Wandering Around Waroona

 

Waroona is a small town some 113 Km south of Perth in Western Australia. It’s a town that we’ve not previously had much to do with. We stayed at the Lake Navarino campsite about 25 years ago for one night when we cycle toured the region. Other than that we’ve just driven through it on the way to somewhere else.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Waroona’s entry statement.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
A yarn bomb installation outside the Waroona Visitors Centre.

 

Helen visiting a roadside plant stall in Waroona.

Again this time we arranged to stay at the Lake Navarino Holiday Park, but this time rather than camp for just one night we booked a cabin. Lake Navarino itself is the body of water behind Waroona Dam and it is very popular for water skiing and freshwater fishing. What makes it a bit confusing is that there are two Waroona Dams – the other is also referred to as the Drakesbrook Dam. The Drakesbrook Dam is a delightful little spot with a a swimming beach, BBQ and toilet facilities, and a nature trail that takes you in search of the Noisy Scrub bird. Good luck with that as they are incredibly elusive and are more likely to be heard rather than seen. I did catch a glimpse of one in the understory along the walk trail but it was impossible to photograph.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
A tau emerald dragondly (Hemicordulia tau). Hemel Wetland Walk Trail, Waroona, Western Australia.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Only found in Western Australia the Western Xenica (Geitoneura minyas) can be found at the Hemel Wetlands.

 

Another nature trail in the locality is the Hamel Wetland Walk Trail in the small hamlet of Hemel just outside of Waroona. The wetland only stays wet over winter and spring and then dries out over summer. It is home to numerous species of frog including the Quacking Frog, Motorbike Frog, Slender Tree Frog, Clicking Froglet, Lea’s Froglet, Moaning Frog and the Banjo Frog. If fogs aren’t your jam then the wetland hosts a variety of bird species such as white Ibis, straw neck ibis Black Swans, Hardhead, Pacific Black Duck, Grey Teal, Musk Duck, Australasian Grebe, Hoary-headed Grebe, Black Cormorant, Pied Cormorant, and Black-shouldered Kites. Unfortunately the wetland had dried out for our visit and there wasn’t much bird activity about – just some rufous whistlers and red-tailed black cockatoos.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Red-tailed Black Cockatoo (Calptorthychus banksii). Hemel, Western Australia.

 

If you’re willing to travel a bit further then heading out to Preston Beach and Yalgorup National Park is worth it. The wetlands in the park are home to 67 species of water bird and have been listed as a Ramsar site. The forest within the park contains fauna including western grey kangaroos, emus, brush wallabies, brush-tailed possums, echidnas and bandicoots.

 

Helen at Preston Beach.

 

Waroona by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
The three bears made from straw bales. Waroona, Western Australia.

 

So if you find your self driving down the South Western Highway take some time to stop in Waroona and explore what it has to offer.

Surprise Visitors

Carnaby’s Black Cockatoo (Zanda [Calyptorhynchus] latirostris] called Ngolak by the Nyoongar of Western Australia.

The other I was sat in my office pouring over the incomprehensible bumf sent out from an insurance company when I heard a commotion outside. There was a load of raucous squawking coming from the back garden. I picked up a camera and ran out to see what was going on. To my delight it was a flock of Carnaby’s Black Cockatoos. They are classified as an endangered species but are commonly seen in the Wheatbelt. I get quite a thrill seeing flocks of them flying but it was taken to another level to see them in the garden.

 

Sitting in the peppercorn tree.

 

No sooner had they all settled than they were off again heading towards bigger gum trees on neighbouring properties.

 

… and then they were gone.

Garden Visitors

Silvereye by Paul Amyes on 500px.com

Silvereye, Zosterops lateralis. York, Western Australia.

 

We’re still getting visitors to the garden. Lately we’ve been getting half a dozen or so Silvereyes visit at around 4-5pm. They’re tricky things to photograph because they are so small (about 10cm beak to tail) and they move so erratically- think manic clockwork toy on speed and you’ll be in the ball park. Just before sundown we get a female rufous whistler pick over the mulch in the garden beds. I can hear the male in the peppercorn tree but I’ve not seen him.

 

Rufous Whistler by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
A female rufous whistler visits the garden.

 

The Nankeen Kestrels have been spending a lot of time on out TV aerial and the power pole on the street. They largely just sit and watch the paddock opposite. Occasionally they are digesting a recent meal. Every now and again we are treated to display of aerial acrobatics where the kestrel will hover over a spot and watch it carefully before diving at great speed to take its prey.

 

Martiet by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Nankeen kestrel (Falco cenchroides cenchroides), York, Western Australia.

 

Prey sighted now dive! Nankeen kestrel (Falco cenchroides cenchroides), York, Western Australia.

All Change

I like the changes in the seasons and particularly look forward to the arrival of autumn. In fact spring and autumn are what living here are all about – fantastic weather with near perfect temperatures.

Autumn Burn Off by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
The Autumn burn off in the fields of the Western Australian Wheatbelt has left its distinctive stripes on the landscape.

 

The farmers have launched into a frenzy of activity – the fields are being burnt in preparation for the next crop. They are hoping that the war in the Ukraine and the sanctions against Russia will bring about record wheat prices. That optimism is being tempered by rising costs of fuel, fertiliser and pesticides.  As usual for this time of year the valley fills with palls of smoke leading to some spectacular sunsets.

In the garden the bob tailed lizards are nowhere to be seen. While they don’t exactly hibernate they go into torpid state where they hide up and live off the fat reserves in their tails. The white browed babblers have upped sticks and moved to another garden and the only real activity is coming from the white-cheeked honeyeaters. They had a bit of a population explosion over summer so there are lots of adolescents  chasing one another around the garden.  This has led to some spectacular demonstrations of flying with some very close calls with windows and near misses while dodging around the rear veranda.  Just as dawn breaks lots of them sit on the fence outside my bedroom window and make a tuneless racket. What they lack in musical ability they make up for with enthusiasm.

 

White-cheeked Honeyeater by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
White-cheeked Honeyeater (Phylidonyris niger).

Yes I like autumn it marks the start of more activity out in nature.

BIF

White Faced Herron by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
BIF or bird in flight. White faced heron, Egretta novaehollandiae, Wilson Inlet, Denmark, Western Australia. Olympus EM1 mk I with Panasonic 100-400mm lens.

 

I’m not talking about the Oscars but Birds In Flight. I’m finding this a very troublesome aspect of nature photography. 

If you listen to bird photographers talk this is the holy grail and if you take a picture of a bird in a tree it is derisively called a bird on a stick and is seen to have no merit at all. In fact BIF is now considered such an important part of photography that with each new camera launch the manufacturers herald its new bird tracking autofocus capabilities. These cameras are now capable of shooting incredibly high frame rates in excess of 20 frames per second which encourages photographers to just machine gun the subject – the so called spray and pray – in the hope of capturing something interesting. So why do I feel this troublesome. Well this technology doesn’t come cheap and the fact is that you have to be seriously minted and committed to bird photography to afford the equipment. The Sony A1, the Nikon Z9 and the Canon R3 are all around $9-10,000 AUD. Slap on a suitable long fast prime lens like a 600mm f4 and you have a package that will set you back a cool $30,000 AUD. Predominantly I shoot with Olympus’ cameras and their newly released camera plus their top wildlife lens will set you back around $15,000. So as you can see it’s not for the faint hearted or the financially embarrassed. 

 

Yellow-billed Spoonbill (Platalea flavipes) by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
A Yellow-billed Spoonbill (Platalea flavipes) flying back to its nest on the Avon River. Canon EOS 550d with a Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8 IS L lens.

 

So does this state of affairs mean that unless you are wealthy you shouldn’t take up nature/wildlife photography? No because I happen to believe that it is the skill of the photographer that makes great photos and not the size of their bank account. Nothing beats going out into the field and spending time getting to know your subject and the environment they live in. The more time you spend out there the more picture taking opportunities you will have.

 

Yoondoordo by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
The Eastern Osprey (Pandion cristatus) is known to the Nyoongar people of the south west of Western Australia as yoondoordo. Oyster Bay, Lower King, Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 mk ii with Panasonic 100-400mm lens.

Secondly don’t obsess about equipment. Get what you can afford. Any camera with interchangeable lenses with a long lens is capable of excellent results. What matters is that you spend time with your camera and learn how it works. Eric Hoskins, 1908-91, was a pioneer in bird photography. He worked with what would now be considered very primitive – large format single shot cameras with no metering, no auto focusing and slow film emulsions (10 ISO) – yet he changed the face of bird photography with his use of flash and he enabled people to see birds in a way that they’d never seen before. Buy stuff second hand. Take advantage of the well heeled enthusiasts who have to have the latest and greatest. They change their equipment like I change my socks and often sell off perfectly good equipment for far less than they paid for it.

 

Great Egret In Flight by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Blue sky. Check. Bird in flight. Check. A great egret (Ardea alba modesta) flying over the Creery Wetlands Nature Reserve in Western Australia. Olympus OMD EM1 mk ii with Panasonic 100-400mm lens.

 

Thirdly there is more to nature/wildlife photography than birds in flight. I find endless pictures of birds flying across a blue sky boring. I like to see animal’s behaviour – feeding, building nests, rearing young, mating rituals etc. Show the animal in its environment.

 

Kooljak by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
Kooljak is the Nyoongar name for the Black swan (Cygnus atratus), Toodyay, Western Australia.

Fourthly you don’t have to go on expensive safaris to take pictures of animals. Thanks to the power of the internet what can be found in your backyard is interesting to people in different countries so capitalise on what you have close to home because the skills you learn will pay off in spades if you are able to go on a trip of a life time to somewhere exotic.

 

We Have Lift Off! by Paul Amyes on 500px.com
A Western Corella flies amongst the tree tops along the Avon River in York.

 

The shots below were taken at Tomato Lake which is in a park in one of Perth’s suburbs. The camera used was second hand with an older adapted lens with adequate autofocus. A few hours of being prepared to sit in mosquito ridden undergrowth by a lake gave me the chance to take some photos that I’m happy with and enjoy myself.

 

Ngalganing by Paul Amyes on 500px.com

An immature Nankeen Night Heron, , Nycticorax caledonicus subsp mannillenis.

 

Mimal by Paul Amyes on 500px.com

Australian Darter, often called Snake Bird, Anhinga melanogaster subsp. novaehollandiae.

 

Yellow-billed Spoonbill by Paul Amyes on 500px.com

Yellow-billed Spoonbill, Platalea regia.

What The Duck?

I was at Tomato Lake the other day watching the ducks while the Beloved Significant Other was working at attaining croquet excellence. After a while I came to the conclusion that in many ways people and ducks share similar behaviour. Like men the drake is up for rumpy pumpy at any time which can prove annoying for the females. When a drake gets in the mood for horizontal folk dancing he’ll start flirting. This basically involves getting the attention of a female. Drakes prefer to get amorous on the water and will shake their tail feather and bob their heads up and down. A bit like drunken males on the pull at the disco. If the hen doesn’t move in the general direction of away then the drake assumes that she is up for it and pulls out his really smooth moves. This starts with flicking water at the hen. My partner says adolescent boys do this to try and get attention from girls and it was really annoying. What happens next is a bit dependent on the species of duck, but the blue-billed ducks I was watching the other day have quite elaborate moves.

A male blue-billed duck on the cop. Stage one consists of pressing his head into the water and blowing bubbles.

The blue-billed duck has spectacular mating display. He’ll swim up to a hen and then he presses his head into the water and blows bubbles. Having done that the next stage is to flick his head backward throwing water about with his bill.  Then he’ll rise up out of the water with his back arched as if in spasm, with possibly his legs kicking water spray above his body. He’ll then have a bit of a shake check to see if his victim is still watching and then repeat the whole thing again. The human equivalent is when the bloke goes full on Travolta – you know he’s seen Saturday Night Fever, Grease, and Pulp Fiction and thinks he’s dead good at dancing. Now if the drake has been successful he’ll chase the hen and then jump her – she often gets completely submerged in the process. It’s a bit like some men think a nudge in the ribs is foreplay. Once over they straighten their feathers  the hen heads off to the reeds to  build a nest, lay her eggs and raise the young. The drake does a runner and chooses to hang out with his mates until another hen takes his fancy. There’s no child support payments for ducks. 

 

Then he’ll rise up out of the water…

 

… and arch his back as if in spasm…

 

… he then starts chucking water all over place.

Was the drake I was watching on a promise? No the hen swam off very quickly. She was obviously out of his league.

 

Unfortunately the object of his affections wasn’t impressed and legged it.

That Was Then This Is Now

The Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro compared to its newer variant the Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Both lenses have their lens hoods attached.

Back in the annals of time, well 1999 to be precise, Sigma released the Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX Macro lens. Twenty one years later they released the Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN Art Macro lens. So let’s see what has changed in macro lens design.

As always click on the images to see them larger.


TLDR

.


Physical Attributes

Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX Macro

The Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens in Canon EF mount. The lens has no weather sealing.

 

As I said above this lens was introduced back in 1999 and it was well received by reviewers and users alike. In fact it cemented Sigma’s reputation for producing excellent macro lenses. One of my photography lecturers reckoned that this was one of the best lenses he’d used so I bought the lens new in 2003 to use with my then Canon EOS 3 and 30 and it remained in regular use until 2016. I’ve used it for macro, product shots, still life, portraits, fine art reproduction and copywork and of course close ups of flowers.

The lens was designed with film use in mind and was made available in the following mounts:

  • Canon EF
  • Minolta A
  • Nikon F
  • Pentax K
  • Sigma SA

Pick up the lens and it feels very well made. It is light by modern standards but it has a nice heft to it. The lens barrel is metal – none of your plastic composites here – and the lens mount is a chrome plated brass affair. The front lens element is recessed 25mm into the lens barrel and it is ribbed to prevent reflections and acts as shallow lens hood. Combine it with the included metal lens hood and it is virtually impossible  to induce flare. The lens hood screws firmly into place on the lens’ front filter thread and is threaded to take 77mm filters which is a neat idea as it makes it possible to quickly attach filters without having to take the lens hood off.

The finish is the peculiar matt black finish that Sigma had for all their EX range of lenses with a gold ring at the end of the focus ring and the text done in a mixture of white and gold. The focusing ring is 35mm wide and has ribbed rubber to aid grip. In autofocus mode the ring spins freely, but pull that ring back and flip the AF switch and it has a nice smooth 270º throw taking you from infinity to 31cm. The lens barrel extends as you focus closer by 50mm and there are magnification scales marked on the barrel extension for both manual and auto focusing. This means you can quickly set the lens to a desired magnification ratio. It is to my mind still one of the best implementations of manual focus on an autofocus macro lens. The lens motor makes quite a bit of noise and it can’t be called quick by any stretch of the imagination, however, macro lenses are not noted for their speed of use.

 

The Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens at full extension to give 1:1 magnification. Note the magnification ratios marked on the lens barrel. This makes manual setting of the lens for specific ratios a breeze.

 

Behind the focusing ring is a clear panel over a focusing scale in both feet and metres. There are two switches on the right side of the lens. The first is a focus limiter which speeds up auto focus by preventing the lens racking back and forth through the whole focus range. The second switch is the previously mentioned focus mode switch. Both are very positive in their action.

Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN Art Macro Lens

Sigma’s 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens attached a Sony A7Rii.

 

Announced in September 2020 the DG DN is available in Sony FE and Panasonic/Leica/Sigma L mounts. It is part of Sigma’s Art series and so shares the same gloss black finish with understated white graphics and lettering. No 1990’s gold bling here, just a minimalist workman like appearance. The body is a combination of metal and Sigma’s Thermally Stable Composite a kind of plastic with thermal expansion properties the same as aluminium. There are a number of ribbed panels to facilitate a secure grip. It’s great to see that Sigma has not abandoned the chrome plated brass  lens mount – it’s a proven method and lasts a long time. Pick the lens up and the first thing you notice is the weight. It is very heavy for its size. The 17 lens elements really make their presence felt when compared to the EX’s 10.

 

Both lenses are focused at their minimum focusing distance to give a maximum magnification ratio of 1:1. The DG DN focus internally and remains the same length while the EX’s barrel extends.

 

So weight and appearance aside how else does the DG DN differ from its distant ancestor the EX? Well the DG DN is 40mm longer, but it is important to remember that it is made for mirrorless cameras with a shorter lens flange distance than DSLRs. Put a Sigma MC-11 on the EX and they are virtually the same length. Another difference is that the new DG DN focuses internally – there’s no extending barrel and this will help with the weather sealing. The large ribbed focusing ring is of the fly-by-wire type, there’s no pulling it back to engage a manual focus mechanism. Consequently there are no hard stops and you get no feedback as you focus other than the image in the EVF or on the back panel. Macro photography is an area where you do use manual focus a lot and using it on the DG DN is not a very pleasant or positive experience to my mind. 

 

The controls on the Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens include an AF/MF switch, a reprogrammable focus lock button, a focus limiter switch and a switch to de-click the aperture ring.

 

There are a lot more controls on the newer lens:-

  • an AF MF switch
  • a focus lock button that can be reprogrammed
  • a focus limiter switch with 3 settings – 0.295 to 0.5m, 0.5m to infinity, full range.
  • a switch for de-clicking the aperture ring
  • an aperture ring
  • a locking switch for the aperture ring

 

The aperture ring on the Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Not only can it be de-clicked it can also be locked in the auto position for those who would prefer to chasnge aperture using camera dials.

 

The focus limiter switch has three settings. 0.295-0.5m macro, 0.5m to infinity normal range, and a full range option.

 

So let’s have a quick gander at the specs for both lenses.

 

 

Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX Macro lens Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN Art Macro lens
Focal length 105mm 105mm
Angle of view 24º (on full frame) 23.3º
Maximum aperture f2.8 f2.8
Miniumum aperture f45 for Canon, Sigma, and Minolta

f32 for Nikon and Pentax

f22
Filter size 58mm on the lens body

77mm on the lens hood

62mm
Stabilisation No No
Maximum magnification 1:1 1:1
Minimum focusing distance 31cm from the film plane 29.5cm (from the sensor plane)
Focusing modes Auto and manual Auto and manual
Optical construction 10 elements in 9 groups with 3 special low dispersion elements 17 elements in 12 groups with 1  special low dispersion element
Aperture blades 8 9 (rounded)
Weather sealing No “Dust and splash proof construction”
Weight 456g (Canon EF mount) 710g
Dimensions 95mm (h) x 74mm ⌀ 135.6mm (h) x 74mm ⌀

Optical Performance

Sharpness

A comparison between the 1999 Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens and the 2021 Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Aperture: f 2.8

This is where we really start to what has changed in terms of lens design over the years. Wide open at f2.8 the DGDN is sharper and more contrasty in the centre of the frame. The corners are sharp but the contrast is lower. The EX on the other hand is softer and has less contrast in the centre and the corners are not only softer but display prominent chromatic aberration and have a warm tinted vignetting. Older Sigma lenses were known for having a warmer look than other brands and it is clearly visible.

 

A comparison between the 1999 Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens and the 2021 Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Aperture: f 4

 

A comparison between the 1999 Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens and the 2021 Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Aperture: f 5.6

By f5.6 the corners of the DGDN have improved considerably and the centre is even sharper. The centre of the frame for the EX has improved but not to the same extent as that of the DGDN. The corners of the EX are still quite soft and still exhibit vignetting.

 

A comparison between the 1999 Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens and the 2021 Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Aperture: f 8

 

At f8 the DGDN really hits its stride and produces its best optical performance with both the centre and the corners having excellent sharpness and contrast. The EX has reached its best centre performance but it is still not as good as its younger sibling. The corners have improved slightly but vignetting is still present.

At the aperture of f11 the DGDN’s performance remains the same as it was at f8 in both the centre and the corners of the frame. The EX now turns in its best performance but some vignetting remains.

 

A comparison between the 1999 Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro lens and the 2021 Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens. Aperture: f 32

At f16 diffraction is taking effect on both lenses. Interestingly the EX will stop down to f45 but you wouldn’t want to use it as it looks like someone has smeared vaseline over the front lens element.

Chromatic Aberration 

Chromatic aberration is the failure of a lens to focus all colours at the same point and there are two types:-

  1. Axial or longitudinal chromatic aberration – this where different wave lengths of light are focused at different distances from the lens. Generally it can be reduced by stopping down thereby increasing the depth of field so that all the wavelengths fall with acceptable focus. This is very hard to remove in post processing.
  2. Transverse or lateral chromatic aberration – different wavelengths of light are focused at different positions in the focal plane. It does not occur in the centre of an image and increases as you move out to the edges. It is not effected by stopping down, but can be removed in post.

The DGDN is exceptional well controlled for both kinds of chromatic aberration and even at magnifications of 200% I could not observe any. The EX is really showing its age here as both types can be seen. The transverse chromatic aberration is very prominent.

Flare

 

The Sigma 105mm DGDN shows good resistance to flare. In this extreme case we can see some evidence of veiled flasre and a little reflection.

 

The EX despite having that recessed front element that acts as a de facto lens hood suffers badly from halation, veiling flare, and reflections when specular light sources were in the frame. The DGDN has better lens coatings which means that the halation and reflected glare is minimal and there is no halation. This means that there’s little loss of contrast.

Bokeh

Sigma 105mm f2.8 DGDN Macro lens bokeh test.

 

 

 

 

 

Both lenses at f2.8 have nice round bokeh balls in the centre of the frame and at the edges exhibit that elliptical cats eye effect. The tonal transitions are nice and smooth, there is no busyness or swirly effect. At f4 the EX is starting to develop polygonal balls while those of the DGDN are still nice and round. At f11 the bokeh balls in the corners of the DGDN are starting to develop into sun stars and the effect on the EX is more profound. The 9 rounded aperture blades are producing much more pleasing bokeh effects than the 8 straight ones of the EX.


Autofocus

Continuous autofocus with the Sigma 105mm f2.8 mounted on a Canon EOS 6d.

 

Autofocus is where there has been an enormous improvement in performance over the last 22 years. The EX when mounted on the Sony A7r ii with either the Metabones V Smart Adapter or the Sigma MC-11 just won’t autofocus. When you switch the camera on the lens racks through its entire focus range (depending on where the limiter is set) and then does nothing. So to test the AF performance I had to mount it on a Canon EOS6d which wasn’t known for its blistering AF speed. I shot several sequences with the focus limiter on at f2.8 of me walking slowly towards the camera with it set Continuous AF and obtained a nit rate of between 70-75%. Video AF was a non starter and it just would not find focus. To be fair the CAF of the 6d in video mode is pretty lacklustre. With the DGDN mounted on the Sony A7r ii the stills burst rate for AF averaged out at 94% which is pretty impressive. The DGDN handled the video AF test with aplomb, it was smooth and positive keeping up with me moving about in the frame. The AF was noisy and was picked up by the shotgun microphone mounted in the camera hot-shoe. Speaking of noise the EX was incredibly noisy.

 

Continuous auto focus using the Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN macro lens on a Sony A7rii.

 


Conclusion

Both lenses mounted on Sony bodies. The EX is mounted via the Sigma MC-11 lens adapter.

 

This should really come as no surprise, time has marched on and the advances in lens design are easily apparent.The Sigma 105mm f2.8 EX macro was considered a very good lens in its day, and even now it is remembered fondly on photographic forums. The DGDN is just at another level of performance both in terms of optics and auto focusing. The EX while being optically suited to a number of tasks its AF performance let it down when it came to anything that moved quickly or erratically. The DGDN on the other hand can be confidently used as a general purpose short telephoto with a wide variety of subjects as well as being a dedicated macro lens. The only area in which the EX is superior to the DGDN is in the handling department. The manual focusing experience and the ability to pre-set specific magnification ratios makes the lens a joy to use manually. The DGDN is clearly aimed at the autofocus only photographer. A great shame.

So if you have a Sony FE or one of the  offerings from the “L mount alliance” then the lens is worth a look at. Well it is your only option in L mount. It is also a worthy competitor to the Sony 90mm f2.8 FE macro OSS G at a cheaper price.

 


Sample Images

 

Looking through the Olympus OM Zuiko 135mm f2.8 lens at an Olympus OM 40.

 

Lime slice oozing juice.

 

Cream runs down over a strawberry.

 

Where there’s smoke there’s fire.

 

Australian one and two dollar coins.

 

Sigma 105mm f2.8 DG DN Macro lens auto focus test. Auto focus tracking a subject walking towards the camera while the lens is wide open at f2.8.

 

Darth Vader divided by the light.

 

Bee feeding on lavender flowers.

 

A bee feeding on a daisy.

 

A ladybird looking for aphids.

 

Clubbed Spider Orchid, Caladenia longiclavata. Mount Observation, Western Australia.

 

Custard Orchid, Thelymitra villosa. Mount Observation, Western Australia.

 

Known by a variety of names the dancing spider orchid (Caladenia discoidea) is also known as the antelope orchid and sometimes the bee orchid. St. Ronan’s Nature Reserve, Western Australia.

Sigma MC-11 Lens Adapter

The Sigma MC-11 adapter allows certain Sigma EF lenses to be used on Sony E mount bodies while retaining autofocus and image stabilisation.

This is the second part of a series of articles on upgrading camera equipment on a budget. Part 1 can be found here.

I’ll deal with the Sigma adapter first because I got that to work with just one lens – my Sigma 150-600mm F5-6.3 DG OS HSM Lens – Contemporary lens. 


TLDR


Construction

The Sigma MC-11 comes in two different versions:

  • Sigma SA mount to Sony FE
  • Canon EF mount to Sony FE

Obviously as I own Canon EF mount lenses this is about the EF version. Sigma state that their adapter is for use with their Global Vision lenses which comprises of three lens lines:

  1. Art
  2. Contemporary 
  3. Sport

As of the time of writing there are 44 Sigma lenses that are compatible with the adapter and these allow users to access all the auto focus modes on Sony E mount cameras. This is important to me as I want to be able to use the 150-600 for bird photography.

The Sigma 150-600mm F5-6.3 DG OS HSM Contemporary lens is one of the lenses that is compatible with the Sigma MC-11 lens adapter.

 

The first thing you notice when you pick up the MC-11 is that it is very solid and well made. The body is of metal construction and the lens mounts are chromium plated brass. Disappointingly there are no weather seals. On the body is a USB port behind a soft plastic flap and on the opposite side is the lens release button. Just by that is a tiny LED light which is very hard to see when it is off. The purpose of the light is to inform you about how well the lens attached will work it does this through one of four states:

  1. Constant green – the lens is compatible
  2. Flashing green – you need to update the lens firmware 
  3. Flashing orange – the adapter firmware needs updating
  4. No light – the lens isn’t compatible 

The light only comes on for 2-3 seconds when you switch on the camera.

Speaking of firmware updates to do this you will need to download the Sigma Optimization Pro software from Sigma’s website. To update the adapter just needs a USB cable, for lenses you will need the Sigma Dock UD-01. I find it somewhat frustrating that you can’t update the lens firmware through the MC-11 adapter. The dock isn’t expensive to buy although in Australia the retail price varies between $80 to $120 AUD so it pays to shop around. Luckily there seem to be plenty for sale second hand on EBay for about $40. I ended up updating both the adapter and lens firmware and the whole process was very straightforward.

 

 

 


In Use

Before I updated the firmware I found that there was difficulty in acquiring focus when shooting in low light, backlit situations and with subjects in undergrowth. Once upgraded things worked a lot better. I experimented with the settings on the camera by setting up two custom modes. Custom mode 1 was in shutter priority with the shutter speed set at 1/500 sec, Auto ISO, Auto Focus Continuous, Lock on AF with a medium sized flexible spot and the frame rate was set to low speed continuous. Custom mode 2 was in shutter priority with the shutter speed set at 1/2000, Auto ISO, Auto Focus Continuous, lock on flexible spot large and high speed continuous drive. Both modes had the following parameters set:

  • Phase Detect Area – on
  • Pre AF – off
  • Priority set in AFC – balanced emphasis 
  • AF with shutter – on
  • AF drive speed – fast
  • AF tracking sensitivity – high

With birds in trees that weren’t moving too quickly I found that I was getting a hit rate of around 90%. With more erratic moving birds my hit rate dropped to 36% when I was using my custom mode 2. When I switched to mode 1 the hit rate improved to 85%. Photographing my dog running towards me both custom modes acquired focus very quickly, but the results from custom mode two weren’t very consistent fluctuating between 60 to 85%. In custom mode 1 I got very consistent results at 85%. When shooting birds in flight I found that I didn’t get a single shot with critical focus which was disappointing to say the least.

 

The video performance of the A7r II and the Sigma 150-600 was surprising. Shooting wide open at the short end AF performance is good, it is quick and confident. At the long end the AF is a bit slower but it does acquire focus and lock on. What is very apparent is the noise of the lens motor, it is quite loud and would mean that any sound would have to be recorded using an external microphone.


Conclusion

 

The Sigma MC-11 adapter allows certain Sigma EF lenses to be used on Sony E mount bodies while retaining autofocus and image stabilisation.

In practice it would certainly seem that shooting at higher frame rates the autofocus struggles to keep up and dropping the frame rate improves the hit rate considerably. Whether using this combination is a good idea depends very much on your expectations and what you want. If you want the performance of a Sony native lens then you are better off getting that. But if you already have the lens and want to change from a Canon DSLR to a Sony full frame mirrorless camera and you are shooting birds in trees, scrub, on the ground or on water then this works very well. For birds in flight you’ll want either a full Sony set up or a full Canon set up.


Sample Images

 

 

Menekedang called the Red-capped Robin (Petroica goodenovii) by white colonialists.

 

Melkullya called the Yellow-billed Spoonbill (Platalea flavipes) by white colonialists.

 

Menekedang called the Red-capped Robin (Petroica goodenovii) by white colonialists.

 

Red Wattle bird (Anthochaera carunculata subsp. woodwardi) known to the Nyoongar people as wodjalok. Yellagonga Regional Park.

 

Three wise corellas – hear no evil, see no evil, and sorry my mouth is full. Yellagona Regional Park, Western Australia.

 

Manyt or the Western Corella (Cacatua pastinator subsp. derbyi). Yellagona Regional Park, Western Australia.

 

Dillabirt, known to non Nyoonga people as the Magpie-lark (Grallina cyanoleuca). Yellagonga Regional Park.

 

Melkullya or Yellow-billed Spoonbills, Platalea flavipes, amongst the paperbarks on Lake Joondalup in Yellangonga Regional Park.

 

Melkullya or Yellow-billed Spoonbills, Platalea flavipes, feeding at Lake Joondalup in Yellangonga Regional Park.

 

The eponymous Willie Wagtail, Rhipidura leucophrys leucophrys. Yellagonga Regional Park, Western Australia.

 

Despite their small size the Silvereye, Zosterops lateralis, has an incredibly loud birdsong. Yellagonga Regional Park, Western Australia.

 

An Australian Pelican (Pelecanus conspicillatus) feeding on Lake Joondalup in Yellagonga Regional Park.

 

A white-faced heron looks out from its tree top perch over Horse Swamp. Whiteman Park, Western Australia.

 

Western Grey Kangaroo, macropus fuliginosus, Whiteman Park, Western Australia.

Adapt Or…

…go with out.

Lately I’ve been reading a lot of how photography has become really expensive. Sony released the A1 at $10,000 AUD, Canon are due to release the R3 at the same amount. As for lenses well the latest fast primes are priced in the stratosphere. But here’s the news – photography is very expensive if you treat it as technological proliferation. If you insist on having the latest and greatest you are going to have to pay. But do you really need the latest and greatest? Do you honestly need 30 fps shutter speed? 8K video? 4K 10 bit 4:2:2 video at 120fps? Fifteen stop dynamic range? Only you can say what you need, but I’m guessing that like 90% of photography enthusiasts you don’t. I know I don’t. Let’s face it the greatest photos of the Twentieth Century were taken with basic equipment. The vast majority on cameras that didn’t have autofocus or built in metering.

 

The back bone of my professional kit has been full frame Canon DSLRs since the launch of the original Canon 5d in 2005. Here is my 6d with my lenses.

 

Maybe you’re a bit like me. You’ve been doing the photography thing for quite a while. You were a happy SLR user in the days of film and when the digital revolution took place you patiently waited for the affordable DSLRs to arrive on the market and you made the switch. You bought into a system, acquired some nice lenses and upgraded the camera body as needed. But now something has come along that threatens that. That something is the advent of the mirrorless camera. These new wonder cameras are technological marvels with their WYSIWYG viewfinders and their information overlays, the incredible image stabilisation systems, the convergence with video, and the list of features goes on and on. The fly in the ointment is that to achieve this the manufacturers abandoned their lens mounts and developed new ones that could take advantage of the lack of the mirror box. This is where the expense comes in because to make the switch you have to spend big on not only a new camera body but also on new lenses. When I went digital I went Canon and over the years I ended up with a modest kit based around an EOS 6d, a 24-70 f4, a 70-200 f2.8, a 100mm f2.8 macro, a 50mm f1.8, and a Sigma 150-600mm. To get the equivalent kit based around an R6 body would cost me a few dollars under $20,000. That is a phenomenal amount of money. My wallet puckers up just thinking about it. So I looked at the more wallet friendly option of the R6, a Canon EOS-R Mount Adapter to adapt my EF lenses to the new RF mount, and a Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM as my old 50mm f1.8 wouldn’t cope with CAF needed for video. The damage would be just under $5000 which while more wallet friendly was still more than I really wanted to spend. The other problem is that the  Canon EOS-R Mount Adapter is currently back ordered here in Australia at the time of writing with no word on when stock would become available. Bugger!

 

The Olympus OMD EM1 mk ii with the Olympus m.Zuiko 60mm f2.8 macro lens.

 

Time to reappraise the problem. As regular readers will know I went mirrorless about ten years ago with the Micro Four Thirds system and this is what does the bulk of my work. But I wanted a larger sensor and higher resolution for certain situations. A bit like when I was running Canon  35mm SLRs in conjunction with a Pentax 645n II. So m43 gives enough quality for about 80% of my needs. I wanted auto focus, 5-6 fps frame rate, in body image stabilisation, 4K video , and of course full frame. So the Canon R and RP were  immediately excluded. Then it occurred to me that if I was going to have to adapt my Canon glass to use on an R series camera why not consider adapting them to another make such as Sony. Now again regular readers will be aware that I acquired a Sony A7r with which to use my old collection of manual focus Olympus OM mount and Voigtländer M mount lenses. So perhaps going Sony was the solution. From what I read the Sony A7r was not a suitable candidate for this because of its contrast based auto focus so it was going to have to be 2nd generation cameras or later. New prices were still out of my league, but secondhand looked promising. I also found that the secondhand prices on the Metabones Canon EF to Sony E-mount T Smart Adapter (Mark V) and the Sigma MC-11  EF-Mount Lenses to Sony E mount were less than half the price of new. To keep within my $2000 AUD budget I decided to go for a Sony A7r II as I wouldn’t need to buy extra batteries as I already had loads for my A7r. So it was just a case of searching and eventually I came up trumps and found an A7r II with less than 50 shutter actuations, a Sigma and a Metabones adapter that kept me within my budget.

 

The Olympus OM Zuiko 35mm f2 mounted on a Sony A7r.

 

So did this end up a workable solution? Well I’m not going to review the A7r II as that has been done to death on the internet. But, suffice to say it gave everything I was looking for in a full frame mirrorless camera. The next two parts will look at how well the adapters worked with my lenses and the A7r II.

 

The Sony A7rii with the Sigma MC-11 and Metabobes V EF to FE lens adapters.

 

Mount your Canon EF lenses to your Sony A7rii using the Metabones V Smart Adapter.

 

Will the Sony A7rii work well with my Canon lenses? Is it time to say “Adios EOS”?