For wildlife photographers on a budget I happen to believe that micro four thirds (M4/3) has a lot to offer and represents incredible value. The micro in micro four thirds is a reference to the size and weight savings the system brings, it has no impact on the features and performance on offer.
Available Lenses
The Panasonic Leica DG Vario-Elmar 100-400mm f4-6.3 and the Olympus M.ZUIKO DIGITAL ED 75-300mm f/4.8-6.7 II lens are just two of the long lenses available for Micro Four Thirds wildlife enthusiasts.
The M4/3 system is now at the time of writing 15 years old and is, therefore, fully fleshed out. This means that there is plenty available on the second hand market. But, before we consider camera bodies let’s look at lenses first. Both Olympus (now OM Systems) and Panasonic provide a range of long lenses suitable for photographing wildlife. At the budget end there’s the Olympus 75-300mm II f4.8-6.7 and the Panasonic 100-300mm f4-5.6 which represent excellent value. On a M4/3 camera these two lenses have the same angle of view as a 150-600mm and 200-600mm lens respectively when used on a camera with a 35mm full frame sensor at a fraction of the weight and cost. The Olympus 75-300 can be found for around $500 AUD second hand (or $600 new) and the Panasonic 100-300 can be picked up for about $550 2nd hand ($1000 new). This means it is very feasible to put a good kit together for under $1000 AUD which is about $650 USD.
The Olympus 75-300mm lens delivers amazing performance for its price.
In the midrange category both companies offer 100-400mm zooms. The Olympus 100-400mm F5.0-6.3 IS sells for around $1500 2nd hand or $2200 new and the Panasonic Leica Vario-Elmar 100-400mm f4-6.3 sells for around thee $1200 mark second hand or $2200 new. This is for the original version. It has just been updated to make it compatible with tele-converters and will likely retail for around $2600 AUD.These two lenses give an angle of view equal to that of 200-800mm on a 35mm sensor in a very compact package.
Panasonic Leica DG Vario-Elmar 100-400mm f4-6.3 is a premium lens that be picked up on the secong hand market for a fraction of the price of full frame equivalents.
At the top end of town there are two lenses. The Olympus 300mm f4 IS which apparently is a gem of a lens and can be had for approx $2800 on the used market or $4000 new. Then we reach the stratosphere with the Olympus 150-400mmf4.5 IS PRO which retails for an eye watering price of $11500 new. Good luck in finding one new at a dealer as they are in short supply. I have seen a used one on a Japanese dealerswebsite going for $7500 and it was gone within a day.
The Panasonic G85 with the Panasonic 100-400mm lens compared to a Canon 6d with Sigma 150-600mm lens. The Panasonic combo is a fraction of the weight and has more reach.
So out of all these lenses I own the Olympus 75-300 and the Panasonic 100-400. Both of them have been very good, but with some caveats. The major criticism of the Olympus 75-300 is that it is soft at the long end. First I’d like to say get real! This is a budget lens. But, seriously this is a common complaint about zoom lenses especially at the budget end of the market. In my opinion,and based upon the example that I own, it is not as bad as people make out wide open and it improves if you stop down a bit. The pluses are it is amazingly small and light. I did intend to sell it when I got the Panasonic 100-400 but I kept it for those moments when I don’t want to carry the larger Panasonic ie when I’m out walking the dog. The Panasonic 100-400 is an amazing lens and I really enjoy using it. When it was first introduced there were complaints about it having an overly stiff zoom ring and it couldn’t be repaired. I’ve not experienced any problems and have used the lens extensively in all sorts of weather since I got in 2018. My only criticism of the 100-400 is that the lens based image stabilisation isn’t compatible with that of my Olympus cameras’s IBIS.
Click on the image to see full size
Click on the image to see it full size
Click on the image to see it full size.
Click on the image to see it full size
Camera Bodies
The Panasonic G85.
Once you’ve decided upon your lens then you can consider camera bodies. As things are at the time of writing I’ll be looking at the following camera which can be picked up easily second hand. The Olympus EM 1 mk I (approx $400 AUD), the Olympus EM1 mk ii, and the Panasonic G85. I own all three and think they all offer tremendous value for the wildlife photographer on restricted budget.
The Olympus EM1 is a very capable wildlife camera for those on a restricted budget.
Panasonic G85
Olympus EM1
Olympus EM1 mk ii
Year of Introduction
2016
2013
2016
Resolution
16 Mp
16 Mp
20 Mp
ISO range
200-25600
200-25600
200
Boosted ISO
100
100
64 and 100
IBIS
5 axis
5 axis
5 axis
File Formats
RAW and jpg for stills
AVCHD and MP4 for video
RAW and jpg for stills
H.264 and Motion jpg for video
RAW and jpg for stills
H.264 and Motion jpg for video
Auto Focus
Contrast only (DFD)
Multi area
Centre zone
Selective single point
Single AF
Continuous AF
Tracking AF
Face detection AF
Touch screen AF
Contrast and phase detect hybrid system.
Multi area
Centre zone
Selective single point AF
Single AF
Continuous AF
Tracking AF
Face detection
Touch screen AF
Contrast and phase detect hybrid system.
Multi area
Centre zone
Selective single point AF
Single AF
Continuous AF
Tracking AF
Face detection
Touch screen AF
Manual Focus Aides
Focus peaking
Focus peaking
Focus peaking
Focus Points
49
81
121
Maximum Shutter Speed
1/4000 mechanical
1/16000 electronic
1/8000 mechanical
1/32000 electronic
1/8000 mechanical
1/32000 electronic
Exposure Modes
Program, aperture priority, shutter priority, and manual.
22 Creative Control modes.
iAuto, Program, aperture priority, shutter priority, and manual.
22 scene modes and 12 Art filters.
iAuto, Program, aperture priority, shutter priority, and manual.
22 scene modes and 14 Art filters
Built In Flash
Yes
No
No
Dive Modes
Single frame
9 frames per second with the mechanical shutter and continuous AF. Up to 40 fps with the electronic shutter and the autofocus set to single point.
Single frame
6.5 fps with mechanical shutter and continuous AF. 11 fps with single AF and electronic shutter.
Single frame
Up to 18 fps with mechanical shutter and continuous AF. 60 fps with single AF and electronic shutter
Buffer
300 large jpgs,
45 RAW and RAW plus jpgs
50 large jpgs,
34 RAW
117 large jpgs,
84 RAW
Metering Modes
Multi zone, centre weighted and spot metering.
Multi zone, centre weighted, and spot metering.
Multi zone, centre weighted, and spot metering.
Video
4K up to 30 fps
HD up to 60 fps
HD up to 30 fps
Cinema 4k 24fps IPB
4K up to 30 fps
HD up to 60 fps
Storage media
1 x SD card slot UHS-II compatible
1 x SD card slot UHS-I compatible
2 x SD card slot with only 1 UHS-II compatible
Environmentally Sealed
Yes
Yes
Yes
Anti Aliasing Filter
No
No
No
Weight
505g with battery and card
497g with battery and card
574g with battery and cards
Battery CIPA Rating
330 shots
350 shots
440 shots
The Olympus EM1 mk ii is an extremely well specified camera that can be found for less than $1000 AUD on the used market making it somewhat of a bargin.
All three cameras feel good in the hand. The G85 has the easiest to navigate menu system. The Olympus menus cop a load of flack for being labyrinthine but they do allow a phenomenal amount of customisation and once these are set, your custom modes set up, and you use the Super Control Panel (SCP) you shouldn’t have to deep dive them often.
The Panasonic G85 with Panasonic Leica 100-400mm lens makes a very good wildlife video set up.
Which one should you get? Well that depends upon your budget and what you intend to do with the camera. If cash strapped the the EM1 is the one to go for. It’s a beautifully built camera that turns out a great performance. The only place is where it is lacking is video. If you shoot primarily stationary targets and some video capability is important I think the G85 is a great buy. It is only let down by its auto focus the DFD technology Panasonic uses just wasn’t as good for action as phase detection autofocus. Having said that I have used the camera to shoot some wildlife videos – you’ve just got to be patient and pick situations that the camera can cope with. If you’ve got the budget then the EM1 mk ii is the one to get.Not as accomplished in the video department as the G85 but it does produce a solid result and the AF for video and stills works quite well. You’d have to spend quite a bit more money to get better performance.
The Olympus EM1 is a very capable wildlife camera for those on a restricted budget. Pair it with the Olympus 75-300mm lens and you have a compact lightweight, but powerful combination.
Teleconverters are an affordable way of getting longer focal lengths, but with the advent of software such as Blow Up 3, Topaz Gigapixel Ai and Adobe Lightroom’s Super resolution do they still have a place in the wildlife photographers kit bag?
TLDR
The Canon Extender EF 2x ii.
A teleconverter is a tube containing a series of lens elements that goes between the camera body and the camera lens. They commonly come in the following strengths; x1.4, x2, and x3. They work by enlarging the centre part of the image. So for a full frame camera (36 x 24mm) a 1.4 teleconverter magnifies a rectangle of 25 x 17mm and a x2 teleconverter magnifies a rectangle of 18 x 12mm. So while the look like they’re increasing your focal length they are really just cropping your image and magnifying it. In photography the old adage “There’s No Such Thing As A Free Lunch” comes into play a lot, and no more so than here. The penalty for doing this is light loss. A x2 teleconverter looses 2 stops of light and a 1.4 teleconverter looses 1 stop. This is usually expressed in the following way:-
A 300mm f4 lens with a x1.4 teleconverter becomes a 420mm f5.6
A 300mm f4 lens with a x2 teleconverter becomes a 600mm f8
This means that to keep your shutter speed high enough to stop the motion of animals you have to use a higher ISO.
A 300mm f4 lens will make it difficult to photograph small shy animals, while adding a x2 teleconverter will make it an attractive proposition so you can see why they are so popular. Indeed if you take into consideration the cost of long lenses then you’ll see how they can look a screaming bargain. Lets look at the current range of Canon EF lenses for an example:-
The Canon EF 600mm f4 lens costs a whopping $21,000 AUD
The Canon EF 300mm f4 costs $2000 AUD
The Canon EF x2 extender mark iii costs $750 AUD
So for for $2750 you can get a combination that gives you a focal length600mm and saves you $18,250 AUD sounds pretty good, but are you getting the same optical performance? The short answer is no. The in depth answer is somewhat more complicated. When photographing birds in flight (BIF) a shutter speed of 1/2000 sec is the minimum I’d consider. So if were shooting with the 600mm f4 shooting wide open at f4 and an ISO of 1600 for the 300mm f4 plus x2 teleconverter I’d have a wide open aperture of f8 which would mean I’d have to use ISO 6400 which would impact on my image quality by having more noise and less dynamic range.
Remember that I said previously that the teleconverter magnifies the image, well in doing this it also magnifies any optical faults in the lens. Chromatic aberration is magnified – the coloured fringing on high contrast edges looks broader and more noticeable. If your lens isn’t tack sharp it will make it look softer. The more magnification a teleconverter has the more impact it has on the image quality. The perceived wisdom is that if you’re going to use one then the x1.4 varieties have the least impact on image quality and just don’t bother with the x3 ones.
Also remember what I said about light loss – it impacts the autofocus performance. In most cases it will just slow the subject acquisition, but in some cases (dependent on your camera and lens) it mean your camera won’t focus at all. When you put a x2 teleconverter on a lens with an aperture of f4 it becomes an f8 and some DSLRs won’t autofocus with an aperture of f8 and slower. So before you commit to this check your camera manufacturer’s website.
The Canon Extender EF 2x ii is a matched teleconverter and is designed to only fit certain Canon L lenses. Note how the lens elements stand proud of the lens mount.
In the case of teleconverters you really get what you pay for. With the camera manufacturers when they design a teleconverter they do so with only certain lenses in mind and they are designed to become part of the host lenses optical formula. You can see this when you look at the teleconverter as the optics protrude from the body and nestle into a space left for it at the back of the lens. The design goal is that the teleconverter should not cause any optical degradation. They are often described as “matched teleconverters” or “matched multipliers” and they won’t fit any other lens from that manufacturer. Cheap teleconverters are designed to work with any lens with that mount. They don’t have as many lens elements or the lens coatings of the more expensive camera marque models.
Model
Lens construction
Weather sealing
Compatability
Price (Australian Dollars)
Canon EF x2 extended iii
9 elements in 5 groups
Yes
All prime L lenses above 135mm, EF 70-200mm f2.8 L, EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L, EF 70-200mm f4 L, EF 100-400mm f4.5-5.6 IS L.
$750.00
Viltrox C-AF 2x ii AF 2.0 teleconverter for Canon EF
7 elements in 4 groups
No
All EF mount lenses except EF-S
$154.00
Fotodiox Pro Autofocus 2x teleconverter for Canon EF
4 elements in 3 groups
No
All EF mount lenses except EF-S
$100.00
Luckily Canon and Nikon have been making teleconverters for years so there are plenty on the secondhand market. Canon, for example, have since 1987 produced three versions of the x2 teleconverter. Their x1.4 teleconverters have been in production since 1988 and there are also three models. The first versions were pretty lacklustre but the mark ii was considerably better and can be had for around $300 AUD. The mark iii has even better performance and can be had for around $500 AUD. If you have a Sigma or Tamron lens they have also produced matched converters for some of their lenses. My Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 DG OS Contemporary is compatible with the Sigma Teleconverter TC-1401, which is weather sealed and will allow autofocus up to f8. So check the website of your lens’ manufacturer to see what is compatible.
I know the mist isn’t helping image quality here and nor is shooting 400ISO film, but the x2 teleconverter had a big impact on image quality. Dal Lake, Kashmir, India.
Working elephant heading off to work in the early morning mist in Chitwan National Park, Nepal.
My own history with teleconverters goes back to the late 1980s. I was heading off to back pack around India and Nepal for a year and wanted to take only two lens – a 35-105mm and a 75-210mm. Virtually couple of days before we were due to head off I went to my local camera store to pick up the 200 rolls of film I’d ordered and I thought I’d get a x2 teleconverter to give me a bit more reach when in the National Parks. So I bought a Vivitar x2 teleconverter for £25 and set off without knowing what I’d actually bought. When I got back and processed the film I was shocked to see how soft the images taken with it were. It was as if someone had used a belt sander on the front lens element. What I’d done is put a bad teleconverter on a mediocre zoom lens. This was the experience of a lot of people at the time and it was why teleconverters got such a bad reputation. In 2004 I started a project photographing the Western Australian rodeo scene and I decided to get a Canon 100-400mm lens to help with this. At the time they were like hens teeth in Australia and my dealer suggested getting a Canon x2 converter for my Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens. I was very skeptical because of my previous experience, but the sales person said if I wasn’t happy with the results I could bring it back and get a refund. When I looked at the first images taken with it I couldn’t believe how sharp they were. This convinced me when I changed to the Olympus micro four thirds system to get the Olympus x1.4 teleconverter to go with the 40-150mm f2.8 lens. I use that combination a lot to photograph wild flowers and I’m extremely happy with it.
Taken on the Canon 5d with Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens with x 2 teleconverter at 400mm f5.6.Steer roping competition. Boddington Rodeo, Western Australia.
Taken with an Olympus OMD EM 1 mk ii with Olympus m.Zuiko 40-150mm f2.8 and a x 1.4 Olympus teleconverter at 210mm f4. Winter donkey orchid, Diuris brumalis. Woottating, Western Australia.
Since then, however, a new alternative has come up and that is using AI powered software to enlarge images. Exposure Software’s Blow Up was one of the first, Topaz Labs has Gigapixel AI which are plugins for Photoshop and Lightroom. Adobe now has Super Resolution as part of its Enhance function in Lightroom. GigaPixel is $99 USD, Blow Up is $125 AUD and Super Resolution comes with your Lightroom subscription. So do these make teleconverters obsolete? If you want the best image quality should you even use any of these options?
Blow Up 3 is one of several apps that can enlarge, and selectively crop and enlarge images with apparently no loss in image quality.
Lightroom Super Resolution is a part of its Enhance function in Lightroom.
The test will take a Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens and test it with the canon EF x2 extender ii and compare it to images taken without the converter, and then without the converter but enlarged using Blow UP and LightRoom Super Resolution. Then I’ll test the Olympus 40-150mm f2.8 Pro lens in the same way but using the Olympus m.Zuiko Digital 1.4 x Teleconverter MC-14.
Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L and Canon EF x2 Extender ii
The Canon Extender EF 2x ii shown next to the Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens. The extendinded lens leement of the converter are designed to be placed inside the body of the lens.
Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L with and without a teleconverter comparison using a lens chart wide open.
Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L with and without a teleconverter comparison using a lens chart f5.6.
First off we’ll look at the lens sharpness chart. Wide open with out the extender the centre of the chart is a little soft and is lacking contrast. When adding the teleconverter the results are a little softer. Stopping the lens down to f4 and f8 (with the extender) the results are better with a bit more sharpness and contrast. The shot without the teleconverter is still sharper than the one with. Finally two stops down from wide open is generally considered to be where optimum performance is found and here we see that f11 the 70-200 and teleconverter have attained their best result, but it is still softer and has less contrast than the 70-200mm on its own.
Comparing images taken with the Canon 70-200mm f2.8 IS L using a teleconverter, Blow Up 3 and Lightroom Super Resolution.
Lens charts don’t really tell the whole story so we’ll look at the results we got with Gazza the Galah. The camera was set to aperture priority at 100 ISO and the aperture was one stop down from wide open (f4 and f8 respectively). The photos were all taken from the same position with the camera on a tripod, and the results are interesting.
Obviously in the shot with the teleconverter Gaza is larger, and that is what we wanted to see.
The bokeh in the shot with the teleconverter looks smoother and more pleasing. All we are seeing is the magnification of the out of focus areas and it makes appear smoother.
The shot without the teleconverter has more fine detail.
The shutter speed without the teleconverter was 1/200 sec and with 1/50 sec so a light loss of exactly 2 stops.
Just as an afterthought I decided to see how this all stacked up against the Sigma 150-600 at 400mm. The Sigma delivers a much better performance that the Canon 70-200mm with teleconverter so no surprise there.
Comparing the image quality from the Canon 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens with x2 teleconverter against the Sigma 150-600mm Contemporary set at 400mm.
Next I took the shots taken with the 70-200mm without the teleconverter and put them through Blow Up and Super Resolution and in both cases the results from the lens with the teleconverter were better.
Olympus m.Zuiko 40-150mm f2.8 with Olympus 1.4 Teleconverter MC-14
The Olympus MC-14 teleconverter.
Like the Canon Extender x2 the Olympus MC14 is designed to be used by a few of the Olympus Pro lenses, and they have room for that protruding lens assembly of the teleconverter to fit inside the lens body.
I basically ran the same tests as above and found that the Olympus combination was very consistent in that the teleconverter had only a marginal impact on image quality.When compared to a shot taken with Panasonic Leica 100-400mm set to 210mm the 100-400 resolves more fine detail.
Olympus 40-150mm f2.8 Pro with and without a teleconverter comparison using a lens chart with the lens wide open.
Olympus 40-150mm f2.8 Pro with and without a teleconverter comparison using a lens chart with the lens at f5.6.
Comparing the image quality of the Olympus 40-150mm f2.8 pro lens with the results from the Olympus x 1.4 teleconverter, Blow Up2 and Lightroom Super Resolution.
Comparing the image quality from the Olympus 40-150mm f2.8 pro with 1.4 x teleconverter with the Panasonic Leica 100-400mm lens at 210mm.
Looking at the results when run through Blow Up and Super Resolution we see that the results from the teleconverter were a tiny bit better with more micro contrast. The image produced by Lightroom’s Super Resolution look over sharpened withmoirés evident and artefacts in the shadow areas. The shot for the lens and teleconverter looks more pleasing.
Conclusion
The software solution was very disappointing and I would not go out of my way to buy Blow Up or Topaz Labs Gigapixel Ai. The Lightroom Super Resolution comes as part of Lightroom and I would only use it in dire situations.
The results from the teleconverters showed that they are worth having, but they won’t give the best image quality. This really depends upon three things:
The quality of the lens
That you are using a matched teleconverter
The magnification of the teleconverter. 1.4 teleconverters have less impact upon image quality than x2 teleconverters.
The best results were naturally from the lenses without teleconverters.
For the budget conscious photographer who has a good quality lens then it is certainly worth trying a matched teleconverter if you can’t afford a longer lens.
This is the second part of an ongoing series called “Birds On A Budget”. It really should be “Can You Do Wildlife Photography On A Limited Budget?”, but that’s not as catchy or succinct.
TLDR
When looking for secondhand cheaper alternatives for wildlife photography it is all too easy to get preoccupied with specifications sheets without looking at the whole picture. It can mean that just because Camera X does have a specific feature that Camera Y has then it must be inferior. Well let’s look at an example.
The cameras I’ve chosen to look at are the Canon EOS 80d and the Sony A6500. Both were introduced in 2016, both have 24Mp sensors, and both can be found second hand for about the same price. The 80d is a DSLR and is probably considered retro-tech now and the A6500 being mirrorless is seen as the more up to date technology. Let’s see how the specs compare.
Sony A6500
Canon EOS 80d
Introduced
December 2016
February 2016
Resolution
24 Megapixels
24 Megapixels
Camera type
Mirrorless interchangeable lens camera
DSLR
Sensor size
APSC (23.5 x 15.6mm)
APSC (22.5 x 15mm)
In Body Image Stabilisation
Yes
No
ISO range
100-256,000 which can be extended to 512,000
100-16,000 which can be extended to 25,600
Dynamic Range
13.67 EV
13.17 EV
Autofocus
425 AF points covering the whole sensor.
On sensor phase detect AF supplemented with contrast detect AF.
Multi area, centre zone and single point modes.
Tracking
Single AF
Continuous AF
Face detection
Live view
45 AF points clumped in the centre of the frame when using the optical viewfinder
Phase detect AF
Multi area, centre zone and single point modes
Tracking
Single AF
Continuous AF
Face detect in live view only
Live view AF with ‘Dual Pixel CMOS AF’ which means every pixel can be used for phase detect auto focus
Rear LCD panel
Tilting 3 inch touch screen with 921,600 dots
Fully articulating 3 inch touch screen with 1,040,000 dots
Viewfinder
Electronic viewfinder with 100% coverage with 1.07 magnification (0.71 x 35mm) and 2,359,296 dots.
Optical viewfinder with 100% coverage at 0.95 magnification.
Shutter speed range
30 sec – 1/4000 sec
30 sec – 1/8000 sec plus ‘B’
Built in flash
Yes
Yes
Flash synchronisation speed
1/160 sec
1/250 sec
Frames per second
11 frames per second in both mechanical and electronic shutter modes with no live view and 8 fps with live view.
7 frames per second using the optical viewfinder and 2.4 fps when using live view.
Buffer
100 frames in RAW or RAW + jpg
300 frames in jpg only
When using the optical viewfinder:
Unlimited frames at 7fps in jpg
24 frames in RAW
20 framesin RAW and jpg
When using live view:
Unlimited in jpg
Unlimited in RAW
36 images in RAW + jpg
Metering modes
Multi-zone
Centre weighted
Spot
Highlight weighted
Multi-zone
Centre weighted
Spot
Video
Available codecs AVCHD, XAVCS, H264, MP4
4K (3840 x 2160) 30p, 25p, 24p
HD (1920 x 1080) 120p, 100p, 60p, 50p, 30p, 25p, 24p
Available codecs MPEG-4, H264 with a choice of all I or IPB
HD (1920 x 1080) 60p, 50p, 30p, 25p, 24p
Storage
SD card (UHS-1)
SD card (UHS-1)
Connectivity
USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec)
3.5mm microphone port
Micro HDMI
WiFi – 802.11b/g/n + NFC
Remote control via a smartphone
Tethered shooting to a computer
USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec)
3.5mm microphone port
3.5mm headphone port
802.11/b/g/n with NFC
Wired remote control
Remote control via a smart phone
Tethered shooting to a computer
Battery
NP-FW50 battery with CIPA rating of 350
LP-E6N battery with a CIPA rating of 960
Weather sealing
Yes
Yes
Construction
Magnesium alloy
Composite construction with an alloy chassis with plastic shell
Weight
453g
730g
Dimensions
120 x 67 x 53mm
139 x 105 x 79mm
Other functions
Inbuilt Timelapse function
On the whole the Sony seems the better camera as it has an electronic viewfinder that provides realtime exposure feedback, better video capabilities, better ISO range, better dynamic range and In Body Image Stabilisation (IBIS) all in a smaller and lighter package.
Sony A6500 real world usage
The A6500 body is not overly small, but the button and dial placements leave a little to be desired. There are twin control dials but they are both on the rear of the camera meaning your thumb has to do double duty. To me the lack of a front dial around or near to the shutter button is a big handicap. Now when it comes to using Sony cameras this is not my first rodeo. I have an A7r and A7r ii so I am quite familiar with the idiosyncrasies of the menu system. But, having said that I still find them labyrinthine and illogically laid out and the paucity of physical buttons and dials means that menu diving on the A6500 is quite frequent.
There is only one SD slot on the A6500 and although I prefer 2 slots it is not a big consideration. The SD card slot is located in the battery compartment and this is major pain. Even when shooting handheld it is fiddly to change cards and shooting on a tripod makes it downright frustrating. Often I find myself having to take the battery out to access the SD card. Speaking of the the battery compartment the battery in itself is hopeless. If I go out for the day shooting photos then I have to take 2 spares and if I intend to shoot any video I take at least 4. Luckily they are readily available and reasonably priced.
The LCD EVF on the left side of the body is good – for its time it is nice and detailed while being responsive. The rear LCD is of the flip up variety. I prefer the fully articulated type but it’s no big deal and I can work with both. The quality of the screen is abysmal – it is very hard to see in bright sunshine and it becomes very dim when shooting 4K video making it all but useless. Sony claims it is a touch screen but it is very limited in function. It can only be used for selecting AF points and nothing else and the implementation of that is pretty poor as it is laggy when working well and down right unresponsive when it isn’t. I’ve been in situationswhere I’m repeatedly touching the screen and the focus point is not moving meaning I’ve lost the shot.
Speaking of autofocus it works very well. Having AF points spread over the whole sensor is great which means you can really concentrate on composition. The AF is very quick and locks on moving subjects. Another nice feature is that you can link spot metering to the active AF point. The electronic shutter is another feature that I really like and although the rolling shutter is quite pronounced when shooting moving subjects I like to use it with shy wildlife as it means I won’t disturb it. In Body Image Stabilisation (IBIS) is fantastic. While not as good as that on other cameras I’ve used (Olympus and Panasonic) it works well and is very welcome when shooting handheld video.
Image quality is impressive. Shooting RAW the files are very malleable in processing as long as you get your exposure right. The high ISO performance is quite impressive and the dynamic range is such that I don’t feel the need to blend exposures to get details in the shadows and highlights when shooting scenes with a high subject brightness range. When shooting video the story is a little complicated. The 4K is nice and detailed and looks very good, but it is only 8-bit and so can’t be pushed too much in post. The provision of flat profilesSLOG 2 and 3 is good to have when shooting contrasty scenes outside. Shooting HD the footage is softer and doesn’t look so good. It’s OK but I prefer to shoot 4k and downsize to HD on export. Focus peaking, zebras, and a live histogram are features that make shooting video easier and it is good to see them on the A6500.
All these points are well documented so why did I get the A6500? Well I’d switched from Canon full frame cameras to a Sony A7r ii a couple of years ago and I’ve really enjoyed the whole experience. Initially I was using adapted lenses but gradually I switched over to native Sony EF mount lenses with the exception of my 150-600mm. Just for giggles I started doing some bird photography with the A7r ii and I found myself using the crop mode a lot which gave me a 15 Mp image. After 18 months of doing this I thought well why not get a second hand A6500 and have a quicker camera that has electronic shutter and more importantly has 24 Mp. I was also toying with the idea of shooting more wildlife video and the A6500 fit the bill for that as well. Overall I persevere with the A6500 because I like the final image, but it is a real effort as I just find the camera so awkward to use.
Nidoolyorong or Black-fronted Dotterel (Elseyornis melanops). Monger’s Crossing, York, Western Australia. Sony A6500 with Sigma MC-11 and Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 OS lens.
Pacific Black Duck (Anas superciliosa) duckling. Avon River, York, Western Australia. Sony Alpha a6500, Sigma MC-11, Sigma 150-600mm f/5-6.3 DG OS HSM Contemporary.
A juvenille White-faced Heron (Ardea novaehollandiae) roosting in a dead sheaoak tree. Monger’s Crossing, York, Western Australia. Sony A6500, Sigma MC-11 and Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 OS lens.
Canon EOS 80d real world use
During the later part of the Film Age (1822 to 2000) I used Olympus OM4s, but by 2003 I could no longer get them repaired and my father-in-law generously gave me a Canon EOS3 SLR. Whenever I pick up any Canon camera from the EOS 650 introduced in 1987 to the Canon EOS 5d iv introduced in 2016 I feel immediately familiar with the control layout, the handling and the operation of the camera. Canon, for all their faults, of which there are many, has always produced well sorted nice handling cameras. The 80d is no different. The camera fits perfectly in the hand, the buttons and dials are well laid out and intuitive to use. This attention to the user experience extends to the camera menus which are simply and logically laid out.
Like the Sony A6500 there is only one card slot, but it is positioned on the side of the handgrip behind its own door. It is easy to access under all scenarios. The battery is the venerable Canon LP-E6 and it lasts forever. Sure this is partly down to the fact that SLRs draw less power than mirrorless cameras, however, it is also gutsier at 7.2V, 1800mAh and 13Wh compared to 7.4V, 1080mAh and 7.3Wh of the Sony NP-FW50 which is in the A6500. The upside of this is that I’ve rarely used more than one battery for a full day of shooting.
The optical viewfinder is nice and large and clear. Although I now prefer EVFs because of the realtime exposure feedback the 80ds viewfinder is very pleasant to use. The rear LCD screen is of the fully articulated flippy flappy type which I really like not just for shooting video but also for shooting landscapes and macro in the vertical orientation.The screen has a teensy-weeny bit more resolution than the A6500s, but more importantly it is bright and clear when using in bright sunlight. It is also a touchscreen– you can control the camera, go through the menus and review images with it. While there is no joystick to select autofocus points you can use the screen to do this and it is responsive. While we’re talking about autofocus it helps to view it as two cameras in one body. Using it as a SLR with the optical viewfinder the 45 AF points are all centrally grouped. If when composing an image your subject is outside of that area then you have to focus and recompose. The autofocus is quick and with a well calibrated lens very accurate. When using the rear LCD screen in “Live View” the performance is like a mirrorless camera with every pixel on the sensor doing double duty as an AF point. The 80d has face detection that works well. Although how responsive this is will depend on the lens – those with STM motors work the best. I did consider just using the camera in the live view mode but there is a significant performance hit with the maximum frames per second of 7 reduces to 2.4. I also find it hard to track birds using the rear screen and a super telephoto lens. Another much missed feature is In Body Image Stabilisation so you have to depend upon the IS in the lens if it has it.
The image quality is good – a real leap up from the 18Mp sensor that Canon seemingly used forever. But with that said it is not as good as that in the A6500. The dynamic range of the Canon 80d is 13.17EV as opposed to the 13.67EVof the Sony as measured by DXO. The amount is paltry and in real life terms negligible. If we look at ISO performance and particularly noise then both cameras are fairly equal up to ISO 800. At 1600 the A6500 is about a stop better and at 3200 is 1 1/2 stops better. The highest maximum native ISO on the 80d is 16,000 and this can be extended to 25,600. The A6500 tops out natively at 256,000 which can be extended by a stop to 512,000. In reality the highest ISOs on both cameras aren’t much chop, on the 80d the furthest I’d go is 6400 and the A6500 can be used up to 12800. But having said this I am using Topaz DeNoise AI to clean the images up. Your tolerances to noise maybe a lot lower than mine. If you shoot RAW colour output is pretty much the same, you should be able to get the results you want in post. Shooting jpgs well if you like punchy reds and warmer looking images then you’ll prefer the Canon. For video the lack of 4k can be seen as a major drawback. I shoot 4k and then in post will often crop in because I’ll output the final file as HD. The HD video on the 80d is an improvement on the previous 18 and 20Mp sensors that Canon used. It is also better than the HD from the Sony. There is no flat profile on the camera, but I solved that by installing the Cinestyle Profile from Technicolor and I am getting great results. The video output is again 8-bit so can’t be pushed around too much in post.
When shooting video the lack of an EVF is a bit of hindrance, but, thankfully the rear LCD screen is of high quality. The touch screen implementation makes operating the camera a doddle. Another feature I really like is the ability to create a ‘My Menu’ spread over three pages and I’ve made one of the pages dedicated to video. The AF in video works much better than I expected but again this is really lens dependent. While it is quick to acquire and initially lock on it does have the annoying tendency to drift off the subject and onto the background. You need to keep taping the touch screen to maintain focus on the subject. Unfortunately Canon doesn’t provide any focus peaking for help with manual focusing and no zebras to warn about clipping. Also Canon’s pre-amps are not the best.
I bought the Canon EOS 80d with the sole intention of testing cameras at various price points to see how they’d fare for nature and wildlife photography. I fully intended to sell the camera once I’d finished with it. Now having used it for several months it has become one of my favourite cameras (my favourite being the Olympus EM 1 mk ii). The 80d is such a well thought out camera that it is above all fun to use to use. No it’s not a hybrid camera as the video implementation doesn’t perform well enough, but it is certainly an excellent tool for the photographer on a budget. It has certainly piqued my interest in the 90d which addresses some of the limitations of the 80d.
Ngoolyak or Carnaby’s Black-cockatoo (Calyptorhynchus latirostris). Yanchep National Park, Western Australia. Canon 80d with Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 OS lens.
Djer-djer or Splendid Fairy-wren (Malurus splendens). Yanchep National Park, Western Australia. Canon 80d with Sigma 150-600mm f5-6.3 OS lens.
Yongka or Western-grey Kangaroo(Macropus fuliginosus). Yanchep National Park, Western Australia.
Ngalkaning or Nankeen Night Heron (Nycticorax caledonicus subsp mannillenis). York, Western Australia.
Conclusion
The thing that became very apparent when using both of these cameras is that user experience plays an important part. Canon and Sony have very different design philosophies. Sony is more a technology company and looks to throw as much technology into a product without any consideration of the users experience when using it. Canon take a conservative approach to technology – nothing cutting edge – and look to bundle it in a product that is pleasant to use and reliable. Both cameras are very suitable for nature and wildlife photography, but the user experience is very different. The technology of the A6500 is negated by poor design and handling. I feel I’m fighting the A6500 every inch of the way to get it to work and that is miserable. The 80d overcomes its shortcomings by being a joy to use – it disappears allowing me to concentrate on photography. Unfortunately when it comes to wildlife videography both are wanting. The Canon needs more technology in the form of 4k video, focus peaking and waveforms. The A6500 needs a better touchscreen, a better rear LCD panel and better menus to make it more useful.
So when buying a camera, whether it be new or second hand, while the specification sheet maybe useful as a guide I think more attention should be given to the ergonomics. What does it feel like in the hand? What’s it feel like to use? These are the questions that need to be addressed rather than how many megapixels or how much dynamic range.
The title is really an exercise in alliteration. It really should be “Can You Do Wildlife Photography On A Limited Budget?”, but that’s not as catchy or succinct. I used to think it was impossible. I thought to be a wildlife photographer you needed deep pockets to be able to afford the cameras and lenses. The photo review sites would have you believe that you need to drop unto $10K AUD on a camera body and up to $24K AUD on a lens to be in with a chance of taking a decent photo. Then you had to have the wonga to be able to travel to Africa, Antartica etc to actually find animals worthy of being photographed. About twenty years ago my sister tried to encourage me to enter the BBC Wildlife Photographer Of The Year competition my response was that I didn’t have the money for the equipment let alone alone being able to travel to a suitable location.
Richard and Cherry Kearton photographing a birds nest.
Twenty years later my views have radically changed. What changed them was the confluence of learning about two of the pioneers of wildlife photography and the digital camera revolution. The photographers were Cherry Kearton (1871-1927) and his brother Richard (1862-1928) the naturalist and writer. They were very early pioneers of wildlife photography and they published the first natural history book entirely illustrated with wild photographs in 1895. Their 1898 book “With Nature And A Camera: being the adventures of a field naturalist and an animal photographer” illustrated with 160 photos was a best seller and inspired many people to become wildlife photographers. A very young David Attenborough attended one of their film lectures and in an interview to The Guardian Newspaper said “It captured my imagination and made me dream of travelling to far-off places to film wild animals.” (Vidal, J; The Guardian 4th December 2021).In their book the two brothers list what it takes to be a wildlife photographer:
“The great points about successful natural history photography are: the possession of suitable apparatus to work with, an aptitude for taking care in stalking timid creatures and plenty of patience and determination to wait for and get what is wanted in spite of obstacles.”
p.334 Kearton, R and Kearton, C; With Nature and a Camera, 1898, Cassel, London.
The “suitable apparatus” was a half plate (4¾ × 6½ in or 120mm × 165mm) Dallmeyer camera with a pneumatically controlled silent shutter for still subjects and a large quantity of hemp rope for scaling cliffs.
The “suitable apparatus” was a half plate (4¾ × 6½ in or 120mm × 165mm) Dallmeyer camera with a pneumatically controlled silent shutter for still subjects and miniature plate camera (probably 3 1/4” x 4 1/4” glass plates with a 5 1/4” f8 lens) for birds in flight. There was no autofocus with bird recognition AI. No 40 fps. Nothing under 4Kg in weight and certainly no endless digital images on a memory card. The plates had a sensitivity of 2 to 25 ISO. They’d be lucky to carry a dozen glass plates and take one picture every 2 minutes. They initially started just photographing the fauna of their native Yorkshire in their days off often sleeping in hedges or barns. No luxury safaris with 5 star accommodation and the convenience of modern jet travel.
No memory cards giving unlimited shooting for the Keaton’s. This is a box of Ilford photographic glass plates.
The digital camera revolution has meant for the last twenty years camera and lens manufactures have brought out new products with amazing technological innovations every year. This has meant that the second hand market has been flooded with equipment as photographers unload their “obsolete” stuff so they can buy the new stuff only to do the same 12 months later. This now means that there is a wealth of extremely capable second hand equipment out there to suit every budget.
Advances in in digital photographic technology has meant that there is a plethora of second hand equipment for sale.
TLDR
Needs Versus Wants
This is quite important as it will help us decide on equipment and set a budget. For instance if all you want to do is post some photos on social media then pretty well any interchangeable lens DSLR or mirrorless camera released in the last 20 years will suffice. If you want to print photos up to A3 in size then a 12Mp camera is adequate. If HD video and 4K video are important then that sets another parameter. It’s nice to day dream about having top of the line equipment such as a Sony A1 and a Sony 600mm f4 lens, but that combination will set you back $27000 AUD new and won’t be had for thrift shop prices second hand. But, say you want to print up to A3 it is possible with a bit of careful shopping on EBay or GumTree to get a DSLR with an APSC sized sensor and a 75-300mm lens for less than $500 AUD second hand.
I basically find that deciding on the lens is the most important part of the exercise and you really should aim to put most of your budget to that. So what are we looking for?
Sensor size
Full frame (36x24mm)
APSC (23.6 x 15.7mm or 22.2 x 14.8mm [Canon cameras only])
Micro Four Thirds (17.3 x 13mm)
Minimum Focal length
400mm
300mm
300mm
Best Case Scenario
600mm
600mm
400mm
The focal length will determine how close you need to get to your subject. The shorter the focal length the closer you will have to get. Having said that a shorter focal length is not a handicap because you’ll have to learn bushcraft so you can approach animals and that is a very good skill to have in this game and it’ll also stand you in good stead if you get a longer lens later on down the track.
You can use zoom lenses or primes. A prime lens is a fixed focal length, whereas a zoom lenscovers a range of focal lengths such as 75-300mm, or 100-400, or 150-600mm. In theory a prime lens will give better image quality and have a larger maximum aperture value which will let more light in. The down sides are that primes are usually more expensive and being a fixed focal length means that if your subject gets too close (it does happen more often that you’d think) you won’t be able to take a picture. Zooms offer flexibility in that you’re not stuck at one focal length, but the trade off is that they’re not as optically good as primes at the cheaper end and the maximum aperture value isn’t as great meaning that you may have to stop shooting as the light goes down.
A comparison of the common camera sensor sizes.
Now as soon as you tell another photographer what you’re planning to do they will inevitably tell you that you should get a camera with a full frame sensor as you’ll get a whole heap of benefits over the other smaller sensors. Now if we just content ourselves with reading spec sheets maybe, but out in the real world other things come into play. You want to photograph a bird that is 20cm long and fill the frame with it, so that’ll mean getting 5m away from it. To do that with a full frame camera you’ll need a focal length of 800mm, with an APSC camera 600mm and with a micro four thirds camera 400mm. There is a magnification factor when comparing the focal lengths on the different sensor sizes. It is x1.5 (or 1.6 for Canon) for APSC and x2 for micro four thirds. We’ll look at this comparing three common focal length ranges for the three sensor sizes.
75-300mm
100-400mm
150-600mm
Full Frame (36x24mm)
75-300mm
100-400mm
150-600mm
APSC (23.6 x 15.7mm)
(22.2 x 14.8mm Canon cameras)
112-450mm full frame equivalent
120-480mm full frame equivalent when used on a Canon APSC camera
150-600mm full frame equivalent
160-640mm full frame equivalent when used on a Canon APSC camera
225-900mm full frame equivalent
240-960mm full frame equivalent when used on a Canon APSC camera
Micro Four Thirds (17.3 x 13mm)
150-600mm full frame equivalent
200-800mm full frame equivalent
300-1200mm full frame equivalent
So a smaller sensor will mean you don’t need very long lenses and that is good because they are expensive. Shorter lenses have the advantage of being lighter which is good when carrying stuff in the bush.
Canon EOS 300d body with Canon EF 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
I started my nature photography using a Canon EOS 300d with a Canon EF 75-300mm lens. The camera has an APSC sensor so that gave me almost enough reach to fill frame with my 20cm bird at 5m. It did me well until I decided that I wanted to invest more into the hobby. So if your budget is really tight I would recommend getting either a Canon of Nikon APSC camera and a 75-300mm lens as the bare minimum, and we’ll look at what’s available a bit later on.
Memory cards are now very cheap. Develop a strategy for keeping them safe while working in the field.
The other thing to consider is that when you buy a camera and lens you also have to budget for batteries and memory cards. First things first; when looking at memory cards over the last 20-25 years there have been roughly ten types of memory card and many of them have gone obsolete so when buying a camera I would suggest that buying one with a commonly available card such as Secure Digital Card or SD Card. Similarly with batteries, make sure batteries are easily obtainable. With both cards and batteries try to buy the best you can afford and I’ll expand on this a bit further later on. Buying second hand also means that there is a chance where you’ll be able to buy the camera with spare batteries, a memory card, strap and possibly some form of bag as a package. Just make sure you’re getting things you actually want and are not paying more than if you to buy each item separately.
All the cameras I’ll be talking about are cameras I’ve owned or used. They’re not recommendations they are to give an idea of what’s about and where possible I’ll suggest equivalent models from other manufacturers.
Bargin Basement
You’ve got next to no money. OK a bit of a draw back, but not insurmountable. Back in the dim dark days of digital photography there existed a class of camera that you don’t hear much about now – the bridge camera. They are a cross between a point and shoot compact and an SLR. You get a wide range zoom lens with a small body. They were popular with enthusiasts in the early noughties as more serious cameras were way way expensive. Every manufacturer offered at least one some several at different price points. Sony and Panasonic still make a few models and they range in price from $500 to $2400 AUD new. But on the second hand market that’s where things get interesting. You can pick up something for less than $50.
What you are looking for is camera models with the terms “UltraZoom“, “superzoom” or “mega zoom” in the model name. Ideally look for something with at least an 8x zoom, better yet 10x or 15x. The more zoom the bigger your subject will be in the final image.
Olympus Camedia C-720 Ultra Zoom
Olympus Camedia C-720 UltraZoom bridge camera.
The Olympus C-720 was introduced in 2002 and is fairly typical of models from that era. It has a whopping 3 Megapixels and an 8x zoom range (24x if digital zoom is switched on but it is crap). It’s small, light, and cheap. Typically expect to pay about $15 to $35 AUD for one. What makes it ideal is that the camera runs off 4x AA batteries which are plentiful and cheap. The downsides are that it takes a SmartMedia memory card which while obsolete can still be bought. The downside is that you will probably spend more on the memory card than the camera. Another problem is that the largest capacity card is 128MB which can hold 14 photos at the best quality TIFF setting, 58 in SHQ jpg, 170 HQ, 196 in SQ1, and 206 in SQ2. The last two come at a smaller resolution. Although 3MP is a bit limiting you can print a postcard sized print comfortably and print an A4 sized print at a stretch.
In use it is not a speed demon, it takes about four seconds to power up. When shooting in sports mode with medium quality jpgs the camera can manage to shoot at 1 fps for a total of 15 frames. The autofocus is slow and very noisy. The top shutter speed is 1/1000 and the maximum ISO, or sensitivity, is 400. At 400 ISO the noise is bad and prevents you from recoding fine details. This is not a camera with which to take pictures of fast moving subjects in low light. But in good light, with a heap of patience and an understanding of the cameras limitations you can get some pictures. Whether you enjoy the process or not will depend upon your outlook.
Little Corellas taken with the Olympus C720UZ camera.
When light levels fall the inadequacies of the C720UZ are quite apparent. The noise patter prevents detailed images.
Canon EOS 300d with a 75-300mm lens
Canon EOS 300d body.
If you can swing to $250-300 AUD there are better alternatives than the very old bridge cameras. The Canon Canon EOS 300D (Canon EOS Digital Rebel in North America and the Canon EOS Kiss Digital in Japan) was the first real consumer budget DSLR when released back in 2003. For $60-100 you should be able to find a body only. I’d look to team this up with a 70-300mm zoom lens. With a bit of careful searching the combo should come in at under $300. Alternatives from that period going for around that are the Canon EOS 10d and the Nikon D100. They’ll be a little bit more money but they have slightly better features. The downside to them is that they were often used professionally and so they might not have much life left in them.
Canon EF 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens
So with the 300d what do you get for your money. Well you get a 6MP camera that takes Canon EF mount lenses – one of the biggest ecosystems of lenses in the world which means lots of choice at a variety of prices. Canon themselves have made an assortment of 75-300mm lenses over the last 30 years and you should be able to pick up something for $120 AUD and the one I’m looking at with Image Stabilisation for about $220. Sigma and Tamron are third party lens makers and you can find their versions for around the $100 mark.
The good points of the 300d are that it’s cheap, batteries (Canon BP-511a) and memory card (Compact Flash) are still available. The camera has a 6MP sensor that produces very nice A4 prints and it is very simple to use. The downside is that the camera was built to a budget and it is not possible to shoot in Continuous Autofocus when shooting RAW, the buffer is 2.5 frames per second for 4 frames, and the plastic body looks a bit tacky (but at least it feels solid). On the copy I have the rubber panels have gone a bit soft and sticky. To use Continuous AF you need to shoot in the Sports mode which is jpg only and you cannot adjust the exposure using exposure compensation in this mode. There is no being able to use the rear LCD screen to compose pictures on and there is no video mode. Maximum ISO is 1600 and the quality is ropey, but files can clean up quite well in image processing software.
The 70-300mm lenses at this price point are not going to win any awards for optical performance, but they will suffice to get you started. Irrespective of the manufacturer they all tend to be a little soft at the 300mm end and are not the fastest to find focus especially in low light, but they are capable of giving you a nice image if you don’t shoot wide open and keep the shutter speed up.
If you don’t want to buy Canon then at this price point look at the Nikon D100. Obviously you’ll have to substitute Nikon fit lenses as well.
Australian Pelican at Woodman Point, Western Australia. Canon EOS 300d with Canon EF 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS.
Kadjinak or Grey Fantail (Rhipidura albiscapa). York, Western Australia.
Djidi-djidi or Willie Wagtail (Rhipidura leucophrys). York, Western Australia.
Djida or Yellow-rumped Thornbill (Acanthiza chrysorrhoa). York, Western Australia.
Koolbort or Singing Honeyeater (Gavicalis virescens). York, Western Australia.
Kaaka-baaka or Yellow-billed Spoonbill (Platalea flavipes) in the rain. York, Western Australia.
Djangkang or Red Wattlebird (Anthochaera carunculata subs woodwardi). York, Western Australia.
Canon Eos 550d with a 75-300mm lens
Canon EOS 550d body.
If you can squeeze another $50-100 then a good option would be to go for something like the Canon EOS 550d. You have a substantial increase in resolution with an 18Mp sensor with better high ISO performance – now up to 6400 natively or 12800 by expansion. Continuous auto focusing in all shooting modes and the frame rate is increased to 3.7 frames per second with a buffer of 34 frames shooting jpg and 6 frames shooting RAW. The AF system has been beefed up a little and while still only having 9 centrally arranged focus points it has a cross type sensor in the centre with extra sensitivity. The camera uses SD cards which are cheap and easily found. The battery, the Canon LP-E8 is a bit of a down grade in terms of performance compared to BP-511a used in the 300d, but it is readily available and affordable. While being able to shoot 1080 video it is only really suitable for still subjects as the contrast based autofocus is is too slow to lock onto moving subjects. My first videos were shot with this camera and it is capable of producing a good result if you are prepared to manually focus. Other downsides are the limited buffer and the slow frame rate, the lack of a second control dial also makes using exposure compensation a little fiddly. I try and keep my ISO below 3200 as the chroma noise is quite intrusive and difficult to clean up without destroying fine details. But, having said all that this is a camera which is capable of producing very good results. Even though I now have other better cameras I still like to get the 550d out and use it because it is just fun to use.
Canon EOS 550d with Canon EF 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
Quokkas are a small marsupial that inhabit Rottnest Island. Canon EOS 550d with Canon 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
Brushtail Possum (Trichosurus vulpecula) at the Coal Mines Historic in Tasmania. Canon 550d with Canon 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
Like many cockatoos Galahs, Eolophus roseicapilla, nest in hollows in eucalypt trees. Woodbridge Riverside Park. Canon EOS 550d with Canon 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens
Maned Duck (Chenonetta jubata) also known as the Australian Wood Duck, Swan River, Woodbridge. Canon 550d with Canon EF 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
Australian pelican (Pelecanus conspicillatus), Swan River, Woodbridge. Canon EOS 550d with Canon 75-300mm f4-5.6 IS lens.
This would be a camera which would benefit with a better lens if you can afford it. Something like a Canon EF 300mm f4 (approx $500 on EBay) or a 400mm f5.6 (approx $600 on EBay). This would be a nice nimble set up that would give great results.
The Nikon equivalent to this camera would be the Nikon D5000 for about the same amount of money.
Summary
It is quite possible to put together a competent kit to photograph wildlife for less than $500 AUD. It won’t have all the bells and whistles of more modern high end cameras but you will be able to make it work. The limitations mainly are speed of operation and picture quality. Learning how to make up for the short comings will inevitably make you a far better photographer in the long run than having the latest and greatest camera will.
The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.
Before we get going I’m going to be a little bit pedantic. The Nissan MF18 Macro flash is not and I repeat NOT a ring flash. A ring flash such as the Profoto ProRing2 Plus UV has a continuous light tube that forms a circle. The MF18 has two separate flash heads (A + B) in two semicircular diffusers.
The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.with the flash heads positioned at their widest setting.This also shows that the head is comprised of two separate flash tubes in their own semi-circular diffusers.
What I’m looking at in this review is the Nissan MF18 for Sony cameras. This is important because the features and the included accessories vary somewhat depending on whether you have the Sony, Canon or Nikon models. Also while this unit is capable of wireless control I didn’t have the where withal to test that as I don’t own a suitable controller.
TLDR
Specifications
The MF18 is compatible with the following flash protocols:-
Canon ETTL and ETTL ii
Nikon i-TTL
Sony ADI/P-TTL
Having said that some cameras from Sony, Canon and Nikon aren’t compatible.
Canon:-
1dx mk ii, 5d mk iv, 6d mk ii, 80d, 900d, 1d, 1ds, and all the EOS M series of cameras.
Nikon:-
D2Hs, D2H, D100, D1H, D1. Firmware updates are required to ensure compatibility with the Z series cameras, the D6 and the Zfc.
Sony:-
RX100 mk ii
For Sony cameras the wireless strobe will not fire unless the flash mode is set to [WL(wireless)] in the camera menu or the wireless flash function is set to [ON].
Guide Number (GN)
16/53 (ISO 100 m/ft)
Flash output
83 Ws at full power
Power Source
Internal – 4 x AA alkaline/Ni-MH batteries
External
Nisin PS300 battery pack
Nikon SD-8a or SD-9 battery pack
Canon CP-E4 battery pack
Battery Life (approx.)
AA batteries 120-800 flashes
Nisin PS300 500 flashes
Nikon Sd-8a or SD-9 200 flashes
Canon CP-E4 260 flashes
Recycling time
0.1-5.5 seconds with AA batteries
0.7 sec with the Nisin PS300
1.5 sec with the Nikon SD-8a/SD-9
1.5 sec with the Canon CP-E4
Colour Temperature
5600 K at full power
Flash duration
1/700 sec at full power when using both flash heads and 1/300 sec when using one.
Wireless flash
Optical system relying of line of sight only
Sync
Hot shoe or PC sync
Modes of operation
Auto, TTL, full manual (power ranges from full to 1/64 in 1/6th increments) and fine macro (1/128 to 1/1024 in 1/6th increments).
1st curtain sync
2nd curtain sync
High speed flash sync (dependent on whether the camera allows this).
Dimensions
Body 115 x 65 x 85mm
Head 120 x 134 x 41mm
Weight
446g without batteries
Included accessories
Adapter rings to mount the flash head to the lens.
For Canon and Nikon 52, 58, 62, 67, 72, and 77mm.
For Sony 49, 55, 62, 67, 72, and 77mm.
It is possible to buy adapter rings individually in all sizes from 49mm to 82mm.
First Impressions
The box the Nissin MF18 comes in.
The contents of the box. The flash body and head plus 6 adapter rings. The sizes of the included rings depends upon on whether your camera is Sony, or Canon/Nikon.
The quick start guide printed on the inside of the box lid.
I don’t normally talk about packaging but in this case I’ll make an acceptation. The box and its overall presentation were very nice – almost “Applesque” – and showed nice attention to detail which I thought boded well for the flash itself. Overall the MF18 feels very well made. Like all flashguns/speedlights it is of a plastic construction. There is no mention of any weather sealing on the Nisin website so I’ll assume there is none. The body is connected to the head via a chunky coiled cable that feels nice and secure at both ends. In the case of problems with the cord it doesn’t look user replaceable but this is not unusual. The batteries are held in a magazine that slides out of the side. It is a very neat arrangement and spares are available (Nisin BM-01) for those who want a fast reload capability. The flash body is held in the camera hot shoe via blue anodised knurled ring. Not as fast as a lever that is sometimes found on other brands but perfectly satisfactory. On the rear of the body you’ll find a 3cm square colour LCD panel which is sadly not touch compatible. I really like the touch capabilities on my Metz flashes and it is a shame Nisin didn’t include it. Underneath the screen you’ll find an on/off/lock switch, a four way ‘D’ pad with central button, and a combined pilot and status indicator light/button. On the flash head are four buttons – the two vertical ones release the head from the adapter runs, and the two horizontalallow the flash tubes to positioned further out. This prevents vignetting and also allows more even lighting over some larger subjects.
The rear of the MF18. The A and B buttons allow the flash head to open up to prevent vignetting and provide a wider coverage.
Overall everything is very confidence inspiring.
Performance
Nissin claim that the MF18 has a Guide Number of 16 (ISO 100 in metres). Here the subject is 1m from the camera sensor, the power has been set 1/64 and the aperture set to f2. As we can see the photo is approx two stops under exposed. Also Nissin claim that the white balance of the flash is 5600K. The camera white balance was set to 5600K and this resulted in warm cast.
Nisin quote a Guide Number (GN) 16 (ISO100 m) but my testing has found this to rather fanciful as you can see from the table below:
Power setting
GN per Nisin
Measured
full
16
6.9
1/2
11.3
4.9
1/4
8
3.6
1/8
5.6
2.7
1/16
4
1.9
1/32
2.8
1.5
1/64
2
1.4
1/128
1.4
N/A
The measured guide numbers are between 2 and 21/3 of a stop lower than Nisin’s figures which is quite disappointing. The only positive I can say about it is that running the test 3 times the measured results were very consistent.
I measured the colour temperature using a grey card and setting the camera’s white balance to 5600K and found that the actual colour temperature was 4750K.
Checking recycling times using a fresh set of AA Ni-MH batteries saw recycle times average out at 8.9 sec when shooting at full power and 4.55 sec at 1/2 power. This falls short of Nisin’s claimed figures.
In Use
York Sun Orchid, Thelymitra yorkensis. Wandoo National Park, Western Australia. Using high speed synchronisation means I can overpower the sun and render backgrounds dark while illuminating the flower.
OK testing is one thing how does real world performance stack up. I’ve been using the MF18 since August 2021 on a Sony A7r2. The only manual shooting I’ve done with it is just testing it for this review. The rest of the time I use it in TTL mode for photographing flowers. More often than not I use it in high speed sync mode as well so I can have the flash as my key light and the ambient light as my fill. For this it has worked extremely well.
Shy sun orchid, Thelymitra graminea. York Golf Course, Western Australia.
Operating the MF18 is simplicity itself. The basic functions are controlled by the camera. The only time I have to go into the menu is select high speed sync. You can also select 1st or 2nd curtain flash there as well. It is so easy to use that I really don’t have to think about it
The MF18 control menu.
The menu for selecting advanced features such as second curtain sync power saving modes etc.
Conclusion
Pros
Cons
High speed flash synch
Simple to use
Fine macro mode allows power output down to 1/1024 power
A spare battery magazine is available (Nisin BM-01 and it costs approx $20 USD
Can be powered from the mains
Can be powered by Canon and Nikon external battery packs
Firmware can upgraded via a USB port
No case provided – other brands I’ve used provided a case
Only a limited range of adapter rings supplied in the box and while the rings are available as separate items they are quite pricey at $30 USD each.
Compatibility issues with certain models of camera
No weather sealing
GN not accurate
Colour temperature not accurate
The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.viewed in profile.
I bought the Nisin MF18 with my own money. At the time it was the only macro speedlight compatible with Sony that had high speed flash synchronisation. While some of the performance issues such as the GN, recycling times and colour temperature are a bit disappointing they have had no impact on how I use the flash.
The Nissin MF18 macro flash mounted on a Sony A7R and Sigma 105mm f2.8 comination.viewed from the rear.
In terms of value for money, compared to the Olympus and Metz equivalents it seems quite keenly priced. It is better specified than the Metz unit but doesn’t have the overall flexibility and the weather sealing of the Olympus.
Blue China Orchid, Cyanicula gemmata. Wandoo National Park, Western Australia.
Would I recommend it? Well if you are just going to use it as I do and are happy with the compatibility issues then yes I would. But if you are still using cameras such as the Canon 5d vi or the 6d ii then I would look elsewhere.
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 lens mounted on an Olympus Pen EP-2.
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 lens was the first prime lens from Olympus for its new Micro Four Thirds System and was launched in 2009 with the Olympus Pen EP-1 their first camera. I didn’t buy the EP-1 when came out, I was deeply tempted but I wanted a camera with a viewfinder. Less than a year later the EP-2 was launched and it had provision for accepting an auxiliary EVF and I promptly bought one and the 17mm f2.8 came as part of the kit and I’ve used it ever since.
The 17mm f2.8 is what is termed a pancake lens. This is where the lens specs are sacrificed to produce the smallest possible lens.
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 wasn’t well received – a lot of people felt that its minimum aperture of f2.8 was somewhat underwhelming especially compared to the Panasonic 20mm f1.7 which was launched in the same year. The Panasonic while sharper in the centre of the frame and having a faster minimum aperture (1.7 compared to 2.8) was larger, heavier, more expensive had slow noisy AF, marked chromatic aberration and didn’t behave very well with the sensor stack of Olympus cameras. There was a strange banding effect when it was used on the EM5 at higher ISO. In 2012 Olympus introduced the 17mm f1.8 which addressed all the short comingsof the older f2.8 lens which was allowed to slip silently into oblivion.
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 lens mounted on an Olympus Pen EP-5.
I wanted to upgrade to the new f1.7 but I could never find a dealer who had it in stock. The same was true when I thought I wanted the Panasonic Leica 15mm f1.7 as a replacement. In the end I bought the Sigma 16mm f1.4 DG DN which is optically a huge improvement over the little Olympus, but is physically enormous.I kept the Old 17mm f2.8 because it served several purposes. It had a very useful close focusing capability when compared to the Sigma (0.11x compared to the Sigma’s 0.07x) and when mounted to my EP-5 it was small, unobtrusive, and would fit in a jacket pocket. The same could not be said for the Sigma.
A size comparisson between the m.Zuiko 17mm f2.8, the Sigma 16mm f1.4 which offers a similar field of view and the Olympus OM Zuiko 35mm f2 for full frame cameras.
TLDR
Vital Statistics
Lens construction of the m.Zuiko 17mm f2.8 lens.
Focal length
17mm equivalent to 34mm on full frame
Diagonal angle of view
65º
Optical construction
6 elements in 4 groups with 1 aspherical lens
Diaphragm
5 rounded blades
Minimum aperture
F2.8
Maximum aperture
f22
Minimum focusing distance
20cm
Maximum magnification ratio
0.11x
Filter diameter
37mm
Dimensions
⦰ 57mm x 22mm (h)
Weight
71g
Internal focusing
No
Lens hood
No
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 is the same size as this Canon EF rear lens cap and body cap.
This lens is small – really small – just 22mm high and 57mm in diameter at its widest. To put that into perspective the lens is only just a little bigger than a Canon EF body and lens cap and weighs just 43g heavier. For such a small and lightweight lens it does feel surprisingly dense in the hand. The lens mount is metal and the body is plastic with no weather sealing. The only control on the lens is the focusing ring which is of the focus by wire type and is nicely dampened. Filter size is weenie – just 37mm. Olympus did not supply a lens hood and nor did they make one. I bought an after market vented metal hood which looks very spiffy when the lens is mounted on my EP-5.
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 lens with vented lens hood mounted on an Olympus Pen EP-5.
Optical Performance
f2.8
Wide open at f2.8 in the centre of the frame the image lacks a little “bite” . Stop down to f4 and sharpness and contrast improve and it remains good until f11. After that diffraction softens the image. In the corners wide open the lens is tiny bit softer than the centre. Sharpness improves at f5.6 but it is not as sharp as the centre at this aperture.
100% crop showing Chromatic aberation at f2.8.
Wide open lateral chromatic aberration is very apparent with magenta and cyan fringing. The modest minimum aperture of f2.8 and the wide angle of view means that there is longitudinal chromatic aberration visible. When Olympus and Panasonic established the Micro Four Thirds standard they made the lens with built in profiles which correct for distortion and vignetting. Consequently looking at an image straight out of the camera with the profile applies there is no sign of distortion or vignetting on the Olympus 17mm f2.8. Switch that profile off and the barrel distortion is very noticeable as is very slight vignetting.
At f2.8 with lens profile disabled. Note the lack of contrast and the prominent barrel distortion.
Diffraction spikes or sunstars at f22.
Veiling flare and reflections are quite prominent shooting into the sun wide open. The result is a significant loss of contrast.
Veiling flare and ghosting are prominent when shooting into the sun as is the loss of contrast. The diffraction spikes (akasun stars) are a bit pedestrian and nothing to write home about.
Bokeh balls wide open at f2.8.
When it comes to bokeh well this lens is never going to be the “Bokeh King”. The bokeh balls are consistently shaped throughout the frame but were not quite perfectly circular. While the rendering of out of focus areas is smooth it is not the most attractive that I’ve seen.
Close up of the bokeh
Autofocus Performance
When the EP-1 was introduced it and the Panasonic G1 were heading the rise of a new class of camera – the mirrorless interchangeable lens camera. The autofocus was contrast based and still in its infancy. In fact dodgy AF was one of the things that was always levelled at mirrorless cameras by DSLR users in those far off days. The AF performance of the Olympus 17mm f2.8 certainly reflects this. For point to point AF using single shot mode the lens is quick and accurate if a little noisy. It is when you switch to continuous autofocus and tracking that things become dodgier than a Balinese Rolex. The performance is very hit and miss. Even when you put it on a phase detect auto focus camera (EM1 mk ii and later) the results are only marginally better. The fault is the because of the type of motor used to move the lens elements.It just can’t keep up with information being sent by the camera. This is why Olympus later introduced its MSC technology. MSC stands for Movie and Stills Compatible and consists of a high speed motor that can provide very small precise adjustments. So while it appears poor compared to later models this is not a lens you’re going to shoot sports with.
Video AF is also a bit pants. The lens makes a horrible noise as it rocks back and forth. It does find focus eventually its just not very elegant or confidence inspiring in the way it does it.
Conclusion
The Olympus 17mm f2.8 lens mounted on an Olympus Pen EP-5.
This lens is not what you call optically brilliant – if you want that look at the Olympus m.Zuiko 17mm f1.2 Pro which costs $1900 AUD – but that’s not what this lens is about. This is a fun lens to use. It’s so convenient to slap it onto an Olympus Pen EP-5 or EM-10 and have a great small camera lens combo that can go with you anywhere. This is what micro four thirds was all about when it was introduced. Team it up with the ridiculously compact Olympus 45mm f1.8 and you have a nice two lens outfit that will fit in a jacket pocket and produce good photos. Unfortunately 17mm f2.8 is out of production, but it can be bought second hand for about $200 AUD. Factor in $10 AUD for a lens hood and you’ve got a nice little walk about lens.
Sample Images
Royal swans near the bridge to Eaton.
Getting in touch with his inner Elvis on Brighton Beach.
Fishing boat pulled up onto the beach at Bognor Regis.
Urban Cowboy waiting at the Perth Rail Station.
Salamnaca Market, Hobart, Tasmania.
Frida thoroughly approves of having a sofa on the verrandah.
On location filming at the Bellerive Yacht Club with the Olympus EM-10 and 25mm f1.8 lens.
St Luke’s Anglican Church .Richmond, Tasmania.
Lavender ice cream in a waffle cone for sale in Richmond Tasmania.
First Contact , Elizabeth Quay in Perth, is a five metre tall artwork by Nyoongar artist Laurel Nannup.
St George’s Cathedral reflected in windows of a high rise building. Perth, Western Australia.
Decorating the Christmas tree on Perth Esplanade. Perth, Western Australia.
James Turrell’s Amarna at dawn. MONA, Hobart, Tasmania.
I’ve thinking about variable neutral density filters a lot lately. When I started to get a bit more interested in video I decided to invest in a good Variable Neutral Density filter and as I’d always bought B+W filters I bought a B+W 77mm XS-Pro Digital ND Vario MRC-Nano Filter. It was beautifully made in Germany with a brass frame and hard stops. It didn’t offer anything spectacular in terms of range just 1 to 5 stops but it was very good. Unfortunately I was filming a waterfall and slipped on the rock and went into the river. I ended up with a week in hospital with septicaemia and the filter was smashed. I was unable to get a replacement so bought a Cokin NUANCES NDX 2-400 Filter which was considerably cheaper, not as well made but the images were good. Over time I decided I missed the hard stops and so as the B+W was still unavailable in Australia bought a Heliopan variable grey neutral density ND 0.3 – ND 1.8 filter which has served me very well.
Recently I decided that I wanted a new one in 95mm size. Normally I’d buy the best quality one and be done with it, but this time I was unprepared to spend that eye watering amount for what just amounts to an experiment. Looking online I saw there is a huge variation in prices and I couldn’t help but wonder whether paying more actually meant a better quality filter. So I’m looking at four filters and the price range goes from $24 AUD to $350 AUD. I’ll look at whether they impact image quality, whether they are prone to flare and whether they effect autofocus performance.
Testing Methodology
Colour casts produced by the filters at their minimum and maximum settings. Click on the image to see larger.
For all the tests the same camera and lens were used – a Sony A7r2 with Sony FE 50mm f1.8 lens. Although the filters are different sizes I used step up rings to fit the filters to the lens. To test for image sharpness and colour casts the camera was set on a tripod in front of a lens resolution chart so it filled the frame. The chart was lit with an LED light set to 5600K and then a custom white balance was set with no filter on the lens and an image was taken which was the control. Each filter was then tested at its minimum and maximum density.
The effects of the filters on image sharpness at their maximum and minimum settings. Click on the image to see larger.
For the video AF test the Sony A7r2 and 50mm lens were used again while with the stills AF test I was so surprised with the results that I also tested with the Olympus EM 1 mk ii and the the Olympus 25mm f1.8 just to make sure. I ran control tests for both camera and lens combinations to provide a baseline with which to compare. In the stills test both cameras without filters attained a 100% in focus rate.
The glare test was done with just the Sony A7r2 and the 50mm lens.
“Image quality may drop when focal length above 200mm. It may not be suitable for a wide-angle lens <24mm,35mm film format equivalent.”
The filter is made from an unspecified Japanese optical glass and there is no mention of any coatings. The frame is made out of aluminium and has a satin black finish. There are no hard stops but there is a scale indicating where the minimum and maximum effect occurs. The filters are made in China and come in a flimsy rectangular hard plastic case.
Certainly this filter has an effect on image sharpness it decreased sharpness and contrast of the tested 50mm lens the most. At the minimum density setting there was a definite reduction in contrast and sharpness which deteriorated even further at maximum density setting. It also had a pronounced colour cast.
The Fotga filter is the cheapest on test but the aluminium frame appears to be as well made as the filters from Cokin and Urth.
When testing the video autofocusing the Fotga produced the worst result – the AF was as snappy or confident and the image was decidedly soft. Shooting a burst of still images imagesthe Fotga filter only achieved an in focus rate of 67% and the images were all low in contrast, very soft and showed glare. Speaking of glare when testing for it specifically the Fotga produced the worst result exhibiting veiling and ghosting flare and strong halation around the light source.
The Urth Variable ND2-400 (1-8.65 Stop) Filter is the next cheapest filter costing $82 AUD for a 77mm filter. Urth state on their web site that the filter is not suitable for use on wide angle lenses stating:
“For wide-angle lenses, we recommend our Variable ND2-32, ND8-128, ND64-1000 or fixed ND filters.”
Urth also state that filter has eight layers of coatings to make it easier to clean but no mention of whether they improve optical quality. They also claim that there are no colour casts which unfortunately is not true, but on the positive side there was no impact on image sharpness at the minimum setting and a slight reduction in sharpness at the maximum setting.
The Urtth variable neutral density filter has an aluminium alloy frame and hard stops.
About the type of glass used the website says:
“Japanese AGC optical glass is coated with an 8-layer nano-coating “
The frame is aluminium and finished in matte black. There are hard stops at each end of the adjustment range with a scale marked showing maximum and minimum. Out of all the filters on test the Urth has the nicest presentation being supplied in a circular metal tin with a screw on lid and it was the only filter to be supplied with a lens cleaning cloth. To make you feel even better about your purchase Urth say they will plant 5 trees with every purchase. Urth are an Australian company but the filters are made in China.
When shooting video the Urth filter had no visible effect on the autofocus, but strangely enough did on the stills performance achieving an 80% hit rate. For the glare test it shared the best performance with the Cokin filter.
Cokin
Cokin NUANCES Variable Neutral Density 2-400 (1-8 Stops) Screw-in Camera Filter
The Cokin NUANCES NDX 2-400 – 77mm Filter comes in at $176 AUD for the 77mm size tested. Cokin put out a very helpful information sheet which clearly states that they do not recommend its use on lenses shorter that 24mm (full frame). Interestingly they specifically talk about the “Maltese Cross” phenomenon which occurs when you try to get the maximum density. This varies depending upon the focal length of the lens and limits the amount of density you can use. To get the full 8 2/3 stops lenses longer than 45mm should be used. A focal length of 35mm gives you 6 1/3 stops and 24mm gives 5 1/3 stops.
In terms of the optical construction the Cokin filter is made of “Schott Glass B270, renowned for its high transmittance and low reflection”. They state that the filter is coated but not with how many coats. The frame is made of aluminium with a matte black finish and it has a series of dot markings with min at one end and max at the other. The dots don’t correspond with any particular effect. The filter comes in a round hard plastic case that is hinged. It doesn’t feel particularly sturdy and I find it quite awkward to open. Although the packaging states it is designed in France there is no indication as to where the filter was made. As Cokin was acquired by Hoya in 2000, which is part of the Kenko Tokina group, which makes filters in both the Philippines and Japan it would be a fairly safe assumption that the Cokin filters would be.
Cokin NUANCES Variable Neutral Density 2-400 (1-8 Stops) Screw-in Camera Filter
Tested performance shows no effect on image sharpness at both the minimum and maximum settings and a very slight cast. The Cokin filter performed very strongly in the video autofocus test showing effect on performance or image quality. The stills performance was the second best at 82% and the results in the glare test were joint best.
“Depending on the focal length of the lens this filter is not recommended for use with very wide angle lenses.”
The Heliopan variable neutral density filter is the only one on test that has a brass frame. It is also one of only two that have hard stops to limit the amount of adjustment.
But having said that you shouldn’t be having too many problems as the filter has hard stops to prevent running into the “Maltese cross” phenomenon. They claim the use of Schott glass but make no mention of any coatings. The frame is made in Germany of brass with a matte black finish to avoid reflections and has hard stops at each end of the adjustment range plus a numerical scale marked from 1-12 but the numbers don’t correspond to any ND value. The filter comes in a square hard plastic case that is hinged and it is quite sturdy.
Heliopan Variable (1 to 6 Stops) ND Filter
The tested performance was similar to that of the Cokin a slight colour cast ( although different from the Cokin) and no effect on image sharpness.For the video AF there was no impact on the focus performance and no effect on the image quality.For the stills AF the heliopan was the best performer with a score of 86%. Interestingly it was not an equal performance across both cameras. On the Sony it achieved a score of 78% and the Olympus 94%. I’m really at a loss to explain why there is such as discrepancy with the results and I had to test several times to confirm it. The Heliopan didn’t do very well in the glare test exhibiting pronounced veiling and ghosting flare. It wasn’t as bad as the Fotga but it was significantly worse than the Urth and the Cokin.
Conclusion
For filters that don’t have hard stops, like this Cokin, if you apply too much filtration you get this cross pattern.
Before I started testing I definitely believed that you got what you paid for. I fully expected the Fotga filter to be the worst performer and the Heliopan the best leaving the Cokin and Urth filters to battle for second and third places. Well I only got part of it right. The Fotga was definitely the worst performing filter of the bunch. Its only redeeming feature is the price – it’s incredibly cheap. The real surprise was that the Heliopan while being marginally the best performer wasn’t delivering any significant improvement over the Cokin which cost half the amount. The Urth filter was a very solid performer. Their 77mm is half the price of the Cokin yet delivered a result that was only a fraction worse – probably undetectable in real world use. Yet the filter has hard stops and is more nicely made and presented. For a little more, $44 AUD to be precise, the Urth Filter Plus+ might be a very good buy having the benefit of the better Schott glass, but that is conjecture as I’ve not used one.
A key takeaway is that to get the best possible image quality you have to set your custom white white balance with the filter on. All the filters produce some degree of colour cast despite what the manufacturers claim. All the filters are prone to flare so I would recommend the use of a lens hood. Lens hoods and variable NDs are problematic as the filters prevent the use of the ones designed for the lens. I now use a matt box when shooting outside and it has made a surprising difference.
To sum up, well if I needed to start again I wouldn’t waste my money on the Heliopan. The Cokin would be my choice if I could live without hard stops and the Urth would be it if I couldn’t.
The Tamron 20mm f2.8 lens for Sony E mount cameras was announced back in November 2019 as part of a trio of prime lenses which share the same exterior design, construction, size, filter diameter and f stop. The other lens being the 24 and 35 mm. I reviewed the 35mm f2.8 back in June 2021 and was quite impressed with it.
TLDR
Vital Statistics
Focal Length
20mm
Maximum Aperture
F2.8
Angle of View (diagonal)
94º30’
Optical Construction
10 elements in 9 groups with 3 low dispersion lens elements and 1moulded glass aspherical element.
Minimum Object Distance
11cm or 4.3 inches
Magnification Ratio
1:2
Filter Size
67mm
Dimensions
(h) 64mm (2.5 inches) x ⌀ 73mm ( 2.9 inches)
Weight
220g (7.8 oz)
Number of Diaphragm Blades
7 curved blades
Accessories
included lens hood
Available Mounts
Sony E
Build Quality
The Tamron 20mm is pretty much the same design and build quality as the 24 and 35. They are all the same length and diameter. They all have the same filter diameter of 67mm. Weight wise the 20mm is the heaviest at 220g and the 35mm is the lightest at 210g. All three have the same magnification ratio of 1:2. So Tamron has worked very hard to ensure that uniformity is carried throughout this line of lenses. It will be interesting to see if they introduce longer lenses like an 85mm how they carry that out. When compared to my Canon EF 20mm f2.8the Tamron is only a smidge smaller and lighter which is quite surprising as the Canon is a retrofocus design built to accommodate the larger lens flange distance of 44mm compared to the 18mm of the Sony.
The body is made out of some form of engineering plastic and the lens mount appears to be chrome plated brass which is nice. There is an “o” ring which provides some semblance of sealing from the elements at the mount. There is no other weather sealing and no indication as to the level of sealing and Tamron on their website just say that it has a “Moisture-Resistant Construction”. Tamron also claim that the front lens element has a fluorine coating which is dirt resistant. The only control on the lens is the ribbed focus ring which is of the fly-by-wire type and it has no hard stops or any form of tactile feedback when turning it. Bad news if you want to do manual video focus pulls. The lens comes with a petal shaped lens hood that bayonets into place.
Optical Performance
Tamron on their website say “The expert arrangement of the LD and GM specialised glass elements greatly controls aberrations, including chromatic aberrations. Tamron’s proprietary BBAR (Broad-Band Anti-Reflection) Coating reduces ghosting and flare, which can otherwise occur when taking a photo against the sun.” When shooting with the camera’s lens correction function enabled “it delivers, throughout the frame, high resolution performance that maximises the benefits of the latest high-megapixel cameras”. So let’s see how those claims stack up to real world usage.
With no lens profile applied there is massive barrel distortion on the Tamron 20mm f2.8 Di III at f5.6.
Let’s deal with the whopping great elephant in the room. This lens has very profound barrel distortion, but for jpg shooters an inbuilt lens profile minimises the effect. For RAW shooters Adobe has made a lens profile available for Lightroom and Camera RAW.
When we look at the uncorrected image and look at the rulers on the bottom and the side we can see that it is 47.4 cm in width and 29.5 cm in height. Compare that to the corrected image which is 43.7cm by 28.3cm. So in percentage terms that is a 7.2% reduction in width and a 4.2% reduction in height. This means that with the lens profile applied the lens effectively becomes a 22mm. But if you shoot video with electronic stabilisation the image is cropped again and it will give an angle of view similar to that of a 24mm lens. So if video is important to you and you want an angle of view given by a 20mm lens then you either get a lens that doesn’t suffer from as much distortion or you get a wider lens– somewhere around 16-18mm.
So in real terms how bad is the distortion? Well comparing the Tamron, which is a very modern design to the Olympus OM Zuiko 21mm f3.5 released in 1984 and the Canon EF 20mm f2.8 USM from 1992 we can see that the Tamron has considerably worse distortion. This is very surprising as the two older lenses are retrofocus designs. SLRs have a big flippy flappy mirror between the lens and the film/sensor and this meant in the early days of SLR photography making wide angle lenses impossiblebecause the rear lens element would foul the mirror. The breakthrough camein 1950 when Pierre Angénieux invented the retrofocus lens which is akind of “reverse” telephoto design where the lens elements closest to the film plane have a negative effect making the image smaller. The downsides are more glass elements which means more air to glass surfaces which means more refraction which means more potential chromatic aberration and distortion. So the fact that the Canon and Olympus lenses have a better performance with their compromised design is saying something.
Slight barrel distortion on the Olympus OM Zuiko 21mm f3.5 lens at f5.6.
Slight barrel distortion on the Canon EF 20mm f2.8 lens at f5.6.
In terms of lateral chromatic aberration the Tamron 20mm shows mild CA in the corners and edges which is very slight when uncorrected and virtually invisible when the profile is applied. Wide open there is longitudinal chromatic aberration present – cyan and magenta fringing on the out of focus edges – but this is easily fixed by stopping down. Vignetting is quite apparent without the lens profile, but when it is applied it is a non issue.
Specular light sources in the frame or just outside it can cause ghosting and flare.
Using the supplied lens hood reduces the incidence of len flare.
When it comes to flare resistance, well extreme wide angles lenses are very prone to the effects of flare and don’t necessarily have to have a specular light source in the frame to cause it. The Tamron handles it reasonably well but is prone to veiling and ghosting flare. The lens comes with a lens hood and it would be wise to use all the time and it does a reasonably good job of reducing the incidence of flare. The seven aperture blades produce sunstars or diffraction spikes that are a bit messy and not very pleasant – although this is a matter of personal taste.
The sunstars or diffraction spikes are a little on the messy side.
The bokeh balls produced by the Tamron 20mm f2.8 Di III lens wide open at f2.8.
A close up of the bokeh balls showing the shape deformity and the onion ring artefacts.
The bokeh produces nice tonal transitions in the out of focus areas.
The bokeh balls aren’t very attractive, they have a very pronounced onion ring effect and even the balls at the centre of the image have a slightly elliptical shape and this gets more apparent towards the edge of the image. While you don’t necessarily buy a 20mm lens for its bokeh it is important on this lens because of its close focusing capabilities. When we look at real world examples we can see the tonal transitions in the out of focus areas are nice and smooth.
Sharpness. Wide open at the centre the lens is a little soft and lacking contrast. Things improve as you stop down and the best sharpness is attained at f5.6. At the edges at f2.8 the corners are slightly worse than the centre. It is not until f8 when the corner performance equals that of the centre.
The pergola in the middle of Tomato Lake in Kewdale.
Autofocus
For stills photography the Tamron 20mm is very positive in acquiring focus if just a bit slow. There’s no hesitancy and no hunting. In a sequence of shots of me walking backwards and forwards the camera and lens combo achieved an 88% hit rate. I would expect that to be better with the third and fourth generation A7 bodies.
Video is a different story. There is some hesitancy in focusing and a bit of wobble even with static shots. Performance is at its best at closer distances.
Usage Scenarios
For landscape and architectural work this would be quite a nice choice, particularly if you are travelling and want to keep the weight of your kit down. The fact that the lens doesn’t reach peak optical performance across the frame until f8 would not be a problem. Just remember to keep for your verticals vertical when shooting buildings.
The minimum focus distance and high magnification ratio means that you can fill the frame with small objects.
To achieve the magnification ratio of 1:2 you have to be very very close to your subject
The close up capabilities of this lens are what sets it apart from other extreme wide angle lenses. This lens will reproduce an object at half size at its minimum focusing distance of 11cm. Now remember that that distance isn’t measured from the front lens element but from the sensor plane. This means to achieve the magnification ratio of 1:2 you have to be very very close to your subject. So close that you may have to remove the lens hood as it casts shadow over your subject. I bought the lens for nature photography, particularly close ups of flowers. Wide angle close up shots allow you to show the detail of the subject and its context. That gives a more unusual look to the more standard viewpoint of a short telephoto macro lens such as 100mm. For this the Tamron works very well.
Cowslip Orchid, Caladenia flava subs. flava. Christmas Rock, Western Australia.
Astro – I don’t do this type of photography but from what I’ve read I think that you’d be better off getting one of the faster 20mm lenses from Sony or Sigma. F2.8 is borderline too slow an aperture and the lack of edge sharpness at wide apertures further handicaps the lens for this particular usage.
Video usage. This is where the lens is like the curate’s egg – “good in parts”. The autofocus is a bit of a let down and the manual focusing makes repeatable focus pulls difficult. The light weight is a boon for gimbal usage as is the fact that the lens doesn’t extend when focusing. If vlogging is your thing then the angle of view is just about perfect – giving your viewers more of the background rather than just having a large talking head – plus the light weight means the lens and camera combo is easier to hold at arms length.
Conclusion
Rainwater captured on Christmas Rock in natural forming crack, depressions and gullies.
A suprising number of plants grow on Christmas Rock.
Jug orchid or recurved shell orchid (Pterostylis recurva). Woottating, Western Australia.
Cycling along the Beenyup Swamp Boardwalk in Yellagonga Regional Park.
I bought this lens to compliment the 35mm f2.8 which I really like and use a lot. I find that the 20mm is somewhat underwhelming. I feel that the optical performance isn’t as good as it could be. The lens distortion is quite severe and the lens profile just blurs the detail in the corners. Couple this with the autofocus performance and I’m left feeling that it would be better to save more money and buy a better lens. In fact if it wasn’t for the close focusing capabilities I would be parting company with this lens.
If you are a regular reader of this blog then you’ll be aware that I’m trying to transition from my full frame Canon DSLR to a full frame Sony mirrorless system without spending a fortune. Initially the idea was to buy a second hand A7r ii body and use second hand lens adapters (the Sigma MC-11 and the Metabones V Smart Adapter) to enable me to use my existing Canon EF lenses. The experience went relatively well until I tried to use the kit for covering a couple of events. It was my experience of using the Canon 24-70mm f4 IS L lens mounted via the Metabones V Smart Adapter that made me start to reconsider the whole idea of adapting Canon EF lenses to Sony FE bodies. I’d already been using a Sony 28-70mm f3.5-5.6 OSS lens and while the AF and the stabilisation were good points I wanted a brighter lens and a constant aperture as it makes life easier when doing flash photography. My options in this focal range were:
Sony Zeiss FE 24-70mm f/4 ZA OSS Lens
Sony FE 24-70mm f/2.8 G Master Lens
Tamron 28-75mm F/2.8 Di III VXD G2 Lens
Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN Lens
The Sony Zeiss 24-70 f4 doesn’t have a very good reputation as there is a lot sample variation and it would appear that good copies are few and far between. Sony’s f2.8 GM, well at just under $3000 AUD was out of the running on price alone. With the Tamron 28-75mm well the original version is permanently out of stock here in Australia so goodness knows when the mk ii version will be available. So the Sigma won the day.
Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN Lens available in both Sony FE mount and L mount.
TLDR
Specifications
Focal length
28-70mm
Angle of view
75.4~34.3°
Maximum aperture
f2.8
Minimum aperture
f22
Filter Size
67mm
Stabilisation
no
Maximun magnification
At 28mm 1: 3.3
At 70mm 1: 4.6
Minimum focusing distance
Ay 28mm 19cm
At 70mm 38cm
Focusing modes
AF and manual
Optical construction
12 groups, 16 elements
Including 2 FLD elements, 2 SLD elements, and 3 aspherical elements
Aperture blades
9 rounded blades
Weather sealing
dust and splash-proof
Weight
470g
Dimensions
φ72.2mm × 103.5mm
Mount
Sony FE and L-mount Alliance
Build Quality
Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN Lens available in both Sony FE mount and L mount.
The 28-70mm DG DN is part of Sigma’s “Contemporary” line which up to recently was seen to be their line which had good optical performance while cutting costs in the materials and finish. Recent releases such as the 90mm f2.8 have muddied this somewhat as they spare no expense seemingly in their construction and performance. Anyway back to the 28-70 it has a more utilitarian approach to its design – it has a rather plain matte black appearance and is made out of Sigma’s Thermally Stable Composite which is a kind of engineering grade plastic that has similar thermal expansion properties as aluminium. The lens is compact and relatively light when compared to other standard zooms with a f2.8 constant aperture. When you pick it up it doesn’t feel cheap or flimsy, but rather it feels reassuringly dense and solid. Nothing creaks or flexes and there are no mould seams – Tamron I’m looking at you! The lens mount is chrome plated brass and there is an ‘o’ ring to prevent the ingress of moisture and dust.
The chrome plated brass mount and the “o” ring that surrounds it.
Compared to other lenses there is a paucity of controls – just a focus ring, a zoom ring and a focus mode selector switch. Both rings have a nice ribbed rubber texture to facilitate a good grip. The zoom ring has a smooth 90º which has just the right amount of resistance – not too sloppy or too tight. The lens barrel extends as you zoom to 70mm by 27mm. The focus ring is of the fly by wire variety with no hard stops. Again it is not too loose or tight and I found it quite pleasant to use.
The controls on the lens are few and far between. A focus ring, an AF mode switch and the zoom ring.
The lens comes with a plastic lens hood that bayonets into place securely. A nice touch is that the interior is ribbed to prevent reflections. The filter size is 67mm which is a modest size and keeps the cost of filters down. The first standard zoom I got had a filter thread of 55mm. Subsequent standard lenses went increased to 77mm and then 82mm so it’s good to see sizes slipping back.
The lens barrel extends by 27mm when zoomed out to 70mm. The lens comes with a petal shaped lens hood.
In terms of size and weight, well my Sigma 16mm f1.4 and Olympus 45mm f1.2 are almost as big and as heavy as the 28-70 DG DN and they were made for the micro four thirds system. It’s a little larger than the the Sony 28-70mm f3.5-5.6 OSS lens and while the same length as the Canon 24-70mm f4 IS L the Sigma is 135g lighter.
The Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN lens is only fractionally bigger and heavier than the Sigma 16mm f1.4 and Olympus 45mm f1.2 prime lenses for the micro four thirds system.
Optical Performance
To see any of the images larger just click on them.
OK lets get down to the nitty gritty. At 28mm wide open the centre of the image is sharp and contrasty. The edges are softer and there is a very, and I mean very, small amount of green fringing. Switching off the lens correction we can see that there is vignetting and barrel distortion. At f8 the edges catch up with the centre sharpness. By f16 the effects of diffraction are noticeable.
At 70mm f2.8 the centre performance is not as good as the wide end being slightly soft and lacking contrast in the centre and with corners a little worse. Stop down to f4 and the centre improves considerably and by f8 the corners are as good as the centre. Again by f16 diffraction is apparent. Without the lens profile there is vignetting and pincushion distortion.
.
When it comes to chromatic aberration well axial (or longitudinal) CA can be observed when shooting wide open especially at the minimum focusing distance. This is easily dealt with by stopping down. It is more pronounced at 70mm than 28mm. Transverse (lateral) CA is very well controlled and images need to be forensically examined at 200% to spot it. Very impressive.
Ghosting flare, sensor flare and diffraction spikes. 28mm at f22. I you look carefully you can see a small amount of ghosting flare and some sensor flare.
Looking at the diffraction spikes (sun stars) for this lens the nine bladed diaphragm produces 18 points and stopping down to f22 produces the best effect. Diffraction blurs them a little but I quite like them.
Flare resistance is very good. There is little to no veiling flare and just a little ghosting flare. What is apparent is sensor flare aka red dot flare.This is caused by reflections from the micro lenses on the sensor hitting the rear lens element and the being reflected back onto the sensor. Unfortunately it seems that mirrorless cameras seem more prone to this due to the shorter lens flange distance.
Looking at the bokeh at 28mm wide open at f2.8 the balls don’t have a round shape – they are a bit misshapen and have visible onion rings. The tonal transitions are smooth. By f8 the balls take on a polygonal shape. At 70mm wide open the balls in the centre of the frame are nice and round with some onion rings. At the edge of the frame they have an elliptical cats eye shape. The tonal transitionsin out of focus areas are again nice and smooth. Stopping down to f4 the balls become tighter and the onion rings not so prominent. Interestingly the bokeh balls keep their round shape all the way down to f22.
Bokeh at 70mm f2.8
Auto Focus Performance
Auto focus test for stills at 28mm.
Shooting stills wide open at 28mm the autofocus is very snappy and sticky in daylight with lots of contrast. I shot several sequences of me walking towards the camera and achieved a 100% hit rate. At 70mm f2.8 the results weren’t as impressive but I averaged out with a hit rate of 81%. The problem seemed to occur when I got very close to the camera and the lens would struggle to keep up. It would focus for a couple of frames, loose focus for a frame and then re-acquire. Using the 28-70 DG DN with my Sony A7 r ii at a grip and grin I found that the AF wasn’t as confident in the low light and contrast setting. It wasn’t terrible but I found it wasn’t as quick as I’d of liked and a couple of times I lost a spontaneous moment because the combination hadn’t acquired focus quick enough.
Auto focus test for stills at 70mm.
When shooting the video test I mounted the camera on my slider with a repeating 20cm movement and then filmed myself walking back and forth. At 28mm wide open the lens did very well with just a couple of moments where it was hesitant. Overall a very good performance. At 70mm the AF wasn’t as confident and prone to loose focus and then not quickly re-acquire. I decided to re-test but not using the slider this time and everything was a lot better at both focal lengths so from that I can assume that the movement from the slider was stressing the autofocus too much.
Checking for focus breathing I found that it was very minimal which should keep the video crowd. Normally I don’t bother checking where a lens is parfocal or not, but, as the lens had so far done so well I thought I’d give it a go. And the Sigma 28-70 f2.8 is indeed parfocal.
Conclusion
Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN Lens mounted on a Sony A7r ii.
There have been a few criticisms about the Sigma 28-70 DG DN. People moan about the distortion present when you don’t use the lens profile. I would argue that using corrections like that enables manufacturers to make compact, lightweight and affordable lenses. Other have been very vocal about the reduced performance at the 70mm end, but it is not unusual for a zoom lens to be better optically at the wide end. Better performance would again mean bigger, heavier and more expensive lenses. The main criticism is that at 28mm it’s just not wide enough and that it really should be a 24-70mm f2.8. Well Sigma does make one and its $600 AUD more expensive and it is bigger. Sony’s GM 24-70mm f2.8 is $1300 AUD more expensive, 371g heavier, 33mm longer and 14mm wider. So if you want a small compact f2.8 constant aperture standard zoom some compromise has to be made and I think Sigma has made the right choices.
The focusing and zoom rings have a nice ribbed rubber grip.
I really like standard zooms – I have one for each of my camera systems (Canon EF, M4/3, and now Sony FE). I find they fit in with my way of working with just one camera and one lens. This lens with its useful close focus ability makes it ideal for shooting small subjects, food, and products. Its constant f2.8 aperture is good for low light, flash photography and video. While 70mm at the long end makes it a bit on the short side for some types of portrait photography the focal range is great for environmental portraiture. Overall this lens is perfectly suited to being used as an everyday carry or part of a lightweight travel kit. Occasionally I wished for something a little wider, so what I ended up doing was carrying my Tamron 20mm f2.8 and then everything was just dandy.
Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN Lens available in both Sony FE mount and L mount.
I really enjoyed using this lens. While it’s not perfect by any means it is a very solid and workman like performer that lets you get on and take photos.
Sample Images
A selection of images taken with the Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 DG DN lens.
A glass of bubbles to celebrate.
York Town Hall as the sun begins to set.
The Tourist Wheel on the Esplanade Park in Fremantle.
The point that tghe Wagyl (Dreamtrime Rainbow Serpent) leaves the Swan River and swims out to sea. Fremantle, Western Australia.
Greg James Sculpture Studio Gallery at the J Shed in Fremantle.
South Metroploitain TAFE Fremantle.
The pusher/tug Svitzer Nana berthed at Fremantle Harbour.
WA Maritime Museum at Fremantle Harbour.
The cargo ship William entering Fremantle Docks.
The cranes at the dry dock that houses HMAS Ovens at the WA Maritime Museum at Fremantle Harbour.
HMAS Ovens in dry dock at the WA Maritime Museum at Fremantle Harbour.
One of the cranes at the dry dock that houses HMAS Ovens at the WA Maritime Museum at Fremantle Harbour.
Part of the HMAS Ovens display at the WA Maritime Museum at Fremantle Harbour.
You must be logged in to post a comment.