two piece lens hood (a mini hood permanently attached to the body of the lens and a separate extension that attaches to it) and also throws in a lens pouch. To be honest I’ve never used it, but, it’s nice they’ve taken the effort to include it.

Performance


Sharpness

 

20250901-OMS100-400mmmk2-0293
The new you beaut lens chart.

 

At 100mm wide open at f5 the performance is even across the frame – a little soft and lacking contrast. At f5.6 the contrast improves a little but the sharpness remains the same. At f8 there is no improvement. At f11 the lens reaches it’s best performance and at f16 softness in the form of diffraction re-appears.

 

lenschart400wideopen

 

Best results from the lens came at 200mm, with the best results at f11.

At 400mm wide open at f6.3 at the centre of the image the lens is soft and lacking contrast and the corners match this. The results follow the progress of the shorter end with best performance at f11.

 

lenschart400f8

 

This is very disappointing as the lens is not capable of resolving fine feather detail wide open unless you stop down to f11 which makes the lens really unsuitable for low light or birds in flight as you’ll have to use very high ISOs to get high shutter speeds and that kills image quality.

 

lenschart400f11

 

Flare resistence

 

20250924-OMSystem100-400-0247-Edit

 

Over all flare resistance is very good – the lens coatings are working well to minimise veiling flare. There is some ghosting present – polygonal shapes and light streaks – and it starts to become intrusive at f8. The diffraction spikes are not pretty at all, but then you don’t buy a lens like this for the diffraction spikes.

Chromatic aberration

Transverse or lateral chromatic aberration is present, but it is very, very slight and you really have to pixel peep to find it or turn off the lens profile in your image editing software.

Axial chromatic aberration, also known as longitudinal chromatic aberration is virtually nonexistent, but that is to be expected with such a small maximum aperture.

Autofocus

If you think this has been a pretty damming review so far well all I can say is brace yourself as we haven’t dealt with the lens’s major short comings. Now before any of you complain about me having a faulty camera I tested the lens on an Olympus EM1, two different EM 1 mk 2s, and an EM 1x and got the same result. The lens and the cameras all had the latest firmware installed. 

 

20250901-OMS100-400mmmk2-0378
The bird on the slider test. The slider was set so that it travelled the 20cm of the slider in 20 seconds on a continuous loop.

 

At best using continuous autofocus on a slow moving target – me walking – I got 56% of the images in focus. Putting a stuffed toy bird on a slider and having it move back and forth 40% of the photos were in focus. At this point I contacted OM Systems Australia and sent the lens into them for recalibration. On getting it back the performance was actually worse with only 20% of photos in focus. The problem is that it seems to take ages for the lens to acquire focus and if it does it will momentarily grab focus for a couple of frames before drifting off again. The number of times where I’ve had a bird sitting just 5-10m away from me with a clear background and the camera and lens refuses to lock on to it. Frustration just doesn’t begin to express what I feel when that happens. Switch the lens over to the PanaLeica and there is no problem. Even the much cheaper OM System 75-300mm MKII lens performs better than the OM System 100-400 despite being a quarter of the price.

 

20250924-OMSystem100-400-0229
No matter what I tried the camera and lens combination would not focus on the bird. This Reed Warbler got fed up with waiting and took off.

 

When shooting video the situation is worse. It struggles to find focus and then will inexplicably drift off.

At the time of writing the lens is with OM System Australia for “evaluation”.

Image Stabilisation 

 

imagestabilisation

 

This is an area where the 100-400 excels. OM System claims that the optical stabilisation of the lens combines with the the in body image stabilisation of the camera body to give 5 axis stabilisation of 7 stops. Back in the days of yore when 35mm film SLRs were the norm there was the old adage of the minimum shutter speed you can hold is the reciprocal of the the focal length. So with the micro four thirds crop factor a focal length of 400mm is the full frame equivalent of 800mm and it would need a shutter speed of 1/800 sec to avoid camera shake. Now seven stops would take us down to a shutter speed of 1/6 sec and with my shake hands I could only get 1/13 or 6 stops and get a sharp image. Pretty impressive by anyone’s standards. The practical application of this is that for taking photos of birds I don’t often go below 1/500 sec so it seems overkill, but for video that is another matter entirely and it makes it possible to shoot handheld with this lens.

Minimum Focusing and Maximum Magnification Ratio

 

OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 mkII lens
The minimum focusing distance of 1.3m at all focal lengths makes the OM System 100-400mm a very capable close up lens.

 

OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 mkII lens
The minimum focusing distance of 1.3m at 400mm gives a Maximum Magnification Ratio of 0.29X.

 

 

Conclusion

Thomas Eisl in his review:

“When working with the 100 to 400 Mark  II in practice, one of the first things you will notice is the exceptional focusing performance…It is therefore highly suitable not just for wildlife photography, but also for professional wildlife film making.”

“The exceptional autofocus performance stems from full compatibility with the latest OM system autofocus technologies. This lens is swift enough for the speediest of all subjects and is definitely on par with OM system pro lenses in that regard.”

“Now to conclude the optical performance analysis, it is fair to state that the 100 to 400 M Ii delivers where it matters most and compromises, if existent at all, are very minimal. Overall, a lens capable of professional results, even under demanding conditions. No wonder that this is my most used super telephoto lens at the moment.”

“The OMS 100 to 400 F5 to F6.3 M II stands as a highly capable super telephoto zoom. Its robust yet portable construction, impressive image stabilization and swift autofocus cement its position as a reliable tool for demanding applications like sports and wildlife.”

“This lens delivers a performance that feels almost too good to be true both on paper and in the field.”

Mike Lane states that there is very little difference between the $2200 OM System 100-400mm f5-6.3 II IS lens and the $12,000 150-400mm F4.5 TC1.25X IS PRO.

Espen Helland says “I’m really impressed with the sharpness of the new lens, my photos at 400mm are tack sharp.” and “Though the 100-400mm chases with autofocus a little bit more than my 150-400mm f/4.5 it still performs really well.”

So with these glowing reviews I reflect on my own experience with supposedly the same lens. As it stands, I think that based upon my experience that the OM System 100-400 mk ii is actually unsuited to wildlife photography. The autofocus is incredibly poor and will just frustrate the hell out of you – well it certainly did me. When it does find focus at 400mm, which is where most bird photographers will use it, it is incapable of resolving any fine feather detail. Now it maybe that I just have higher standards than the other reviewers, but I highly doubt that. It maybe that camera and lens manufacturers make sure they send out perfect examples for review. Possible. I know that if I were sending out a product for critical evaluation I would definitely send the best of the best. More likely I just got a lemon. Now if that’s the case then why aren’t OM System looking to rectify the problem. At the time of writing their official line is no refund, no replacement and we’ll begrudgingly look at the lens , but won’t necessarily do anything. That leaves a very sour taste in my mouth and makes me want to change brand. Now OM System doesn’t have a very large market share, they are really struggling to break even (at the end of 2024 they were ¥1.2 billion or $120,000,000 AUD in the red) so alienating existing users seems like economic suicide.

Can I recommend the lens? In short no.

If you’re an Olympus/OM System camera user and not fussed about synch IS, the computational functions and the need for teleconverters then buy the PanaLeica 100-400 it is the much better lens in every way. If those functions and the use of teleconverters are important then I’d skip this lens and sell some body parts and get either the OM System 300mm or 150-400mm. Don’t waste your money on this lens.

 

190321-PanaLeica100-400-0224-Edit
Just buy the PanaLeica 100-400mm as it is the better lens.

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 with the box it comes in. Inside the box are the lens, the end caps and a lenshood.

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN lens was introduced in April 2023 for APS-C cameras in Sony E, Leica L, Fujifilm X and Canon RF mounts and currently sells for $750 AUD. The focal length gives a full frame equivalent of 35mm and it joins the 16, 30, and 56mm lenses which means that there are now f1.4 primes in 24, 35, 45, and 85mm full frame equivalent focal lengths. I’m looking at the Sony E mount version which I bought in May 2024 primarily to use for video mounted to my Sony A6500. I’ve only recently started using it as a general purpose walk around lens.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 with the Sony A6500 camera.

 


Vital Statistics

 

Mount Sony E, Leica L, Fujifilm X, and Canon RF
Lens Construction 13 elements in 10 groups with 3 Special Low Dispersion glass and 2 aspherical elements
Angle of View 63.4º
Number of Diaphragm Blades 9 rounded blades
Minimum Aperture  f16
Minimum Focusing Distance 25cm
Maximum Magnification Ratio 1:7.3
Filter Size 52mm
Dimensions 65.8mm ⦰ x 78.9mm (h)
Weight 330g for Sony E mount version
Supplied Accessories Petal shaped lens hood

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN is part of Sigma’s Contemporary line which means it has a utilitarian plastic body (or as Sima prefers to call it a Thermally Stable Composite). The only external control on the lens is the ribbed focusing ring which is of the “fly by wire type”. The lens is advertised as being dust and splash proof, but the only sealing is at the lens mount where there is an “O” ring seal. The lens mount itself is chromium plated brass for longevity. It is still good to see this as other manufacturers are tending to use plastic mounts on their budget lenses. The lens is supplied with a plastic petal shaped lens hood which feels very well made and it attaches by a bayonet fitting to the lens. It feels secure and well made.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The only weather sealing is the rubber “o” ring on the lens mount.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The petal shaped lenshood supplied with the lens is well designed and made. Thoughtful touches are the ribbing on the exterior to facilitate a firm grip when attaching and detaching it from the elns. The interior is also ribbed to prevent light bouncing off it and into the lens.

 

Physically the Sigma 23mm is quite a large lens. Not as big as the Sigma 16mm f1.4, but bigger than the Sony 28mm f2 and Sony 50mm f1.8. The weight of the lens is 330g – the Sony E mount version is the lightest at 330g and the Canon RF is the heaviest at 345g – and it contributes to the lens having a satisfying heft in the hand. The whole thing is well put together with no dodgy looking seams in the composite body or creaking and flexing when you give it a squeeze. While not part of Sigma’s more premium Art and Sports lines the Sigma 23mm feels a quality piece of kit. 

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 while being a fairly chunky lens is smaller that the Sigma 16mm f1.4.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
When compared to the Sony 28mm f2 and 50mm f1.8 you can see the Sigma 23mm is quite a chunky beast.

 

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 mounted on the Sony A6500 camera.

 

The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN has an optical construction of 13 elements in 10 groups with 3 Super Low Dispersion (SLD) elements to reduce transverse chromatic aberration and 2 aspherical elements to provide correction of spherical aberration and field curvature. The diaphragm sports 9 rounded blades and while not having the eleven blades that the Art Series primes have this does produce nice bokeh effects – more about which later. The minimum focusing distance is 25cm measured from the sensor plane which gives a maximum magnification ratio of 1:7.3.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The minimum focus distance is 25cm, which is measured from the sensor plane, and gives a maximum magnification ratio of 1:7.3.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 


Optical Performance

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

I must say I was quite impressed with the optical performance of the Sigma 23mm f1.4. Wide open the centre is sharp and the corners are a tiny bit softer and have less contrast. Stop down to f2 and things significantly improve. The centre gets even sharper and there is more contrast and the corners now match the centre. Quite something. This performance stays constant until f11 where diffraction starts to set in and the image softens.

Chromatic Aberration

  • Axial chromatic aberration, also known as longitudinal chromatic aberration is present when the lens is wide open, but it is very well controlled and barely noticeable. Stopping down fixes the problem.
  • Transverse or lateral chromatic aberration is present, but it is very slight and you really have to pixel peep to find it or turn off the lens profile.

There is some very slight barrel distortion present, but you have to turn off the built in lens profile to really see it.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
With the lens profile turned off the barrel distortion is visible. Switching the profile on reduces it rather than totally eliminating it.

 

When it comes to flare and diffraction spikes it is a bit of a mixed bag. The good is that there is no evidence of any veiling flare. Polygonal shapes and light streaks are visible. The diffraction spikes or sun stars are quite nice and defined.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
Reflected glare in the form of polygonal shapes and light streaks are evident at smaller apertures. The diffraction spikes or sun stars are quite nice and defined.

 

The nine curved diaphragm blades produce nice clean bokeh balls with no evidence of the soap bubble effect or onion rings at the centre of the frame when wide open. At the edges they take on a more elliptical shape. At f2.8 and beyond the circles start to take on a more polygonal shape. The rendering of the out of focus areas and the tonal transitions are beautifully smooth.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
Bokeh balls at f1.4. The are round at the centre of the frame and change to a more eliptical shape at the edges. There is no soap bubble effect and there are no onion rings.

 

 


Autofocus Performance

 

Sigma23AFtest

 

The complexity of modern autofocus systems in mirrorless cameras means that much will depend upon the AF settings you have made on your camera. A casing point is that when testing this lens on my A6500 the initial results looked very poor. So poor in fact that I put the lens on my A7r2 in APS-C mode and repeated them and the results were like night and day. A quick examination of the A6500’s menu found that I had previously been experimenting with the AF settings and hadn’t put them back to how they were. Once restored it was like looking at a totally different camera and lens combination.

Shooting stills I tested the lens by walking towards the camera with continuous AF set and the lens easily kept up with my movement. It was only when I got close up that there was any sign of hesitancy, but it still managed to find focus. Averaging out several test runs I was getting a hit rate of 93% with critical focus and 7% with acceptable focus. An impressive result.

Shooting video the results weren’t as positive and the lens had trouble keeping up with me as the target. But, when I mounted Gary the Galah to a slider and set it to a 10 second run while close to the camera the AF was very sticky and accurate.I would expect that the A6700 with its more sophisticated subject tracking AF system would yield a better result here. Focus pulls using touch to focus were very decisive with no overt hunting.

While we are talking about focusing I looked at the focus breathing it was very evident.

 


Verdict

Well after using the Sigma 23mm f1.4 DG DN for a year I can say that I have found it be a very capable lens. For video it is near perfect for filming talking head pieces for YouTube – which is what I mainly use it for. For photography it is a great carry around lens suitable for street photography and urban landscapes. I’d happily travel with it as my only lens as well. Does it have any short comings? Well if I were to nitpick some people might find that the lens makes the camera a little front heavy. It doesn’t bother me in the slightest, but these sorts of things can be a deal breaker for some.

Who should buy it? Well that depends upon which camera ecosystem you’re in. If you have an APS-C Canon RF camera and want a fast moderately wide lens then this is your only choice. For Sony and Fujifilm owners it is a little more nuanced. Both manufactures have their own version of this lens. Sony has the Zeiss 24mm f1.8 which retails for $1500 AUD. It can focus a little closer but has a slower maximum aperture and is getting a little long in the tooth. Fujifilm has two competitors. The XF 23mm f1.4 R LM WR lens which retails for $1500 AUD which has better close focusing and superior weather sealing. Then there is the XF 23mm F2 R WR at $640 which also focuses closer, has better weather sealing and is cheaper while having a slower maximum aperture. If you want a fast maximum aperture at a reasonable price then the Sigma can’t be beat.

 


Sample Images

 

2025 York Motor Cycle Festival

 

2025 York Motor Cycle Festival

 

20240522-Mundaring-0226-Edit

 

20240522-Mundaring-0227-Edit

 

20240612-Frida-0224-Edit

 

20250405-York-0227-Edit

 

20250405-York-0233-Edit

 

20250405-York-0234-Edit

 

20250405-York-0242-Edit

 

20250406-York-0225-Edit

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens
The Sigma 23mm f1.4 makes for a excellent lens for architectural studies.

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Lens

 

Less Is More

I’m feeling really deficient in the focal length department. After my trip to the Baigup Wetlands I’ve realised that if I want a picture of a Crake I’m going to need a longer lens. At the moment I’m capped at 600mm on full frame, 800mm full frame equivalent on Micro Four Thirds, and 960mm full frame equivalent on APSC sized sensors. Unfortunately I’m handicapped by the fact that I don’t have a spare $35,000 AUD lying around or camera to put the lens on or I’d get the Canon RF 1200mm f/8L IS USM. More affordable at $4000 is the OM System M.Zuiko Digital ED 150-600mm f5.0-6.3, but even that is currently beyond my budget. 

 

Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 DG OS HSM lens Contemporary
The mighty Sigma 150-600mm Contemporary lens.

 

Teleconverter Test
The Canon Extender EF 2x ii is a matched teleconverter and is designed to only fit certain Canon L lenses. Note how the lens elements stand proud of the lens mount.

 

So my solution was to use my Sigma 150-600mm lens with a Canon x2 teleconverter on my Canon 80d which would give me the full frame equivalent of 1920mm. That is serious reach in anybodies book, but will it work? The first thing to consider is whether the Canon teleconverter will actually fit on the Sigma lens. If you look at the photo you can see that the lenses of the teleconverter protrude beyond the lens mount and into the lens. Would there be enough room in the Sigma 150-600 to accommodate this. The answer was a resounding “YES!”. The next question was would it autofocus. The problem is that on DSLRs the autofocus mechanism  uses a sensor in the bottom of the mirror box that requires a sub mirror behind the main mirror to reflect some light onto it.  If light levels are too low then the system just doesn’t work and the camera can’t autofocus. So that means a lens with a minimum aperture of f8 won’t autofocus. Having said that if we use ‘live view’ the mirror is moved out of the way and on Canon cameras Canon uses ‘dual pixel autofocus’ where every pixel on the sensor can function as an AF point. So in theory it should autofocus. That is good because the minimum aperture of the Sigma 150-600mm at 600mm is f6.3, slap a 2x teleconverter on and that becomes f12.6. So I set up a target in the back garden to try it out. Lo and behold the camera failed to autofocus when using the viewfinder, so OK I knew that was going to happen, but using live view it did. 

The next thing to consider was image quality. When using a teleconverter image, and especially 2x teleconverters, image quality takes a serious hit – the image becomes notably softer. The answer to this is to stop down. After a bit of experimentation stopping down to f16 improved sharpness slightly, but it means using incredibly high ISOs which has impact upon the image quality. I figured that I’d run the images through Topaz DeNoise AI and hope that I’d get something decent.

 

20250405-Sigma150_600-0239
A suitable test target. After experimentation an aperture of f16 was found to produce the best results.

 

Now I just needed to test this out on a live subject. Luckily our back garden is frequented by lots of birds, so I set the camera on a sturdy tripod and just waited. The results were that using live view and dual pixel autofocus the camera would definitely focus, it’s just it does it very, VERY slowly. I managed to get some photos, but the bird had to sit in one place for quite a while and this was with good light levels in the middle of the day. It wouldn’t be practical for a subject in the shade at dawn. I tried to manually focus but I couldn’t move the focus ring in small enough increments to achieve fine focus. The best results were achieved with birds that were about 5m away. I tried on Ring-necked Parrots that were further away and there was huge hit to image quality, the picture were just not critically sharp.

 

20250404-York-0226-Edit
This Willy Wagtail was obliging enough to sit around for a few seconds. It is mandatory that every Australian garden should have at least one Willy Wagtail.

 

20250404-York-0230-Edit
A leucistic zebra finch happily riding the rotary washing line.

 

20250404-York-0252-Edit
This distant shot of Ring-necked Parrots shows a pronounced hit on image quality. Viewing the image at 100% shows the feather detail has gone to mush.

 

 

Ahh well back to the drawing board.

Turning A Negative Into A Positive

20241227-JJC_filmscanner-0224-2-Edit

 

This last twelve months I have started using 35mm film again. Initially I had the lab where I got my film developed scan the negatives. The results were absolutely diabolical – and this was from one of what is considered the better labs in Western Australia. So I needed a scanner. The market had changed considerably since I bought my last one in 2005. Canon and Nikon have exited the market and Epson  has only the V850 flatbed (only $1600 AUD “cough”!) available in Australia. What is available at more reasonable prices are the Plustek range, which seem to be largely differentiated by the software bundled with them. While the price is attractive they are somewhat under specified. The advertised maximum resolution of 7200 dpi is somewhat optimistic as it really doesn’t resolve more that 3200 dpi in real terms. The density measurement of 3.6 D is pretty mediocre and they are incredibly slow in in use. I then figured the second hand market was the place to look. Back in the day the undisputed market leader for consumer dedicated 35mm film scanners was Nikon. Now Nikon stopped production in 2009 so I thought a late model with USB connection would be the way to go and the Nikon Coolscan 5000 seemed to fit the bill with a true resolution of 4000 dpi, autofocus lens, adapters available for scanning whole rolls of film, and a density measurement of 4.8 D (anything over 4 is the mutts nuts). Unfortunately the current film resurgence has meant that these are selling for $1800-2100 AUD for a working model. 

I had an ask around and was quickly informed that camera scanning was very popular. I watched a load of YouTube videos on the subject and saw everything from DIY Frankenscanners to very swish $6500 setups. I dipped my toe into the pool by making a negative holder from a scrap of matt board, an LED light diffused by tracing paper as the light source and set up a camera with a macro lens on a tripod. With a lot of trial and error (mostly error) I got some reasonable results – better than those I got from the lab. This was encouraging and it gave some idea of what I was looking for. I didn’t want to have to set up a camera on a tripod and then align the negative so it was parallel to the camera sensor plane and centred on the axis of the lens. It had to be compact and quick to set up and breakdown. Most importantly it had to work with one of the camera and lens combinations I already owned. Perusing the inter webs I found two set ups that fit the bill:

In crudest terms both are just a tube that attaches to your lens and at the other end is a film holder and an LED light source. Both offer a wide range of compatibility with different cameras and lenses. The Valoi looked very slick and well designed, the JJC looked a little more rudimentary. I plumped for the JJC as I wasn’t sure at that stage how much use it would get.


JJC Film Digitising Adapter And LED Light Set

 

20241227-JJC_filmscanner-0236-Edit
The kit comprises of several short threaded tubes and step down rings.

 

In the box you get a series of short threaded tubes, several step down rings, a negative holder, a holder for mounted slides, a holder for the negative and slide holders, an LED light, a diffusion panel and a USB power cable with switch. There is a comprehensive instruction sheet and a sheet detailing the necessary combination of parts needed for each camera and lens combination. It was all very straightforward and I was up and running in a couple of minutes.

 

20241227-JJC_filmscanner-0228-Edit

 

20241227-JJC_filmscanner-0237-Edit
The LED light is powered via USB. It has no battery.

 

 

The build quality is OK. It’s made out of plastic, but it fits together quite well. The negative holder does a good job of holding the film flat. The only thing I don’t particularly like is that the step down rings bind very tightly to the filter threads of my lenses and it can be a bit of a struggle to remove them.

 

20241228-JJC_filmscanner-0241-Edit
All assembled and mounted on a camera.

 

Before we get to results we must deal with the elephant in the room – lens compatibility. JJC list a total of 15 compatible macro lenses from Canon, Nikon, Sony, Olympus and Laowa covering micro four thirds, APSC, and full frame. Initially I used the lenses from the list – my Canon EF 100mm f2.8 IS L on my Canon 6d, and my Olympus 60mm f2.8 and EM1 mk ii. Both camera have a 20 Mp sensor and both worked very well. What I really wanted to use was my Sony A7r2 and Sigma 105mm f2.8, but the lens is not officially supported. I tried various combinations of the tubes until I found one that worked – a combination of large tubes listed for the Canon EF 100mm f2.8 L macro with the step down ring for the Nikkor Z MC 105mm macro. It delivered excellent results. So if your lens is not listed then it could be worth playing around with the tubes. Do you have to use a macro lens? For best results I’d say yes. It’s not just close focusing capability that’s important. Field curvature is as well. In simple terms an ordinary lens when photographing a flat object ie a film negative cannot bring the whole subject into focus. The centre is sharp and then that sharpness falls off towards the edges of the camera sensor. Macro lenses have inbuilt correction to achieve a flat film plane ie where the image is sharp across the whole frame. Some would say stop down and the problem goes away, and to an extent that could work depending on how acute the field curvature is because if you stop down too far then the diffraction kicks in and the image softens. Having said that if you don’t have access to a macro lens then there is nothing to stop you using a 50mm lens with 2 x 25mm extension tubes to see how you get on. Personally if you’ve got a mirrorless camera I’d look on EBay for a second hand manual focus macro lens and get an adapter so you can mount it on your camera. You don’t need autofocus to scan film.

 

20241228-JJC_filmscanner-0243-Edit
Mounted on a Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens for Sony E mount. The lens is not on the JJC list of supported lenses, but playing around with the tubes and step down rings I was able to find a combination that worked.

 

Results. Well I compared the results from my three camera and lens combinations with some images I’d scanned using my old  Canoscan 9900f. On comparing them all the camera scans were better than the flatbed scanner. There was more detail in the highlights, there was finer detail in the whole image, subtle tonal roll off, and the images weren’t over sharpened.

 

This is an image I shot on slide film in 1986 and scanned using a Canoscan 9950f flatbed scanner.

 

Squat Door
Now viewed at 200%

 

Camera Scanning
Sony A7r2 with Sigma 105mm macro lens. 42Mp. Viewed at 200%.

 

Camera Scanning
Canon EOS6d with Canon 100mm macro lens. 20Mp Viewed at 200%.

 

Camera Scanning
Olympus EM1 mk ii with 60mm f2.8 macro lens. High Res mode. Equivalent to 80 Mp. Viewed at 200%.

 

Camera Scanning
Olympus EM1 mk ii with 60mm f2.8 macro lens. 20 Mp. Viewed at 200%.

 

Under The Olive Tree
A section of an Ilford SFX negative scanned with the Canoscan 9950f viewed at 200%

 

200%SonyA7r220240318-Cobdar-0226-Edit
The same negative scanned with the Sony A7rii and Sigma 105mm macro. There is more fine detail and a much gentler roll off of tones with greater dynamic range.

 

Cóbdar,
This is a section of an Ilford FP4 negative scanned by the Canoscan 9950f and viewed at 200%.

 

200%SonyA7rii20240318-Cobdar-0224-Edit
The same negative at 200% shot with the Sony A7rii and Sigma 105. Again note the finer detail and tonal range of the image. The camera is able to extract more information out of a negative.

 

 

Now you’ve got a memory card full of digitised film what happens next. Well I’m using Adobe Lightroom so I ingest the images into the Lightroom catalogue. What happens next depends upon the film stock. With black and white or slide film no special software is required and you can process entirely in Lightroom. It’s really not difficult. With black and white just invert the tonal curve and with colour slide it’s just a case of making small scale adjustments to the colour balance, unless the slide is old and experienced a colour shift then the adjustments are bigger and you may have to do contrast masking. With colour negative things are harder due to the orange colour masking. Now it is possible to do this manually yourself, but you’ll save yourself a lot of time and frustration if you get a Lightroom plugin to do it for you. I tried once doing it myself because I once considered myself a fairly competent colour darkroom worker. I mean with with red areas appearing cyan, greens appearing magenta, and blues appearing yellow, and vice versa just how hard could it be? After an hour of chasing my tail on one negative I happily plonked down the money for Negative Lab Pro. It’s easy to use and the money is well spent as it preserves sanity.


Conclusion

 

20240318-Beijing-0224-Edit
Ilford XP1 scanned with the Olympus EM1 mk ii and 60mm macro at the native 20Mp of the camera.

 

Six months and a couple of dozen films in how do I feel about camera scanning? Well to be honest if I could get a modern version of the Nikon Coolscan 5000 with up to date software, drivers and a USB C interface I’d buy it in a heartbeat (Nikon are you listening?). The reality is that there isn’t and it is unlikely to happen. So I guess I’m a camera scanner with reservations. With a good macro lens and good post processing skills it is a viable alternative to the dedicated film scanner and is streets ahead of what flatbed scanners can achieve.

 

20240318-Beijing-0231-Edit
Ilford XP2 scanned with the Olympus EM1 mk ii and 60mm lens at 20Mp.

 

As to JJC Film Digitising Adapter And LED Light Set I think it is good as a low cost entry to camera scanning.

Pros

  • Cheap – $130 AUD from Amazon
  • Quick to set up and quick to scan
  • Easy to use
  • Adapts well to a range of lenses and cameras
  • Better results than a flatbed scanner when using a camera with around 24Mp
  • Good documentation making it easy to get started

Cons

  • It can only scan 35mm film
  • On paper it is only compatible with a limited number of lenses
  • Black and white negatives and slide film can be processed with no special software, but colour negative will require a plugin such as Negative Lab Pro
  • Expensive if you don’t own a digital camera and macro lens
  • The negative and slide holders are sloppy as is the holder insertion slot on the LED. They wobble and rotate as you feed the film through. Also the locating notches on the holders are not accurate so it is not a quick or smooth process when you put the film through and it requires fiddling with to ensure accurate framing

For the time being I’ll continue using it and work around some of the quirks as the price was right. Let’s put it another way. My lab charges $11 to scan a roll of film. Scan 12 rolls of film and the scanner has paid for itself.

 

20240318-Fremantle-0225-Edit
Ilford Delta 400 scanned with a Canon 6d and Canon EF 100mm macro lens.

 

A Mixed Bag

Most of the time when I go out photographing I have something specifically in mind, but the other day my partner wanted to go to Lake Leschenaultia for a swim (I believe it’s now called “wild swimming” , but when I were a lad it was just called swimming). I was allocated driving duties and while the Beloved Significant Other was communing with the natural world via the water I was left to walk around the lake. I’d taken along with me one camera and one lens but I didn’t expect to get to use the combo as it was  well past the usual post dawn photo time so I just went with the flow and see what I could find.

 

Scented Sun Orchid, by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Scented Sun Orchid, Thelymitra macrophylla. I don’t really think of Lake Leschenaultia as a place for looking for orchids. You might see the occasional one but that would be it. On this visit I saw more that I’d ever done in over thirty years previously.

 

Wandering Percher by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Wandering Percher, Diplacodes bipunctata. There was this little clearing in among the trees that had lots of everlastings, Blue Leschenaultias and flowering grass trees and the sun light was breaking through lighting it up. Looking carefully there loads and loads of different species of dragonfly that were roosting on the plants waiting for the sun’s warmth to wake them up.

 

Wandering Percher, by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Wandering Percher, Diplacodes bipunctata . Lake Leschenaultia, Western Australia.

 

 

Tau Emerald by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Tau Emerald, Hemicordulia tau , Lake Leschenaultia, Western Australia.

 

Kwirlam by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
This Kwirlam or Purple Swamp Hen (Porphyrio porphyrio) gave a bit of a fright. I was photographing some dragonflies in the reed beds behind me when there was this angry squawking and then this psycho Purple Swamp Hen burst out from the vegetation and gave me what for. Normally they are very placid and I have had them come up to me and get in my camera bag looking for food. I don’t know what got this bird’s feathers ruffled. Lake Leschenaultia, Western Australia.

 

Clubbed Spider Orchid by Paul Amyes on 500px.com

Clubbed Spider Orchid, Caladenia longiclavata. Lake Leschenaultia, Western Australia.

 

One of the most significant developments, to my mind at least, to have come out of the mirrorless camera revolution has been that of lens design. Free from the constraints of the SLR mirror box the short flange distance has allowed manufacturers to make lenses, especially telephoto and telephoto zoom lenses, that have very short minimum focusing distance. My Panasonic 100-400mm lens can do double duty. It’s great for photographing birds, but is a very competent lens for close up work. It makes it easy to travel very lightly for casual trips out.