AI Armageddon…

… or perhaps not. Back in 1969 a journalist by the name of Bill Vaughan sagely wrote:

“To Err is Human; To Really Foul Things Up Requires a Computer”

The much hyped advent of AI technology has amplified this a thousand fold. Now I’ve written about how Ai is changing photography and not necessarily for the better.  The aspect I want to touch on today is how Ai is supposed to make things more efficient and easier and thereby increase productivity and therefore increase profits.

Despite the advent of micro stock photography causing the bottom to fall out of the stock photography business I still persist and up until this year I was making a small (and I mean very small) amount of sales. This year all that had changed and everything has ground to a halt. Initially I put it down to the fact that the market is over saturated – too many producers chasing too few sales. But on checking with the stock library I think I’ve discovered the real reason.

Now one of the crucial things you have to do when you submit images is caption and tag your work so the library’s search engine can find what a client is looking for. Of late the stock library I use adopted Ai technology to do the captioning and tagging automatically based upon what it recognises in the image. Fantastic! I’ve been liberated from the drudgery and tedium of captioning and tagging giving me more time to use for creating. Why isn’t the cash rolling in? Because the Ai gets it wrong. Very wrong. Below are a few examples.

 

This one is my favourite. “Close-up of squirrel on field. Western Australia Australia.”

 

This kangaroo lying in the shade of a bush became “Portrait of donkey standing on field”.

 

This is not a photo of a red tailed black cockatoo it is in fact a woodpecker!

 

The program seems to be pretty fixated on eagles.

 

Apparently this Little Corella perching on a branch is an eagle flying.

 

This Carnaby’s Black Cockatoo is also a flying eagle.

 

This perching white-faced heron is also a flying eagle.

 

Yet when given an image of a bird prey it either calls it a heron

“Close up of a heron…”

or ignores it completely.

‘Low angle view of tree against sky”

 

I think humans have nothing to fear from Ai. With all that harvesting of data from all the human knowledge ever created and it can’t tell the difference between a parrot and a squirrel. I’d want my money back if I’d invested in the technology. With this kind of accuracy, or  should I say inaccuracy, it does not bode well. Imagine presenting at the accident and emergency department at your local hospital and they use Ai to triage and make the initial diagnosis. You present with all symptoms of a cardiac arrest and the program tells you you’ve got haemorrhoids and sends you home with a tube of ointment. Not very assuring is it? This was all done so I could, and thereby the stock library, make more money. So far I’ve made none and the library has lost money because the system they bought to help sales isn’t making any.

A Picture is Worth …

… a thousand words but no money.

Views of Mount Bakewell
Mount Bakewell seen from the York Golf Course. Mount Bakewell is called Walwalling (place of weeping) in the Nyoongar language and features in their Dreamtime stories. Mount Bakewell is the most easterly extent of the Darling Ranges.

Earlier this week I was contacted by Moving Still Productions a video production company based in Perth Western Australia. They wanted to use the above photo in a production they were making. The email was pleasant with flattery about how beautiful the image is and what an important part it would play in the production. They were very generous with their offer, I would get a credit but no payment as there was no budget.

“We couldn’t afford to financially reimburse you, but we of course would credit you as the photographer. Your photo could really help us tell the story visually, and your assistance and generosity would be greatly appreciated.”

Vanessa Barnett, Senior Producer

Riiiiiight! So obviously the production crew are working for nothing as well? No there is a budget for the production crew. Ms Barnet went on to say in another email:

“We simply don’t have the budget to send a photographer to York, which is why we need your help! “

So it’s not that the photograph is really that good. You want my photo because it meets the criteria that you won’t have to spend any money thus maximizing your company’s profit. Thanks, but no thanks! I expect that Ms Barnett likes to be paid for her work, but it seems that she cannot see how that would extend to others.

Should I? Shan’t I?

There comes a time in every photographers life behind the lens when they get asked to do something for free. There are a whole heap of reasons why we apparently should in this post industrial, post modern and peak everything media interconnected world, but there are also a lot of reasons why we shouldn’t.

Looking back to the clubhouse from the court.

The reason why I’ve brought this up is that in the last couple of weeks two people have asked me to do some work pro bono (for the good not for the singer). I’ve done work for free before, namely work for some churches, a human rights organization, and some weddings where the photos were my wedding present for the bride and groom. So as you can see I do have form here. Unfortunately it has also been my experience that doing work for free can often lead to an unpleasant experience, and this tends to happen where you feel taken advantage of. The first job was a little complicated as it not only involved photography, but writing copy and graphic design as well. But what should have taken just an afternoon ended taking up the best part of the week as it happened that the person who “commissioned” didn’t have a clue and despite protestations to the contrary was completely computer illiterate and did not know what to do with the product and would n’t listen when told. To cap it all there was no acknowledgment or thanks for the work. The second job was a straight forward cover an event and provide some photos suitable for handing out to sponsors and to promote it in the future. Photos delivered the day after and they were followed by a very nice email thanking me for the work put in. Reading it left me with a nice warm fuzzy feeling and restored my faith in human nature.

58 Cadillac Coupe by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
58 Cadillac Coupe – York Motor Show

The problem is that we now live in an age where the camera is ubiquitous and we are bombarded with slick imaging every day. What this has done is devalue the work of the photographer because to coin an oft quoted phrase “We’re all photographers now”. There is also the perception that in the digital age photography is free as there is no film and processing to pay for. In fact the situation is such that even multi-nationals and  national media outlets are all expecting content providers to work for nothing with the premise that doing so  will “further” our careers. But if we work for free how do we pay for our equipment, and important stuff like food and housing? So should we work for free? I guess that we all do it at some time in our life, but I would like to say that when you do it do you feel taken advantage of or manipulated? If you do then you probably are and these are the freebies to avoid.